Long before it carried a tribe’s English name, the creek that drains Arbon Valley was simply Muddy Creek. A room of Shoshone-Bannock landowners heard that on November 18, 2024, along with what the creek is called in Bannock and in Shoshone.
Bannock Creek rises at the head of the valley and flows north past Arbon and Pauline, then on through the Fort Hall Reservation, where its lower course gives its name to one of the reservation’s districts. The valley above was itself once called Bannock Valley, and the family history of George Dennis Arbon says the name came from the Bannock tribe. The valley’s north end meets the reservation line, and the West Fork farms, which the government bought in the later 1930s, now lie inside it, as told in Pauline and West Fork.
Muddy Creek
The November meeting was an Elders for Justice program on two things that matter to anyone holding reservation land: grazing on the range units and water from the Fort Hall Irrigation Project. It met in the events center of the Shoshone-Bannock Casino Hotel at Fort Hall, and Lori Ann Edmo reported it for the Sho-Ban News of November 21.
Louise E. Dixey led the part on range. She had ranched for 45 years, worked for the Bureau of Indian Affairs and done paralegal work for the Tribes’ attorney, and she said she had come on her own time and spoke for herself, not for the Tribes. She started with history: how the reservation was made, the homelands its people had been forced from, the lands they ceded, and the native names of each district. The Ross District, she said, is Under the Mountain, Lincoln Creek is the old schoolhouse, and Gibson is “Sagebrush Hill.” She had names for Fort Hall as well. Bannock Creek was Muddy Creek, which in Bannock is Pasagway huude and in Shoshone Saikwi hunnu.
This Muddy Creek is Bannock Creek itself, and should not be confused with the Muddy Creek up near Crystal. That smaller stream turns up in the American Falls Press of October 9, 1917, which found Manning Standley still running his header, a grain harvester, on “upper Muddy creek, two miles southeast of Crystal.”
Then Dixey turned to the numbers. Of the reservation’s 546,000 acres, she said, 97 percent is trust land held by the Tribes or by individual allottees, and the Tribes have 6,187 enrolled members. The Tribes have run the range program since 2018. Its 14 range units cover 320,292 acres, assembled from about 1,544 tracts, some tribal and some fractionated allotments. Using a map she walked the room through Unit 3, about 126,000 acres, where a tribal member paid $8.50 an animal unit month to graze and anyone else paid $29.50.
Water and grass
Dave Bollinger, who manages the irrigation project, followed. Its water comes from the Blackfoot and Snake rivers and other sources and serves farms on the reservation and on the ceded lands. The system went in between 1894 and 1954. Most of it lies in two big units, Fort Hall, dating from 1907, and Michaud, from 1954. Three minor units, all from 1948, take their names from Lincoln Creek, Ross Fork Creek and Bannock Creek. The bureau owns the works, which count 2,172 structures, two pumping plants and upward of 300 miles of canals, laterals and drains, and landowners and lessees pay to keep them up. Bollinger read from a 1936 solicitor’s opinion holding that Indian owners of reservation land owe no operation and maintenance charges for their water. Bannock Creek’s water had been fought over long before that; a federal decree in 1907 split it between the Tribes and the settlers upstream, a story told in United States v. Daniels.
Cecil Breland, retired from the bureau, also took questions. Michelle Pak of the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service explained the Conservation Reserve Program, which pays landowners each year to keep environmentally sensitive ground out of farming under ten-year contracts. Russell Haskett, who lives at Bannock Creek, said cattle were grazing CRP ground there and asked who watched over such land and whether anyone checked the fences. Pak said complaints of violations get followed up. A Ross Fork resident told Bollinger of water being blocked from a canal, and another asked whether Indian water users could organize; they could, Bollinger said, once they had bylaws. Elders for Justice members said another workshop was likely.
Pasakwa Huude
Dixey spoke again on January 31, 2025, at a Winter Wellness Gathering put on by the Waapi Kani Cedar House. By then the paper named her manager of the Tribes’ Language and Culture Preservation Department. In the list of reservation place names she gave that day, the Sho-Ban News of February 6 printed the Bannock Creek District as Pasakwa Huude. That report did not name the language. It looks like the Bannock name from November in a different spelling. Both spellings appear here just as the paper printed them, and neither has been checked with the department.
A creek renamed
The work of restoring names had been under way for some time. On November 19, 2021, Interior Secretary Deb Haaland signed Secretary’s Order 3404, which declared a word found in many place names derogatory and created a task force to rename the 665 features that bore it. About 259 of them, by the paper’s count, were in Shoshonean original territories. The Tribes handed the question to their Cultural Committee and staff, and Daniel Stone of the Fish & Wildlife Department brought the list down to 57 new names.
On Friday, April 8, 2022, the Language and Culture Preservation Department held a forum called “Restoring Newe Place Names, Removing Derogatory Geographic Names.” Nolan Brown, its researcher for original territories and history, passed out the proposed names, drawn up with the lead language instructors Zelphia Towersap and Tony Moon Elk Shay and others in the department. Roselynn Yazzie’s report in the paper of April 14 offered one example, a creek the paper placed in the Bannock Creek district of Power County. Four names were up for it: Donambi’na Baa’, Newe Baa’, Indian Creek and Tsaa Naivi Creek. Brown said the list was not settled. To him, putting Native names back on the land was a road to wellness and a way to answer systemic racism, and taking back the homelands “through our own place names” could straighten out some of the warped ideas and stories that had gathered around the old ones. Written comments were due April 24, with a decision by the Board on Geographic Names expected in September.
On September 8, 2022, the Interior Department announced that the board had voted on new names for nearly 650 features, taking effect right away for federal use. None of the Sho-Ban News reports used here gives the outcome for the Power County creek. The federal Geographic Names Information System now lists a Power County stream that once had the old name as Tonampi Naokwa̱i̱de, with its mouth about eight miles north-northwest of Pauline. It is probably the creek discussed at the forum, though no report read here says so. The name is not among the four put forward in 2022, though its first word is close to the first of them, and the sources do not say who proposed it or when it was adopted.
The district today
The district along the creek has kept changing. By March 21, 2024, the old main building of the Bannock Creek Community Center had been taken down to make room for a steel building of about 4,000 square feet, with $1 million budgeted for it. For the November 2024 election, the Tribes’ notice sent Bannock Creek residents living in Power County to vote at the Pocatello Airport, and those it called “Arbon Valley residents” to the Arbon Valley Bible Church. The Tribes’ own history is linked from Start here.
At the January gathering a panel of elders spoke too. Daisy Hood grew up in Bannock Creek and lives now in Fort Hall. She remembered her grandmother weaving baskets of willow, and the years before electricity, when water and wood were hauled by hand. She had lived in California and Oklahoma along the way, but as the paper put it, “her heart’s always been in Bannock Creek.”
Sources
- Sho-Ban News, April 14, 2022
- Sho-Ban News, March 21, 2024
- Sho-Ban News, October 31, 2024
- Sho-Ban News, November 21, 2024
- Sho-Ban News, February 6, 2025
- American Falls Press, October 9, 1917, page 3
- U.S. Department of the Interior, news release, September 8, 2022
- U.S. Geological Survey, Geographic Names Information System, feature 375235
- U.S. Geological Survey, Geographic Names Information System, Pauline
- MyTopo, Tonampi Naokwa̱i̱de, Power County, Idaho