Brett Lusk was a farm boy of 13, a junior rodeo rider and a wrestler, with his eighth-grade year just ahead of him. On a Saturday evening in August 1982 he was riding in a car crowded with young people on the road that links Arbon Valley with Pocatello. At a small rise, a pickup coming the other way met the car head-on.
It was about 6:45 p.m. on August 14. Harley Hatch, 13, of May, Idaho, was killed. Brett was hurt badly enough that he never came home.
First word from the troopers
The Sunday Idaho State Journal of August 15 carried only a short item, headed “Crash Kills One Near Arbon.” Idaho State Police were not yet releasing names. They said one person had died and others were injured on a Power County road about two miles north of Arbon, and their first reading was that the car and the pickup, headed in opposite directions, had each drifted across the center of the road. The paper had nothing more before its deadline.
By Monday the names were out. Lee J. Clark, 20, of Inkom had been driving the pickup. At the wheel of the car was Drew Thomas Lusk, listed as 17 and of Pocatello. Riding with him were Harley Hatch, son of Mr. and Mrs. William L. Hatch, and DaNell Hatch, 16, both of May; Brett Lusk and Ross Lusk, 15; and Lonnie Malan, 13, and Jess Malan, 16. The police now put the crash on Arbon Valley Road about four miles south of Mink Creek, and they counted seven people hurt besides the boy who died. Drew and Ross were Brett’s brothers, as his obituary would later show.
That Monday at 11 a.m., a spokeswoman for Pocatello Regional Medical Center said Brett was still in critical condition in intensive care, under treatment for head injuries. The crash, the paper said, was still being investigated.
The same Monday report carried a second death from that weekend, unconnected to the first. Late Saturday night Alvin J. Mecham, 56, of Pocatello, was driving a tractor on Siphon Road when a tire blew out. The tractor ran off the road and down an embankment, pinning him, and he died early Sunday at the same hospital.
The early accounts do not line up neatly. One day the crash was two miles north of Arbon, the next four miles south of Mink Creek. The car held seven young people in one report and eight in another, and Drew was 17 in one and 16 in another. The first reports gave the Lusk boys’ home as Pocatello and the later ones as Arbon Valley. These pages leave those differences open, and no account of what the investigators concluded has been found. Nor do the papers say where the young people were bound, how the Hatch children from May came to be riding along, or whether they were related to Brett’s mother, whose maiden name was also Hatch. Of the Malan boys and of Lee Clark, nothing is known here beyond the names and towns in print.
Nine days
The Journal still had Brett on the critical list on August 17 and again on August 18. He died on the afternoon of Monday, August 23. A brief notice the following day named him as the son of Mr. and Mrs. Steve Lusk of Arbon Valley.
His obituary ran on August 25. Brett Wayne Lusk had been born in Pocatello on November 12, 1968, to Stephen Thomas and CaroLynne Hatch Lusk, and Arbon was the only home he had known; the family wrote that he “had resided in and loved Arbon all his life.” He already worked the land with his father, his grandfather and an uncle. He rode in the Idaho Junior Rodeo Association, wrestled for the Arbon Valley Wrestlers, and loved horses, hunting, fishing and being outdoors. He was a deacon in the Arbon Branch of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the branch traced in The Arbon LDS branch in the papers, 1976–1998, and his grandfather was his home teaching companion. In the fall he would have started eighth grade at William Thomas Middle School in American Falls.
Besides his parents he left three brothers, Drew Thomas, Ross Shawn and Jared William Lusk, all of Arbon Valley, and two sets of grandparents: Mr. and Mrs. Dave Lusk of Arbon Valley, and Mr. and Mrs. William M. Hatch of the Pahsimeroi Valley.
He came from a family long rooted in the valley. His father, Steve Lusk, was a son of David Wayne and Bette Lusk, and spent nearly forty-seven years as the Power County highway district foreman at Arbon, keeping the valley’s roads passable. His grandfather Dave Lusk ran the Lusk Loop ranch, held by the Lusk family since homestead days.
Services were set for 11:30 a.m. Thursday, August 26, at the Pocatello LDS Stake Center, with David L. Bird, president of the Arbon branch, presiding. Burial was to follow in the Arbon Valley Cemetery. No account of the funeral itself has turned up, and Brett’s name now stands among the valley’s losses gathered in its Stories, on the road his father spent a working life keeping open.