Arbon had no town in 1911, but it was beginning to act like one. When the valley’s correspondent sent in the Arbon Valley Notes for the American Falls Press of March 11, tucked between a well that came in at 75 feet and a dance that lasted until daybreak was one quiet line: “Some people in this vicinity are talking about opening a townsite in this valley, but nothing definite has been decided upon.”
The valley was the old Bannock Valley, south of American Falls and Pocatello. In 1911 it lay in Oneida County; two years later most of it, the Arbon floor included, went to the new Power County. It had no main street and no plat. What it did have, as that year’s columns show, was a hotel, a store, a dance hall, a blacksmith and a butcher.
An old idea
Townsite talk was not new in 1911. On March 20, 1909, with twenty-eight homesteads filed since the November before, the Arbon column announced that “Bishop Arbon is making arrangements to lay out a townsite soon, and people who desire to build in town will soon be able to do so.” The writer expected the valley to fill up enough before long “to support a good little town.” The columns never print the bishop’s first name, but he was most likely Joseph Nicholas Arbon, bishop of the Arbon Ward. A month later a front-page piece written for homeseekers listed “two schools in the lower end of the valley, a general store, and a townsite is being laid out.” After that the trail goes cold. No later report found for this post says where that townsite lay, or that anyone ever bought a lot in it.
A winter of dances
“Our valley is still on the road to progress,” the Arbon notes declared on January 14, 1911. By March the weather was still cold, the snow was deep, and hay and straw for the cattle were running short. People found ways to pass the winter. A good crowd turned out for an entertainment at the Arbon school house. The new meeting house at the north end of the valley was to be finished that week, with a big dance planned for Friday night; as the site’s Firsts page judges, it was probably the Latter-day Saint building at Pauline.
There had already been one large dance at the Hawkins dance hall, where supper was served and the dancing then started up again and “lasted until day break.” The column does not say whose hall it was. Allen Hawkins turns up in the same notes for striking water on his ranch at 75 feet, but no paper read for this post ties him to the hall, so the first dance hall remains a separate question.
About thirty-five people came to “an old time rag party” at the home of W. A. Nunnelley at Summit, between Arbon and Buist. The paper spelled his name Nunnley here and other ways elsewhere. H. E. Chapman took the prize, though the column never says what it was awarded for.
The same notes carried a small advertisement for “The Hotel Arbon,” promising “good accommodations.” The rest of the notice is too jumbled in the scan to read.
The Payne store and hotel
In July four men from American Falls drove around Bannock Peak and stopped at the home of John Payne, whom the paper called “the pioneer store keeper and hotel man.” Payne, an Englishman by birth, and his wife Emily, a daughter of George Arbon, kept one of the valley’s first stores. In September he came home from Pocatello “with a big load of supplies for his store,” and a Pocatello party who had motored out on business “stopped at the Payne hotel over night.” The Hotel Arbon of the March advertisement was most likely the same house (the first hotel).
A village blacksmith and butcher
By late summer the correspondent was writing about the valley’s trades the way a town paper would. The Arbon News of August 31 reported:
Chapman, our village blacksmith, has all the work he can attend to now, fixing up machines for the farmers.
He was probably the same H. E. Chapman who had won the prize at the rag party. The column also announced a new village butcher, printed as Archey Bindley and read on this site as Archey Lindley. He took over from H. E. Hooker, who was leaving for California. Two weeks later Joseph N. Arbon was building “a very fine blacksmith shop on his ranch,” and D. B. Ripley was cutting lumber at the mill he had leased from the Dawson brothers (the first village blacksmith and butcher).
For all that, the papers describe no row of shops. Joe Arbon’s shop stood on his own ranch, and for most of the other trades the columns never give a place. By 1915 the Press was running South Arbon and Central Arbon columns alongside the Arbon news, and the South Arbon writer reported on the blacksmith shop of Harry Chapman, probably the same man: “If a few more ranchers get mule teams he will have to hire an assistant.”
A townsite by the Central school
When a townsite came up again, it was beside the Central school, built on ground given by T. B. Evans. On April 6, 1916, the Arbon column reported: “Miss Leavitt has erected a new stone building on the townsite by Central school. She will soon open with a display of millinery and notions.” In June she took charge of the Arbon post office. The next March Mrs. E. A. Logan, writing a history of the valley for the Press, said Evans “gave the land for the Central school building and has offered land for a townsite.” She counted Harold Leavitt’s barber shop near the post office and Miss Leavitt’s small store, and said Harry Chapman’s blacksmithing near the Highland school “saves the farmers many long trips for repairs.” The Arbon area history follows the Central school and the stone store and post office beside it, and the Firsts page gathers the valley’s first hotel, store, dance hall and village blacksmith.
Whether a town was ever platted there, the papers read for this post do not show. Arbon did, however, have a mayor of sorts. On October 28, 1915, the Press noted a visit from “John Paine, mayor of Arbon,” spelling the name its own way. He had held the office so long, the paper said, that it was his “by right of continuous and beneficial use,” and he “does not have to defend the title.” He was, it added, “one of the oldest settlers in the Arbon country.” A valley without a town had found its mayor in the man who kept its store.
The original article
American Falls Press, March 11, 1911, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan.
Arbon Valley Notes.
By Special Correspondent.
Hay for sale by Julius Abter.
The weather is cold yet plenty of snow.
David B. Evans is quite sick with rheumatism.
Bishop Arbon has just returned from Samaria.
Mr. and Mrs. Affleck and family have returned to the ranch.
Mr. Colton was in the valley in the interest of the Studebaker Co.
E. H. Davis and wife were in Malad attending the big Welch doings.
B. H. Jones and sister-in-law, Mrs. Johnson, left for Albion on a business trip.
Hay and straw for cattle is getting scarce.
Everybody is looking for the spring time.
Conrad Weidermann is drilling a well on his ranch. He is now down [illegible] feet and no water yet.
[illegible] quite [illegible] now recovering.
Allen Hawkins got water on his ranch at a depth of 75 feet. He claims his ranch is worth $1000 more.
A fine entertainment was given last week in the Arbon school house when a good crowd enjoyed the program.
The Dawson Bros. have a fine steam outfit for plowing and expect to do considerable work this spring.
Some people in this vicinity are talking about opening a townsite in this valley, but nothing definite has been decided upon.
The new meeting house at the north end of the valley will be completed this week and a big dance is being planned for Friday night.
The Hotel Arbon is where you can get good accommodations and [illegible] E. A. Payne is [illegible] the [illegible] while there.
A large gathering enjoyed a dance at the Hawkins dance hall. Supper was served at [illegible] o’clock and the dancing again resumed which lasted until day break.
There was an old time rag party given at the W. A. Nunnley residence. The prize was given to H. E. Chapman. About thirty-five were present and all enjoyed a good time.
Sources
- American Falls Press, March 20, 1909, page 8
- American Falls Press, April 17, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, January 14, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 11, 1911, page 4
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 31, 1911, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 14, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, October 28, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, April 6, 1916, page 3
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, second edition, page 7
