Power County raised a bumper wheat crop in 1947, but the growers of Arbon and Crystal watched it come in with frost in their own fields. Their loss never got a story of its own in the Pocatello Tribune, at least in the pages we have read. It turns up in scattered lines of crop news from July into September.
The first word reached Pocatello on July 10. Fred Burton of the Pocatello Mill & Elevator had come home from Boise, where people were saying a recent frost had done eastern Idaho’s grain serious harm. Bancroft and Arbon Valley, he heard, had been hit harder than most, and so had the dry farms west of Idaho Falls. In Arbon, men were already mowing a good part of the damaged grain to save it as hay.
They had made that choice before. After the June frost of 1914, as told in the frost year, E. Keeler of Arbon guessed that the valley would harvest a third of its wheat ground at most, not counting what went for hay. That frost is counted among the valley’s tragedies.
No paper gives the night the 1947 frost struck. The July report said only that it was recent. In September a Malad man who sat on Oneida County’s agricultural advisory committee mentioned frost damage there in late June, just south of the valley, and that was probably the same cold snap, though nothing ties a date to Arbon.
Arbon and Crystal hit hardest
By early August the county agent, Sterling Schow, had numbers, and the Tribune ran them out of American Falls on August 6. Nowhere in the county had the frost done more damage than in the Arbon and Crystal country, where growers had lost 20 to 30 percent of their grain. The loss ran unevenly from farm to farm. A few growers there lost half their crop, and some lost nine-tenths. Schow did not say whether he was counting bushels or acres, and no one tallied how much grain went for hay.
Elsewhere the cold had been gentler. Rockland and Roy lost 5 to 10 percent on average, and the northwest corner of the county, the least hurt, lost 1 or 2. Wherever the frost had stayed light, Schow called the crop a good one. The best yield reported came from Roy, 44 bushels an acre, and the poorest anywhere in the county was 18. Some Pleasant Valley wheat averaged 30 bushels, a fine return for that district, and the Rockland wheat was high in protein and graded better than usual. All told the county’s grain was worth $5 million to $6 million, and one estimate had it beating the 1946 crop, though cutting had barely reached full speed and many growers were keeping their wheat in private elevators.
Arbon was behind everyone. Pleasant Valley had started cutting on July 12 and was nearly done, while parts of Arbon still had grain just turning ripe. Across the county as a whole, the harvest was running ahead of the previous year. Buyers wanted wheat, and only a shortage of railroad cars held shipments back. One Pocatello elevator had loaded and sent out more than 60 cars before the middle of that week.
Schow was very likely the same Sterling Schow still serving as Power County’s agent in the 1970s, when he kept count of the acres sprayed for grasshoppers.
Heavy stands near Crystal
Not every field looked beaten. On August 19 the Tribune printed a letter from Mrs. Carl Wrensted of Crystal Route, Arbon, about two visitors, Mrs. Jeannette Pocatello and Mrs. Margaret Lavatta Calvin. Mrs. Pocatello had never been through Arbon Valley before, and the pair admired the thick wheat and how well the fields looked. The paper never tried to square that picture with the frost losses. Most likely the cold had struck some fields and passed others by.
Grain on the ground
By September 3 Power County was nearly through a harvest of 3,000,000 bushels. The paper noted frost losses at Roy and in what it called the “upper Arbon valley” without saying where that was, but the total still counted as a bumper crop. Now the trouble was too much grain. Southeastern Idaho had run short of both bins and freight cars, and grain dealers figured about 300,000 bushels of the region’s wheat and barley lay piled on bare ground. Frank Heaton, who managed the Power County Grain Growers’ elevator, said he had been given no choice but to put 80,000 bushels there.
Once the grain was in, the plows went out, and the wind followed. All day Saturday, September 13, a west wind of 40 miles an hour or more, gusting to 50, carried dust into Pocatello off freshly plowed grain land in Arbon Valley and around American Falls. Townspeople, the paper said, called it “a good old Power county cloudburst.”
In November Melba Rae Barnett of Pocatello, a journalism student at the University of Idaho, wrote a long portrait of the valley for the Tribune. In her account, 1947 was Arbon’s sixth year in a row of big grain crops sold at good prices. Not one frost report named an Arbon or Crystal farmer or said whose fields lost half and whose lost nine-tenths, and Barnett left the frost out entirely. The farms changing hands in those years show up in Arbon Valley wheat farms in the want ads, 1946–1959.
By the year’s end, the frost that had sent Arbon men out with mowers in July had dropped out of the valley’s story.