Lamond J. Bailey grew wheat in a country that had too much of it, and in the fall of 1959 he decided the cure was for the government to stop paying for it. His letter from Arbon reached the Idaho State Journal in Pocatello, which ran it on December 1 in “Buzz of the Burg,” the editorial-page column carried under the name Ing. He signed it “A Surplus Farmer.”
The timing was pointed. A presidential election was a year off, and the nation’s piled-up grain had become a standing fight in Washington. The Benson of the letter’s first line was Ezra Taft Benson, the secretary of agriculture, who had turned aside his Democratic critics with a one-word answer in a headline. Bailey expected 1960 to bring a deluge of charges and insults over the surplus, which he called enormous and a burden on everyone.
Supply, demand and the merchant
Federal wheat rules reached all the way into the valley. By the middle of the decade every wheat farm carried an allotment, the number of acres it could sow without a penalty, and Arbon Valley farms turned up in the want ads with their allotments offered as a selling point. In January 1958 the Logan Herald Journal had reported Benson saying the administration would ask Congress to drop the acreage reserve, the piece of the soil bank that paid growers to leave cropland idle.
Bailey’s quarrel went past any one program. He set down three dictionary senses of the word subsidy, the last being a public payment to a private business on the idea that the country gains by it, and then argued against the whole notion. Markets, he wrote, ought to be settled by supply and demand. Washington had pushed into private business to collect votes, and in doing so had let socialism in a step at a time. The Department of Agriculture, as he saw it, had worked to keep farmers from producing when it should have been sending what they grew to the hungry of the world.
He set the farmer beside the shopkeeper. Every merchant in Pocatello had goods left on the shelf, he pointed out, and if leftover stock earned a check, they would all be in line for one. And anyone who paid income tax could tell from the bill that the federal government was no good at running a business.
What he wanted from the 1960 race was a candidate who would gather up the government’s controls and agencies, march them back to Washington and hold it to enforcing the Constitution and the laws. Business should rise or fall on its own, without a subsidy of any kind. His last line was “Let every man think for himself.”
Ing’s answer under the letter took a single sentence: the columnist wished more Americans looked at things the way Bailey did. The papers never say who Ing was, and no reply from other readers has turned up. Nor did the letter give Bailey’s own acreage, prices or allotment. He argued from principle alone.
The man behind the letter
The letter offered only a name and a town, but its writer was almost surely Lamond Johnston “Buck” Bailey (1922–2013), a son of Melvin and Stella Johnston Bailey, who appears on the Bailey family page. No other Lamond Bailey is known at Arbon, and a 1970 Journal profile of “Lamond J. ‘Buck’ Bailey” ties the name to the family ranch in the valley. Through his father he was a grandson of J. R. Bailey, and the family research shows that through his mother he was a great-grandson of George Arbon.
He was raised on his father’s homestead on the west side of the north Arbon floor, and he was the same Buck Bailey who recalled knocking over the schoolhouse outhouses on Halloween in the 1930s. According to the 1970 profile, he graduated from Pocatello High School in 1940 and flew in Europe during the Second World War as a bombardier-navigator on B-17s. Home again, he announced on the radio at KSEI and KEIO and had a job waiting at a Reno station when his father persuaded him to come back to the ranch instead.
Melvin Bailey had bought J. R.’s Arbon farm in 1941, as told in the story of the J. R. Baileys. When Melvin died in May 1952, the Idaho Sunday Journal described him as an Arbon farmer and stockman and listed Lamond as one of his three sons. Seven years later, Lamond was the one writing from Arbon.
From wheat to cattle
The 1970 profile describes the family’s Arbon Valley place as a livestock and wheat operation until he converted it to summer range for a small herd of registered Angus and for Holstein heifers. In 1960 he bought ground on Michaud Flats, west of the Pocatello airport, for winter range and hay. The profile gives no date for the change and does not say whether the surplus played any part in it.
A decade after his first letter he wrote to the paper again. In May 1969, signing as Lamond “Buck” Bailey, he protested the state’s decision to shift a planned Interstate 15 interchange from Bannock Creek to Gasline Road, which left the valley’s paved road from Snowville and Malad without a direct link to the freeway. At the state hearing that June, the Journal identified him as a Michaud Flats rancher who still owned land in Arbon Valley. He joined the ranchers and farmers asking for the interchange back, pointing to the irrigated acres it would serve on the reservation and at the north end of the valley.
In December 1970, after some ten months on its staff, Idaho Bank & Trust made him its agricultural representative and an officer of the bank. The surplus farmer who had told Washington to stay out of business had gone into banking.