On a Friday morning in October 1923, the Globe Milling Company raised its price for wheat at Schiller by three cents a hundred pounds. Its neighbour at the siding, the Zaring Grain Company, matched the raise and added five cents more. By the next day buyers all over Power County were sending men out in cars after the crop, and the farmers of Arbon Valley, whose wheat went out through Schiller, were in the middle of it.
The American Falls Press put the story on its front page on October 18: “Fifty thousand dollars was excitedly stuffed in the pockets of Power county farmers Friday and Saturday when wheat buyers engaged in a spirited bid for milling wheat and for two days beat the world in the market they created for wheat.”
A siding 26 miles out
The valley had no railroad of its own. Arbon, Pauline and Crystal had belonged to Oneida County until 1913 and now lay in Power County, and their dry-farm wheat left in sacks for sidings on the Oregon Short Line. Schiller, the one that served them, stood about a mile west of today’s Bannock Peak Truck Stop on I-86, as the history of Pauline and West Fork places it.
At Pauline the grain was gathered first at the warehouse across from the school. A year before the bidding, in November 1922, the Press gave E. C. England of Pauline’s count of grain taken in at “the warehouse” during October as 29,008 bushels. Two weeks later it put that right: the figure was 29,008 sacks, or about 60,000 bushels, at a place it now called the Arbon Warehouse, most likely the Pauline building.
Two days of bidding
The Friday and Saturday of the story were October 12 and 13. Over those two days, the Press said, buyers took about a third of a million bushels, and the price climbed overnight from $1.50 to $1.75 a hundred. Wheat weighs 60 pounds to the bushel, so the top price worked out to $1.05 a bushel, six cents above what Portland was paying.
Power County wheat had commanded a premium ever since 1907, the paper explained, because the mills wanted it. This jump of 25 cents a hundred was something else, “due to rivalry,” and by the paper’s account it began at the valley’s own shipping point:
The price-raising impulse seems to have first manifested itself at Schiller, the shipping point for Pauline, Arbon and Crystal growers.
From those first few cents the contest drew in the Sperry people and spread through the Bannock and Rockland valleys, Bannock being the older name for the Arbon valley. Bids by telephone and calls by the firms’ men in person, according to what the Press judged “apparently reliable reports,” put somewhere near $50,000 in growers’ hands. On Saturday morning the price slipped back to $1.50, held there for perhaps a quarter of an hour, and went back up to $1.75. By Monday it had come to rest at $1.55 for dark hard red winter.
The buyers did not pretend to have come out ahead. They told the paper they had taken all the wheat they wanted at the high prices, owned to their losses and seemed content with the volume of trade. How much of the third of a million bushels came out of Arbon Valley, the Press did not say.
Freighting to the switch
Selling the wheat was one thing; getting it to the siding took all winter. That season the Press printed news sent in by pupils of the county’s rural schools, and the children kept watch on the hauling. In mid-November a Pauline-area column counted about twelve trucks hauling “out of here,” every one heavily loaded; the site’s Stories weigh the valley’s first trucks. A Pauline pupil set down the trade in one sentence: “Mr. T. D. Lusk is freighting that means going to and from the switch and the switch means Schiller.” The Lusk family history takes him to be Dave Lusk of Pauline.
Snowstorms halted the trucks in early December, an Arbon school column reported. A week on, the Pauline pupils wrote that the trucks were idle for another reason: Schiller was “filled up.” The week after, the freighting had resumed. On January 3, 1924, the Valley View column noted that Heber Wood had taken a load of wheat to Schiller.
Spring came and the haul went on. In early March the Armstrong school, between Pauline and Crystal, sent word that E. P. Armstrong, M. J. Crump, F. Barnett and R. Wheatley had gone to Schiller with a load of wheat, and the Valley View pupils wrote that Ralph and Lee Hatfield were freighting grain from Pauline to Schiller. On March 13 came the one hard figure the children recorded: “1617 sacks were taken out of the warehouse at Pauline last Monday and freighted to the railroad down at Schiller, 26 miles away.” At roughly two bushels a sack, that was better than 3,000 bushels. In lines the scan has jumbled, the same column appears to say the freighting stopped again for want of room at Schiller.
Seven days later Pauline was hauling once more. Then, on March 27, the Pauline column reported, “The grain company has stopped hauling grain to Schiller.” The same column added that “Bob Swim has been freighting with ten head of horses.” That was Bob Swim, the husband of Nell Roper of Pauline. The children did not name the grain company, and no column says when the last of the 1923 crop left Pauline.
