The new year of 1944 brought Mr. and Mrs. Chester Smith of Arbon Valley a letter from their congressman. Henry C. Dworshak, the Idaho Republican, wrote to say he had put their son forward for the United States Naval Academy at Annapolis, and that among all the young Idahoans he was naming, Frank Blair Smith stood at the head of the list.
Frank was an apprentice seaman then, training with the Navy at Pocatello while the country was at war. The Associated Press carried the news under an Arbon dateline, and the Pocatello Tribune ran it on page three on January 3, 1944, headed “Frank Smith, Arbon Given Appointment.”
The headline ran ahead of the facts. A nomination did not put him in a midshipman’s uniform, and the story underneath made plain that he still had to pass an entrance examination, scheduled for February 16. The wire report also traced his schooling. He had started at Idaho Southern, the University of Idaho’s branch in Pocatello, in 1942, gone on to the main university campus for 1943, and come back to Pocatello by July of that year to train for the Navy.
A day later, on January 4, the Tribune’s page-two column of state notes, signed by The Consul, passed the news along again. It described him as a V-12 trainee at Idaho Southern whom Dworshak had picked for Annapolis, with the examination still ahead of him.
A Crystal family
Frank was twenty that winter. He had registered for the draft at Crystal in June 1942, and the card puts his birth at Pocatello on June 30, 1923, with Chester S. Smith named as his contact. An older brother, Glenn Allen Smith, born at Crystal in 1922, registered that same month.
The middle name came from his mother’s side. She had been Arvilla Blair, and the site’s family research shows her listed as a daughter of Frank Blair of Crystal when his obituary ran in 1956. That Frank Blair headed the Crystal school trustees in 1925, as the Hayden family page notes, and in 1920 his household was on the upper creek not far from the Bradleys.
The teacher with the radio
Frank’s father was very likely the Chester Smith who taught valley children in the early 1920s. A teacher of that name had the Lyons school, District 26, for the 1920–21 year. In the fall of 1923, the year Frank was born, he and Miss Marion Sparks were teaching at Pauline when the county superintendent came by on her rounds, and the American Falls Press described him as “a late soldier with an over seas record.” That December his pupils wrote in their own news column that “Mr. Smith and his room” had gone to the Allards’ to listen to a radio, the earliest radio mentioned anywhere in the valley’s records.
No one document ties the schoolteacher to the Crystal farmer, though the name, the age, the war record and the place all line up. By the 1930s Chester Smith was farming at Crystal and sitting on the community’s farm committees alongside Norman Hayden and Elva Thacker, and in 1940 he served on the land-use planning board for Arbon and Crystal.
An open ending
How Frank fared on February 16 is a mystery. Neither the Pocatello papers nor the Utah papers searched for this story mention him at Annapolis afterward. If his family knows the rest, the site would like to hear it. Other young men from the valley who served in those years are traced in Arbon Valley men in uniform, 1941–1946.
For one January, at least, a farm family at Crystal could say their boy was the first name Idaho sent toward the Naval Academy.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, January 3, 1944, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, January 4, 1944, page 2
- Pocatello Tribune, March 22, 1940, page 12
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 1, 1923, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 8, 1923, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 20, 1923, page 2
- Salt Lake Tribune, May 3, 1956, page 29
- World War II draft registration of Frank Blair Smith, June 1942, National Archives