Arbon Valley sent close to a million bushels of wheat to market each year in the early 1930s, and every bushel had to leave the valley on wheels. By the spring of 1934 the road that carried it north across the Fort Hall Indian Reservation had all but given out.
On March 20, 1934, the Salt Lake Telegram reported from Boise that Governor C. Ben Ross was heading to Pocatello to talk with A. L. Wathen of the federal Indian Service, also known as the Indian Bureau, about a highway across the reservation that would open the valley to its markets. The road was there already, the governor said. It had been laid out years before, but hauling “nearly a million bushels of wheat annually” over it had ruined it, and it would have to be built again.
Thirty miles to the railroad
The valley had never had a railroad. In July 1918 the American Falls Press figured the season’s crop at close to half a million bushels and noted that all of it would go to Michaud, on the Oregon Short Line, a haul of twenty-five to thirty-five miles. One route to Pocatello climbed over the mountains by way of Mink Creek. That was the Bannock highway, which the Salt Lake Tribune described in 1933 as the road that “connects Pocatello with Arbon valley,” and the Arbon stage in Mink Creek follows it. Much of the grain took the other way, north down Bannock Creek and over reservation land to the sidings at Michaud and Schiller, between Pocatello and American Falls.
The heavy loads tore that road apart. In its issue of December 28, 1922, the Press announced that three and a half miles of it in highway district number one would be graveled starting the next Monday, under the district engineer, Irvin Allred. Every wheat season left the road badly rutted, the paper said, and the gravel would go first on the worst stretch. Twenty or twenty-one four-horse teams, every one supplied by people living in the district, were to do the hauling, so the work would help as many families as possible. The gravel came from a newly opened pit on Bannock Creek, on Indian land, with the Fort Hall agent’s permission. The first state highway tells how the new highway district had set out to gravel the Bannock Creek road back in 1919. In March 1929 Pocatello chamber of commerce leaders took up with Congressman Addison T. Smith the idea of “a government appropriation to improve the Michaud to Arbon road.”
The governor’s inspection
The day after the Telegram’s report, the Associated Press described the inspection. The governor, Wathen, the Indian Service’s attorney Jerry Humphreys of Denver, its supervising engineer L. M. Holt of Salt Lake City and local officials had gone over the stretch of reservation the new road would cross. The plan called for a 20-mile highway linking Arbon Valley farmers with the railroads. Heavy farm hauling and no upkeep had left the old market road “almost impassable,” the AP said, and Wathen was reported to regard the plan “with favor.”
No report names the route, though a 20-mile highway over the reservation toward the railroads was most likely the Bannock Creek road. None of them records what the Shoshone and Bannock people of Fort Hall thought of a highway through their land.
A promise, then a refusal
Senator William E. Borah came through Pocatello by train on September 5, 1935, bound home for Boise. Men from the Pocatello and Blackfoot chambers of commerce met him at the depot. Their main business was the Indian Service’s irrigation program under the WPA, the New Deal work-relief agency, including the Fort Hall irrigation project. But Borah also told them, according to the Tribune, that the proposed road program for Arbon Valley would get more of his attention. Its outlook was good, he said, and he expected word from Washington on it once he got to Boise.
The word, when it came the next June, was no. A Washington dispatch of June 11, 1936, carried in the Deseret News the following day, said Superintendent Fred A. Gross of the Fort Hall reservation, in the capital with a delegation, had been told that the “white farmers” seeking Indian Bureau funds for the Arbon Valley road would have to find the money elsewhere. The only copy found is scrambled together with other columns in the scan. Pieces of it appear to set the cost at $150,000 and to say white farmers would receive 95 per cent of the benefit, perhaps the bureau’s reason, but the full text cannot be made out.
$240,000 for a highway
On April 13, 1939, Senator Clark of Idaho moved to amend the agricultural appropriations bill with added funds for blister rust control, reseeding, forest watersheds, predatory animal control and highways. One of his items, the Tribune said, was $240,000 for a highway through Arbon Valley to bring the area’s farm products to the railroad sidings. Which road he had in mind, the paper did not say.
That same week the Tribune reported the death of Irvin Allred, the engineer who had directed the 1922 graveling. He was found dead in his overturned car on the night of April 11, a mile east of American Falls, at the age of 58. He had served as Power County surveyor ever since the county was formed in 1913 (until then Arbon had belonged to Oneida County) and was also engineer for a Power County road district that included part of the Arbon Valley route. The coroner found no visible injury serious enough to have killed him, and a heart attack was suspected.
The papers read for this post do not say whether Clark’s $240,000 came through, or when and how the road north was finally rebuilt, and in all those years they named not one of the valley farmers who pushed for it. The first oiled road traces the paving that came later, and the Pauline and West Fork history describes the north end of the valley the road ran through. By March 1961, when a plane went down near Pauline, the Tribune could place the wreck about a mile from “the paved Bannock Creek road.”
Sources
- American Falls Press, July 30, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 28, 1922, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 20, 1929, page 9
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 8, 1933, page 8
- Salt Lake Telegram, March 20, 1934, page 7
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, March 21, 1934, page 2
- Deseret News, March 21, 1934, page 16
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 6, 1935, page 2
- Deseret News, June 12, 1936, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 12, 1937, page 28
- Salt Lake Tribune, April 13, 1939, page 9
- Salt Lake Tribune, April 14, 1939, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 25, 1961, page 21