Storage of their own
Within a few years the growers were thinking about warehouses of their own. In late February 1927 the Salt Lake Tribune reported that they had met at Pauline and chosen a committee to study a warehousing organization; its next report named the members as Ed England, William Allard, T. H. Hill, Carl Rudeen and J. H. Keeler. On March 7 the committee, with Dave Lusk and others, met at the Pocatello chamber of commerce, County Agent L. E. Tillotson in the chair. The Tribune’s account survives only as a scrambled scan, but it seems to say they had been quoted a price on the warehouse at Schiller, owned at the time by a Strauss company of Portland, Oregon. Whether they bought it, no paper found so far has said.
By then the valley’s wheat was also going to Michaud, on the railroad west of Pocatello. In August 1928 the Tribune reported more Power County red wheat coming out of Arbon Valley than ever before, so much that even an enlarged Michaud warehouse could not hold it and a good share would be stacked outdoors. A year later Michaud had a new warehouse of 110,000 bushels, nearly half full already, filled with sacked wheat the Arbon Valley farmers hauled in and sent on to the Pocatello mill as it was needed.
The bidding at Schiller was over in two days. Moving the wheat it bought took the rest of the winter and well into spring.
The original article
American Falls Press, October 18, 1923, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
$50,000 STUFFED INTO POCKETS OF [illegible]
RIVAL GRAIN BUYERS [illegible] AND BOOST PRICE [illegible]
Third of a Million Bushels of Wheat Purchased Friday and Saturday—Must Have Power Co. Wheat.
Fifty thousand dollars was excitedly stuffed in the pockets of Power county farmers Friday and Saturday when wheat buyers engaged in a spirited bid for milling wheat and for two days beat the world in the market they created for wheat. In two days they purchased a third of a million bushels at $1.05 a bushel, six cents more than was being paid at Portland and within three cents of the open market at Chicago. The price went from $1.50 a hundred to $1.75 a hundred over night. There has been spirited bidding in years past but nothing to equal the rivalry created last week when one large operator uped the price 25 cents a hundred and started men out in cars to get the wheat. The challenge was instantly accepted by competitive buyers.
Growers were paid more for their wheat here than at any other primary shipping point, and more than dealers received at any market, freight deducted.
Hard red winter brought $1.05 per bushel at American Falls and 99 cents at Portland. The Chicago market was $1.08, but this included freight and dealers profit. The freight on a bushel of wheat from American Falls to Chicago is approximately 27 cents, so American Falls dealers, selling on the Chicago market, would have to get $1.32 to break even, without any handling charges.
Rivalry Boosts Price.
The quality of Power county wheat has always brought a premium, and it is not unusual for growers here to receive from five to ten cents a bushel more than is paid elsewhere in southern Idaho, due to an active milling demand. This has been true since 1907, when wheat growing began to assume importance here. There has not been a time this year when American Falls dealers could ship to any general market and break even. An active milling demand has enabled them to pay the price. The sensational raise of last week of 25 cents a hundred was however, due to rivalry.
The price-raising impulse seems to have first manifested itself at Schiller, the shipping point for Pauline, Arbon and Crystal growers. The Zaring Grain Company and the Globe Milling Company have warehouses at Schiller. Friday morning the Globe raised the price 3 cents a hundred. Zaring met the raise and went 5 cents better. From this small beginning a spirited buying contest began that soon involved the Sperry people and extended throughout the Bannock and Rockland valleys.
Growers Reap Harvest.
Telephone bids and personal visits from representatives of the competing firms, according to apparently reliable reports, resulted in contracting approximately a third of a million bushels and brought growers a benefit of somewhere near $50,000.
Saturday morning the price dropped to $1.50 per hundred, but it remained there only about fifteen minutes when it again skyrocketed to $1.75 and remained there. Monday morning the price dropped to $1.55 for dark hard red winter and has remained steady at that figure.
Dealers Admit Losses.
Dealers freely admit that they bought all the wheat they wanted at the high prices. They confess to losses, but accept them philosophically. They apparently take satisfaction in the volume of business done, and forget the unpleasant features.
Sources
- American Falls Press, November 16, 1922, page 8
- American Falls Press, November 30, 1922, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 18, 1923, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 15, 1923, page 8
- American Falls Press, November 29, 1923, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 6, 1923, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 13, 1923, page 6
- American Falls Press, December 20, 1923, page 2
- American Falls Press, January 3, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 6, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 6, 1924, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 20, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- Salt Lake Tribune, February 27, 1927, page 25
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 8, 1927, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, August 26, 1928, page 31
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 2, 1929, page 10
