Early in the summer of 1915, a sheriff and his deputy traveled from West Virginia to Malad City, Idaho, to look at a prisoner. They knew well the man they were after, a killer who had gotten away from them eleven years before. The prisoner in the Oneida County jail came from the south end of Arbon Valley. The two officers took one look at him and said he “did not resemble him in the least.”
The American Falls Press carried the story in two short items in its South Arbon column, which reported the doings of the Summit and Highland neighborhoods at the valley’s southern end. The paper printed the man’s name most often as L. E. Howell.
He seems to have first turned up in the column in mid-June, under the initials L. K., as a man just home from Pocatello with a Ford car he had bought there. A few weeks later the news was less cheerful. The item of July 8 opened: “Last Wednesday the sheriff and deputy sheriff of Oneida county arrested L. E. Howell”. He was charged with forging checks, and the officers locked him up at Malad. A few words of that sentence are lost in the scan. The column gave no names for the officers, no sum, and no hint of whose checks were involved. Because it seems to have been written at the end of June, the arrest probably came on June 23 or June 30.
Why Oneida County officers and not Power County ones? When Power County was carved out in 1913, Summit and Buist remained in Oneida County, whose seat and jail were at Malad City, south of the valley over the Jenson Pass road. That may explain it, though the Press never said exactly where Howell lived or where he was taken.
“Proven innocent”
Somewhere along the way, Howell came under suspicion of being a fugitive from a West Virginia murder of about 1904. In the July 15 issue the column reported that the visiting officers had cleared him, and that he was home again. The paper never named the wanted man, the victim or the West Virginia county the lawmen came from. Nor did it say what had made anyone think a man at the south end of Arbon Valley might be a killer on the run.
Those words “proven innocent” covered the murder and nothing else. No issue found came back to the forgery charge, so whether it was dropped, settled or brought to trial is unknown. The Malad paper of that time, which might have followed the case through the Oneida County court, could not be consulted.
A neighbor again
Through the rest of 1915 the South Arbon column wrote of Howell the way it wrote of anyone else. On August 12 it told how, a few days earlier, he and two other men had tipped over Lem Robinson’s new car coming home from Ogden; the windshield broke, but nobody was hurt. Late that month he went to Buist on business with W. A. and James Nunnelley. In October a car he was driving to Pocatello went off a bridge and overturned in about two and a half feet of water, again with no one injured. That same month the column mentioned a “Lon Howell,” likely the same man.
His initials kept shifting in print, L. E. in some issues and L. K. in others, and the papers say nothing more about who he was. Nothing in them ties him to Perry Howell or Leslie Howell, the two schoolteachers who shared his surname in the valley’s news that year.
On November 11 the column reported that he had gone “for Oklahoma to see his mother who is not expected to live.” After that, he is missing from every Press page searched, and the man the West Virginia officers did not recognize passes out of the valley’s record.
The original article
American Falls Press, July 15, 1915, page 1, an item in the South Arbon column. Transcribed from the page scan.
L. E. Howell, who has been held in jail in Malad, on suspicion of being a man who committeed a murder and escaped from West Virginia eleven years ago, has been proven innocent and is back in the valley. A sheriff and deputy from West Virginia who were well acquainted with the man who committed the murder came to identify him but said he did not resemble him in the least.
Sources
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 8, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 15, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 12, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 2, 1915, page 8
- American Falls Press, October 21, 1915, page 7
- American Falls Press, November 11, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, December 23, 1915, page 6
