Gayle Waters had come up to Pocatello to see his mother. On the afternoon of Friday, March 24, 1961, she drove him out to the airport a little after three o’clock and stood watching as his single-engine plane lifted off and turned toward American Falls. Within minutes it was down in the mountains near Bannock Peak, in a rainstorm, and the 32-year-old pilot, flying alone, was dead.
Both the Salt Lake Tribune, in a wire report from American Falls the next morning, and the Pocatello Idaho State Journal on Sunday put the crash at about 3:30 p.m. George Carr of the FAA office in Pocatello said the plane had been off the runway only a few minutes. Where Waters meant to go, officials could not say.
Under the peak
The plane fell at the lower end of Arbon Valley, where the valley opens onto the Fort Hall Reservation. Back in 1917 the American Falls Press had pictured Bannock Peak as a pyramid some 8,000 feet high that “stands like a sentinel” over the approach to that end of the valley, and had counted Pauline as the settlement there. By 1961 its post office had been closed for more than thirty years, as told in this site’s history of Pauline and West Fork, and the Tribune spoke of “the little settlement of Pauline in Arbon Valley.” The Bannock Creek road below the peak was paved by then; the same Tribune page is cited for that in the story of the valley’s first oiled road.
Carr placed the wreck roughly 4,800 feet from Bannock Peak and a mile or so off the paved road, about five miles northwest of Pauline and some 38 miles southeast of American Falls. The Journal put it in the mountains near Bannock Creek.
Jessie Pabawena, who lived on Bannock Creek and saw the plane come down, said it “apparently exploded in the air.” Power County Sheriff Rulon Neal, who identified the pilot, said the wreckage looked that way to him too, and the coroner, Bud Kelly, told the Journal that pieces lay across a wide area. Neal was probably the same sheriff who had organized the Arbon and Crystal Valley Vigilantes in 1954.
The sheriff said the body, which had not burned, was brought out at about four o’clock and taken to the Davis Mortuary in American Falls. An FAA inspector and Chet Moulton, Idaho’s director of aeronautics, were to go over the site on Saturday. Neither paper named the make of the plane, and no word of what the investigators found has come to light. The idea of a midair explosion rests on one witness and the sheriff’s reading of the wreckage.
A plumber with three small sons
Gayle E. Waters was born in Rexburg, Idaho, on July 21, 1928, to Eldon Claude and Elmira Brower Waters. His father had died in 1957, and his mother was living in Pocatello. He married in Salt Lake City on May 17, 1957, and, by the Journal’s account, owned and ran a plumbing shop there.
The Journal gave his home as Holladay, Utah. The Tribune could not settle it: Davis County officers who called at an address listed for him in Bountiful learned he had lately moved to Holladay, while Salt Lake County officers reported late Friday that he lived in Bountiful.
He left his wife and three sons, none of them yet three years old. The youngest was about a month old and, the Tribune said, had not yet been named. He also left his mother, two sisters in Salt Lake City and a brother in Vernal, Utah. His funeral was set for Tuesday, March 28, at a Salt Lake City mortuary, with burial in the Salt Lake City Cemetery. The Journal’s story survives here only as a transcription on Find a Grave.
Other planes, other years
The hills around the valley had seen air crashes before and would again. A bomber went down in 1944; a Pocatello flight instructor and two students died in a light plane in 1950; and in 1963 two charter planes were lost in a snow squall.
Four years after Waters died, the same peak saw a gentler kind of trip. In 1965, the year he turned ninety, Joseph Nicholas Arbon rode a horse up Bannock Peak, the sentinel still standing over the lower end of the valley.