The wind was blowing close to 45 miles an hour and the thermometer read 19 below when Rodney Smith and Calvin Williams strapped on their skis and leaned into the harness of a loaded toboggan. Everyone who knew of their plan had begged them to call it off. They were going up into Garden Creek basin anyway, and they meant to live there in a tent for most of a week.
Rodney was 18 and Calvin 21, both from Arbon Valley farms. On Sunday, March 20, 1955, the Idaho Sunday Journal, the Sunday edition of Pocatello’s Idaho State Journal, spread their trip in a banner headline across the top of page 10, with photographs, a hand-drawn map and a long account. Who took the pictures is not recorded, though the pair had cameras along.
A pocket in the mountains
Garden Creek basin lies in the range between Arbon Valley and Marsh Valley, about 10 miles northwest of Arimo by the paper’s reckoning. It is a high hollow of some eight square miles near 6,000 feet, timbered with pine and aspen and walled in by Scout, Old Tom and Scab mountains, with Garden Creek Gap opening at its south end. Apart from a sheepherder or a hunter now and then, hardly anyone went there.
The gap lay on the way across the range from the Arbon side toward Robin and McCammon. In the hard winter of 1948–49 Ross Saxton, a rancher at Rattlesnake, very probably in the Crystal country, got that far on skis while heading for McCammon. Snow stopped him there, and he telephoned out that some 60 families around him had gone three weeks without fresh supplies, as told in Skis and a weasel.
Setting out into the storm
The young men had sought out seasoned mountain men for gear and advice before they went. What they packed weighed about 300 pounds: tent, bedding, food, cooking gear, first aid, cameras, field glasses, snowshoes, rifles and axes. They dressed in layers, two suits of wool underwear and wool socks under a pair of sweatshirts each, with windproof pants and jackets on top and leather boots inside rubber overshoes.
Calvin’s uncle Stan Williams lived out near Robin, on the Marsh Valley side, and that was where the trip began. They gathered at his house, and a heavy storm came in that same evening. Relatives and friends, Uncle Stan among them, warned that the mountains could kill them. Morning brought no letup. Calvin judged he could see perhaps 30 feet. The two set off regardless, wagering that the weather would soon turn. The story gives their start as March 3 and a photo caption has them leaving Robin on skis on March 4; most likely they met at the uncle’s place on the night of the 3rd and pulled out the next morning.
To climb with the toboggan they roughlocked their skis, lashing each boot to its ski with cable from the sled so that the knot underneath bit into the snow and held them from sliding back. Six miles of uphill hauling put them on a lookout above the basin. From the rim the way ran mostly downhill to a warm spring near the head of what the paper names Marley Creek. There, in snow up to their waists, a stand of dead timber broke the wind, and they pitched the tent.
A green aspen bed-warmer
They spent the first night with the tent set straight on the snow and hardly slept for the cold. The second time they knew better. They shoveled a patch down to bare ground, kept fires burning on it until the earth was warm, and laid pine boughs and sagebrush under their blankets. Then they took a green aspen log, heated it in the coals, scraped off the bark and carried it to bed. Calvin called it “the best doggone bed-warmer you’ll ever find,” and by the paper’s report they slept soundly from then on.
Rod did the morning cooking, sourdough pancakes and coffee settled with a pinch of wood ashes.
Each day they ranged out from camp. On a trip toward Old Tom Mountain a band of 20 elk let them come within about 200 yards, and the animals looked to have wintered well. Through the field glasses they picked out some 50 deer on Old Tom’s south ridge with a lynx following along. The cat carried a $25 bounty, and the two spent three days on its trail without getting close, though its tracks were “big as a pumpkin.” One aspen they dropped for firewood turned out to hold a colony they put at about 2,000 bees, and they left it alone.
Sixty feet in the canyons
They kept an eye on the snow as well. Wherever they went they stood a ski on end to gauge the depth, and they put the canyon drifts at around 60 feet. Calvin packed an empty corn can with snow and set it beside the fire, and when it had melted the can stood half full of water. To the two farm boys that promised more irrigation water than the government’s snow surveyors had been forecasting. It was a rough camp test rather than an official measure, but they came home counting on a wet season.
By March 10 the cold had killed their sourdough starter and a warm spell was softening the crust, and they did not want the heavy toboggan breaking through. They struck camp and started out. At about five that afternoon they reached the Garden Creek dam, and there their strength ran out for the toboggan. They left it to fetch the next day and went on to Uncle Stan’s without it, worn through.
The papers read for this post say no more of either young man, not which Arbon Valley families they belonged to and not what became of them. Back home that winter, Arbon and Crystal ranchers had organized patrols against thieving and planned to take to skis if the snow called for it. More on the valley itself is on the Arbon area page. The mountains had not killed Rod and Calvin after all, and they came down with a water forecast of their own, taken in a corn can by a campfire.