Elmira Smith was sixteen in the spring of 1915 when word came to the high south end of Arbon Valley that she had passed her eighth-grade examination. The American Falls Press put it in its South Arbon column on June 3, between a frost that did no damage and a man selling off his engine, horses and hogs. Thelma Nunnelley had passed too.
That column came out of the homesteads around Highland, the country known as Summit, and through 1915 it filled up with threshing crews, ball games and neighbors calling on neighbors. Two names kept coming back: the Misses Elmira and Delone Smith.
Neighbors at a corner
Both girls were born in North Logan, Utah, Emma Elmira on October 19, 1898, and Chloe DeLone, called Delone, on June 8, 1901. Their parents were Edward Girdlestone Smith and Chloe Ann Beirdneau Smith. In 1909, while the whole valley still lay in Oneida County, Edward filed on a homestead at Summit, a few weeks behind his brother-in-law Joseph C. Jenson. The two quarters touched at a single corner, and when the census taker came through in May 1910 the families were next-door neighbors. The Jenson family history tells their half. Edward proved up and got his patent, the government’s deed to the land, in May 1916.
The Smiths were Latter-day Saints. The Saints at the south end had formed a branch in 1913 with no meetinghouse of its own, one of the first congregations at Summit, and on Sunday, May 23, 1915, it gathered at “the residence of Mr. E. G. Smith,” in the column’s words. That same Sunday morning Rev. Sturges, whom the column spelled Struges, preached his first sermon to his small flock at Highland.
A schoolhouse for the district
The June 3 column that brought Elmira’s news also reported that the district had voted $2,500 in bonds for a new schoolhouse at its center, with two teachers and two school wagons to start that fall. It opened as Highland School, the first schoolhouse on record at Summit.
The girls had family among the teachers. Guy Benson, a young man from Logan, had married their older sister, Hazel, in January 1914. On June 11, the column said two weeks later, he took “his school pupils” up to the Frank ranch in the mountains for a picnic. By September the paper had him working on the new school building, and he went on teaching in the valley until he moved to Malad in 1916.
Visiting season
All that summer the column kept track of the sisters. Early in July, Delone went to Logan to see relatives. On September 2 the paper named them twice in one column: as callers at the Nunnelley home on a Friday, alongside Mrs. H. E. Chapman, Mrs. Herman Noth and Miss Amy Johnson, and as hostesses to Misses Ella and LaNetta Ferguson.
The Nunnelleys had come from Kentucky, where they ran a sawmill, and took up their Summit homesteads in 1909, the same year Edward Smith filed on his. Their first winter is told among the Stories. Later that September Elmira and her father set out for two weeks in Logan.
The following June the Arbon column announced that “E. G. Smith and W. A. Nunnley came in today with a new Studebaker car each. They are the proudest men in Arbon.” Since W. A. Nunnelley lived next to him at Summit, that was most likely the girls’ father.
Delone stays
Another name ran through the 1915 columns: Guy Larsen, son of Peter M. Larsen of Mendon. That Peter was very likely the Peter Larsen counted among the first homesteaders at Summit. Guy’s obituary has the family moving to Arbon when he was nine, around 1905, yet in 1915 the Larsens were still going back and forth to Cache Valley. That spring Guy’s good saddle horse put a foot in a badger hole and broke its leg. In early July he went home to Utah after a spring in the valley, and on September 2 the paper had Peter and another son, Miles, down from Cache Valley to harvest their grain and see to their cattle. By November Guy was “Mr. Guy Larsen of Bull Canyon,” the Summit canyon where the Nunnelleys sawed lumber.
Delone married him at Malad in August 1918, at seventeen. Her obituary says only that the family had come to Arbon Valley when she was a young girl, “where they homesteaded.” She and Guy farmed and ranched there for many years, and he served Arbon as justice of the peace, school trustee and fire warden. Her parents moved back to Logan, where Edward G. Smith died on December 28, 1929, at fifty-nine. The Logan Journal listed his five children, among them Mrs. J. Guy Benson of Malad, Mrs. Brown of Logan and “Mrs. Guy Larsen, Arbon, Idaho.” When Guy’s father turned seventy-five ten years later, the Logan paper counted Guy and Delone among the guests from Arbon.
The couple eventually settled at Malad, and Guy died at home there on July 1, 1961. Delone remained in Malad, busy in the Relief Society and the Malad Valley Square Dance Club, until her death on November 9, 1982. She was eighty-one.
Elmira goes back to Logan
Elmira’s obituary remembers Arbon Valley as the place “where she received her early education,” and says she went on to graduate from Brigham Young College in Logan. On February 22, 1922, she married Merl William Brown in Logan. He died in 1933. She made her home in Provo, Ogden and Logan, led the Veterans of Foreign Wars Auxiliary in Logan as its president, joined the Daughters of Utah Pioneers and spent many years working in the Logan Temple. She outlived her sister and was listed among Delone’s survivors. Elmira died in Logan on December 17, 1986, at eighty-eight.
