Nobody at Mercer Creek school had to worry about crowding in the fall of 1951. The whole school was four children, and Mrs. G. W. Bradley was their teacher.
The Arbon school district still ran this one-room school up in the Crystal country, at the head of Arbon Valley. It was small enough to be news. On Friday, November 9, the Idaho State Journal of Pocatello carried a brief dispatch about it from American Falls, sent by its Idaho News Service, under a headline that called it the school with “No Pupil Worries.”
Too far to send them to Arbon
The reason for keeping so few pupils in a schoolhouse of their own was distance. Mercer Creek was in the Arbon district, but its families lived many miles out from Arbon itself, and the paper laid out why those miles counted. In more than one past winter, drifts had closed the road between. And there was no telephone to fall back on: no line ran from Arbon to Mercer Creek, or to Crystal either.
An educator the Journal did not name argued that this was exactly why the little outlying schools should not be merged into Arbon’s. Bus the children down the valley, the reasoning went, and one heavy storm could strand them far from home, with no way for anyone to tell their parents where they were. The item stopped there. It gave no names for the pupils, said nothing of the building and did not say how long the school had been open.
The missing phones were still a sore point nearly two years on. In July 1953 the Idaho Sunday Journal reported petitions circulating in the Arbon Valley and Crystal districts for dial service and for a line to Pocatello that did not go the long way around. The valley’s thirty subscribers came through a switchboard kept in the home of Mrs. Lee Newport, and their calls were routed through American Falls over a line that, by her account, was often dead. Crystal, the paper said, had no telephones at all.
A letter from the teacher
On December 18, 1951, a bit under six weeks after that first item, the same paper ran a letter from the teacher in Ing’s “Buzz of the Burg” column. By then she was down to three: J. Rodney Smith and Gebe Butterfield in eighth grade and Alan Lusk in first. She and her pupils knew of no smaller school anywhere in Idaho, she wrote, and they were “not overcrowded.” The letter did not explain what had happened to the fourth child, and the papers never said which valley families the three belonged to.
The teacher herself appears only under her husband’s initials. George Willard Bradley, who homesteaded on Rattlesnake Creek, was killed in 1937. His son Willard, George Willard Bradley Jr., served in the Marines and afterward came home to run the Bradley ranch, which lies in the Rattlesnake Creek drainage near the bottom of Mercer Creek Road. The Mrs. Bradley of 1951 may have been Willard’s wife, but the site’s family research has not settled who she was, and it cannot yet put Willard back in the valley by that year. He has not turned up in Power County in the 1950 census, and no one has dated the end of the lease held by Harold Crump, the neighbor who took over the ranch after George died. If the family’s account is right, there had been a Bradley teacher there before: Willard’s mother, Ella Miller Bradley, taught at the Rattlesnake school on Mercer Creek more than three decades earlier.
That older school is part of the site’s Crystal history, which recalls a Rattlesnake schoolhouse up Mercer Creek Road where an all-denominations Sunday school gathered in 1911. The same history counts five Crystal-area schools apart from the Crystal Central School of 1912, one of them on Mercer Creek a little above Rattlesnake. The papers do not say whether the 1951 school used the old Rattlesnake building.
Swings in an empty schoolyard
By the spring of 1955 the school was shut. The Journal of May 16 that year told of field trips McCammon’s elementary grades had taken late the previous week. Thirty-nine second and third graders, with their teachers Mary Thornley and Hazel Wrensted and with Leo Crump driving the bus, went out through “the Gap” and into Arbon Valley. That was most likely Garden Creek Gap, on the road from McCammon to the Rattlesnake country, where a rancher heading out to McCammon on skis was snowed in during the winter of 1949.
What the children liked best, the paper said, were the old one-room schoolhouses at Mercer Creek and Crystal, neither of which had held a class in roughly four years. The swings still hung in the yards, and the visitors tried them out. Afterward they ate lunch at Cherry Springs on Mink Creek before the bus took them home.
Four years back from 1955 lands in or just after 1951, and since Mercer Creek was still teaching three pupils that December, it cannot have closed any earlier. None of the papers read for this story report either closing, where the children at the Crystal end went to school afterward, or which of Crystal’s schoolhouses the McCammon visitors saw. More of the valley’s small schools are gathered under Schools of Arbon Valley, along with Lila Wade of Horse Island, teacher in Arbon’s one-room schools and Eight pupils, three families: the Armstrong school.
The school that stayed open because the snow could cut it off from Arbon ended up with only its swings in use, ridden by children who had come out from McCammon for the day.