“Where is John Ryan?”
That was the question on the front page of the Pocatello Tribune on July 1, 1913, and his neighbors from Bannock Creek had come to town to put it to the sheriff and the Pocatello police. Ryan, a hired man on what the paper called “the Evans and Daniels ranch on Bannock creek,” had driven a wagon load of hogs to Pocatello a week earlier and never come home. The Tribune ran the story under the headline “Foul Play Now Feared,” and the next day the Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune reprinted it without changing a word.
The ranch had sent him off with the hogs on a Monday. The paper did not give the date, but the article was written on Tuesday, July 1, and the team had stood untended for a couple of days before anyone went to the police, so that Monday was most likely June 23. Ryan sold the hogs at the City Meat company’s shop on Pocatello’s east side and took a check for them. On Tuesday, probably June 24, he put his team and wagon in the shed of the Blyth & Fargo company and was not seen again. The team waited there a couple of days, with no one looking after it, until company employees called the police.
A week on, nothing had turned up. Ryan had never cashed the check. Nobody had claimed the team or the wagon. Not a trace of him had been found. The Tribune called him “an elderly man, somewhat morose, but still well liked by his neighbors,” and left it there, with no age and no word of where he had come from.
Four theories
Pocatello had no shortage of explanations. Perhaps he had drunk too much and run off. Perhaps he had fallen into the river. Perhaps he had simply had enough of the job and slipped out of town. Or perhaps someone had robbed and killed him and hidden the body. His friends from Bannock Creek were in the city that day, and the paper promised a systematic investigation.
The drinking theory carried a local sting. Pocatello was dry territory that summer, and the same front page told of eight cases of whiskey seized after they came into town by automobile from American Falls, which the headline called a “Wet Town.” When the Tribune guessed at what Ryan might have been drinking, it called it “dry” town liquor, quotation marks and all. A year later Arbon and Crystal had their own say on the liquor question, as Wet or dry tells.
Whose ranch
The article never said which Evans or which Daniels ran the place. The Daniels family kept cattle at the lower, north end of the valley, around West Fork and Pauline. In March 1917 the American Falls Press named “Evans and Daniels, of American Falls and Pauline,” among the oldest stockmen and biggest cattle shippers in Power County, and in June of that year it had “the Evans and Daniels boys” running the spring roundup on the reservation with fifteen or twenty riders. That may well have been Ryan’s outfit, but none of the papers searched for this post makes the link. American Falls had an Evans family of its own, and nothing ties the ranch to the Evans family of Arbon.
After that July, the trail goes cold. The Pocatello papers checked for July and August 1913 never mention him again, and neither do the issues of the American Falls Press searched for 1913 and 1914. Whether he was ever found, alive or dead, is unknown, and so is everything else about who he was. If a family history or a later newspaper tells what became of John Ryan, the site would be glad to hear of it. Until then, the last sure thing about him is a team and wagon waiting in a Pocatello shed for a man who did not come back.
The original article
Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, July 2, 1913, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan. The same text appeared in the daily Pocatello Tribune of July 1, 1913, page 1.
FOUL PLAY NOW FEARED
BANNOCK VALLEY FARMER MISSING
John Ryan Drops Out of Sight After Selling Wagon Load of Hogs in Pocatello—Left Team in Shed Last Tuesday and Suddenly Disappeared
Where is John Ryan?
That is the problem which neighbors of his from Bannock creek are asking the sheriff’s office and the police department to help them solve.
There is a fear that he has either met with foul play or has elected to disappear of his own accord.
Ryan was employed on the Evans and Daniels ranch on Bannock creek. Last Monday he was sent to town with a load of hogs. These he disposed of at the City Meat company’s shop on the east side of town, receiving a check in payment. He left his team and wagon in the Blyth & Fargo shed on Tuesday and dropped out of sight. His team stood for a couple of days unattended until employes of the B. & F. company notified the police. Since that the mystery has remained unsolved. The check given Ryan in payment for his hogs has not been cashed, no one has appeared to claim the team and wagon, and not a trace of the missing man has been found.
Ryan was an elderly man, somewhat morose, but still well liked by his neighbors.
All sorts of theories have been advanced to account for his disappearance. One is that he imbibed too freely of “dry” town liquor and skipped out; another is that he fell into the river; still another is that he decided to quit his job and quietly left town; still another is that he was murdered and robbed and his body hidden.
Friends of his from Bannock creek are in the city today, and a systematic investigation will be started.