Neither obituary mentions Summit by name. For that, there is the South Arbon column of 1915, with its passed examination, its planned schoolhouse, its Friday calls and its trips home to Logan.
The original article
American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan.
SOUTH ARBON NEWS.
About a week ago, Lee Van Horn, in jumping off a horse stepped in a hole and strained his knee so he has hardly been able to walk since.
Emmet Lee is suffering from a severe cold.
The people of the L. D. S. church had services at the residence of Mr. E. G. Smith, on the 23rd
Rev. Struges preached his first sermon to his little congregation at Highland, Sunday morning, May 23rd.
There was a slight frost in this section of the country on the night of the 22nd but it did no damage.
Roy Humphrey spent Sunday at the Lee home.
The spring rains continue and the crops are looking fine. They are a month earlier than usual.
The South Arbon ball team beat the North Arbon team again this week. The score was seven to eight. They are going to play the Daniels team on the 30th.
Mr. Nunnelley is repairing his saw mill and intends to start sawing in a few days.
Thelma Nunnelley and Elmira Smith just received the good news that they had passed the eighth grade examination in this district.
Mr. and Mrs. J. R. Stott have been visiting Mr. and Mrs Tom Stott
Harry Chapman is kept quite busy in his blacksmith shop. If a few more ranchers get mule teams he will have to hire an assistant.
Miss Lillie Blaine has gone to visit her parents who live at American Falls
Willie King has been in Malad for the past week.
Mr. James Lickingteller was fortunate in getting water on his homestead at a depth of forty-one feet. The people on the west side of the valey have had to go from two hundred and thirty to four hundred and sixty feet for water.
W. W. Harvey has a Fairbanks engine, horses and hogs for sale. If he can dispose of his property he is going to leave this part of the country.
Tracy Lee has moved onto his homestead and has been living in a tent while building a home.
Sydna Cram is still in the hospital in Ogden and is reported as being in a very critical condition.
Ed Hooker and Gus [illegible] are logging in Bull canyon and are going to get their building done before the rush at harvest time.
Ben Turner has purchased four work horses.
Among recent visitors were: Miss Sarah Karr at Mrs. Gus Brahmstadt’s, Frank Burke and family at Frank Turner’s, Mrs. C. A. Baker and Mrs. Herman Noth at Mr. Nunnelley’s.
W. H. Smith is putting in telephone poles this month.
The Sunday school at Valley View has been discontinued.
Roy Smith has gone to Malad to get a new Ford.
Little Dorothy Lee has been sick and has been out of school for the past week.
Clyde Johnson is going to take a load of hogs to Malad this week.
The South Arbon ball team recently played the North Arbon team, also the Bull canyon team, and won both the games.
Several people from this part of the country attended the commencement exercises at the Mountain View school house in the district south of here on the 19th of May. After the program there was a ball game between the Buist and Malad boys. Free lunch was served after the game and there was a dance in the evening.
Mrs. Nina Johnson had a fine cow and a horse to die the first of May. The horse died of honorable old age and the cow was poisoned.
P. W. Lee, who has been in Portland, Oregon, under the care of a specialist for some time has returned to his homestead but is still in very poor health.
Mrs. Joe C. Jenson and three children have been quite sick.
Robert, the little son of Mr. and Mrs. Emmet Lee, has been sick but is much better.
Miss Anna Peterson has returned to Arbon after spending the winter months with home folks in Logan, Utah.
Guy Larsen had a fine saddle horse to step in a badger hole and break its leg.
The pupils of the eighth grade finished taking their examinations on the [illegible] of May.
The people of this district have bonded for $2,500 and expect to have a new school house in the center of the district and run two school wagons this fall. They also expect to hire two teachers.
The Highland Sunday school is progressing nicely.
Born To Mr. and Mrs. Tom Stott, on the 6th of May, a baby girl.
Artie King, who has been in Malad for some time was here for a visit with his parents the middle of May.
Jack Folsom and bride have arrived from Dayton, Wash and intend to make this their home.
Mr. and Mrs. Clive Hatfield are rejoicing over the [illegible] of a girl on May 4th.
Sydna Cram has been seriously ill for some time and has been in the hospital in Ogden for two weeks.
Joe Jenson has gone to Oregon on a business trip.
W. A. Nunnelley, Rob Anglo and James Nunnelley went to Stone in Mr. Nunnelley’s new car last Saturday.
Mrs. E. A. Logan and Rev. Sturges were callers at the Nunnelley home last Saturday.
Joe Smith, from Logan, Utah, has been visiting relatives in Arbon this week.
Sources
- American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 8, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, September 2, 1915, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 16, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, November 18, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, June 29, 1916, page 6
- Logan Journal, December 28, 1929, page 3
- Logan Herald Journal, December 2, 1939, page 5
- Logan Herald Journal, January 18, 1960, page 3
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, July 3, 1961, page 11
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 11, 1982, page 44
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, December 19, 1986, page 40
