Late in 1979, families in Arbon Valley could expect a knock at the door from a stranger who wanted to hear what they remembered. The visitors came from Idaho State University in Pocatello, and they were after the valley’s past: the stories its people told, and whatever traces of the old days still stood on the ground.
The Idaho State Journal broke the news on November 9, 1979, with a photograph of the valley on a page in its third section. The work belonged to the Idaho Museum of Natural History, which had its home on the ISU campus and had carried its statewide name for only about a year. B. Robert Butler, the museum’s curator of archaeology, said no one had tried anything like it there before, calling it the valley’s “first attempt at a systematic cultural resource survey.”
Every road, trail and building
Butler wanted the whole picture. His crew would comb the valley for anything that had a bearing on its history or the region’s, whether a road, a trail, a building or a landmark, and then weigh each find against the historic places the state and federal governments had already listed. The caption under the photograph put the job in three parts: talk with residents about their memories, map where the old homesteads, roads and trails had been, and build a photographic record of the valley.
The study area was bounded by the Fort Hall Reservation line to the northwest and reached south as far as the first Bureau of Land Management ground. No federal land was included. Inside those lines the crew meant to call at every household. Butler also asked former residents who still remembered the valley’s early days to get in touch with him at the university.
He was plain that the residents’ own knowledge mattered most. What he hoped to gather was “the unwritten history of the area,” and he wanted the people who lived there now, and those who once had, to choose for themselves which old buildings, trails and relics deserved to be kept.
Six on the crew
Ken Anderson led the team. He had training in cultural resource management and had gone on to graduate work in education at ISU. Bob Waite served as historic preservation officer for the ISU history department. Barbara Perry was a history major at the university, and Jonena Hearst Bamford had earned an anthropology degree at Prescott College in Arizona. Two university employees, John Grahl and Ray Hunter, joined without pay because the valley’s history interested them; the paper did not say why. Together they were a blend of professionals and amateurs in history and archaeology.
The money was federal matching funds, handled by the State Historic Preservation Office. Federal law gave that office the task of carrying out such surveys around Idaho and judging the worth of cultural sites, whether on public or private ground. The crew planned to stay in the field for six to eight months at a minimum, into the late summer of 1980.
On November 19 the Journal ran the piece a second time, now on a page of ISU news under the headline “Team Studies Arbon Valley.” This version had no photograph and no list of crew members. It closed with a passage, partly unreadable on the surviving page, that seems to say the museum’s archaeology division was one of Idaho’s regional archaeological centers, serving the eastern part of the state alongside the preservation office.
A trail gone cold
No later word of the survey’s progress or results has turned up in the newspapers searched for this site, and no published report under its name has been found. If the crew’s interviews, maps, notes and photographs survive, the museum or the preservation office may hold them, but no one has looked yet. The article ties neither Ken Anderson to the valley’s Andersen family nor Butler to the Butlers who homesteaded near Arbon, and no such link has been sought.
Much of what the crew set out to gather now lives in the site’s pages on the Arbon area and in the family histories, while the valley map shows where the old homesteads stood. The valley had tried to write down its own beginnings before, as when D. J. Bowen told how Arbon began in 1917, and again at the 1967 Arbon Valley reunion.
If you or your parents opened the door to that crew in 1979 or 1980, or know where its records went, the site would like to hear from you on the contribute page. The unwritten history Butler came looking for may still be waiting in someone’s memory.