George Stahl Butler had been warned. When he settled on upper Bannock Creek, the old-timers of the Arbon country told him potatoes and other vegetables would never ripen up there. His father came out from Kansas, looked the place over and scolded him for picking it, sure he would fail. By the fall of 1912 Butler was keeping many of those same old-timers in potatoes and vegetables, and his father had changed his mind.
The American Falls Press told the story on its front page on November 21, 1912, under the heading “Becomes Ardent Booster,” after Butler had been in town from Arbon the week before. Arbon then lay in Oneida County; Power County was not created until 1913.
A claim near Pauline
Butler was the eldest of the Butler brothers from Americus, Kansas, cousins of Frank Swim, and the Swim family history follows the Butlers and their homesteads. The Press of November 21, 1908, printed his filing on the northeast quarter of Section 26, Township 10 South, Range 33 East. That ground sits on upper Bannock Creek, some three miles south of today’s Pauline (see Pauline and West Fork).
Four years on, the paper said he had come “about three years ago,” which does not quite square with a filing printed in 1908. Most likely he filed that fall and moved onto the land in 1909.
A pound apiece
He arrived as the valley was finding out what dry ground could grow. On December 4, 1909, the Press ran a short front-page item, “Dry Land Potatoes,” about a sample raised on rainfall alone, with no irrigation:
A sample of dry land potatoes, as fine as any exhibited here Farmers Day, were brought down from Arbon the first of the week. ... The potatoes average about a pound in weight, are smooth and shapely, and of a quality to tempt the highest market price.
Farmers’ Day was American Falls’ show of the season’s best farm produce, announced for September 30, 1909, with T. B. Evans of Arbon among its vice-presidents. The potatoes had gone into the ground in June, six miles from the Arbon post office. The post office was then kept at the house of postmaster J. R. Bailey, near what is now Bailey Road (see the Bailey family).
The item named the grower only as Francis; the digitized page spells his surname two different ways. He was probably Francis F. Binggeli. The 1910 census found a Francis F. Binggeli, 28, and his wife, Gertrude, in the Arbon precinct, and in 1916 Francis F. Binggeli Jr. was granted the patent to a homestead roughly six miles due south of the Bailey post office, just the distance the Press gave. Nothing more about his potatoes has turned up.
The paper made a forecast of his sample: “Potato growing without irrigation is destined to assume vast proportions within the next few years.” Dry-land potatoes, it argued, beat irrigated ones for quality and could pay better than grain. The settlement near Arbon, it added, “has about doubled during the past year,” and the homestead land still open was bringing “a steady increase of immigrants.” Three weeks later it reported four young men from La Crosse, Washington, who liked what they saw in the Arbon country and each filed on a quarter-section, the standard 160-acre homestead.
Wheat and a Sunday school
The Butlers grew wheat as well. In July 1911 the Press passed along the neighbors’ estimate that two Butlers, G. W. Allard and Mr. Keeler, all newcomers, would have 25,000 bushels among them to sell that fall. The Butler grain looked good, the paper said, but “not considered quite as good as those of Allard or Keeler.” That same spring, by a later account, the valley’s first Protestant Sunday school was organized in George Butler’s home.
The father comes around
The 1912 item was about his garden. The altitude where he lived was so high, the Press said, that “ice forms nearly every month of the year,” and still the cold seemed to do his crops no harm. It did not say which old-timers had doubted him.
Then it turned to his father. The first visit came soon after the son settled, and it ended with a lecture and a prediction of failure. The paper gave no years for what followed:
The next year the father made another visit, and after seeing what was produced, modified his opinion somewhat, but still was only half convinced. The next season he came out again and his conversion was complete.
By then, the Press said, Butler was living at Arbon and boosting it as hard as anyone.
The family records on this site name the father as John Lucas Butler of Americus, a Civil War veteran. A John L. Butler, very likely the same man, received the patent in November 1913 to the quarter-section just north of George’s claim. If so, the father who had foretold failure ended up homesteading on upper Bannock Creek himself.
The son was the one who left. By about 1914 or 1915 George Butler had moved to a dry farm north-west of American Falls, and the Bannock Creek garden that had won his father over was left behind.
The original article
American Falls Press, November 21, 1912, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
Becomes Ardent Booster.
G. S. Butler, who was here from Arbon last week, has had splendid success in growing potatoes and other vegetables. When he located here about three years ago he was told by the old timers that such things would not mature and now he is supplying many of them with their needs in this line. Although on account of the altitude in his locality, ice forms nearly every month of the year, the cold does not appear to injure or retard growth of vegetation. When he first located there he was visited by his father, whose home was in Kansas. The father chided Mr. Butler for locating in such a place, predicting he would meet with failure. The next year the father made another visit, and after seeing what was produced, modified his opinion somewhat, but still was only half convinced. The next season he came out again and his conversion was complete. He is now living at Arbon and is one of the most enthusiastic boosters of that promising locality.
Sources
- American Falls Press, November 21, 1908, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 4, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 4, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 25, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 21, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, page 7
- 1910 U.S. census, Oneida County, Idaho, Arbon precinct, images n91–n101 (household of Francis F. and Gertrude L. Binggeli)
- Homestead patent to John L. Butler, November 29, 1913 (IDBL 0011398)
- Homestead patent to Francis F. Binggeli Jr., April 8, 1916 (IDBL 0006163)
