Tucked among the summer news from Arbon on July 27, 1917, between a load of pop for the valley’s two stores and a sultry week of clouds that never rained, was a short line: “James Nunnelley and Arlie King are going to be patriotic and do their bit and have joined the navy.” No draft notice had sent them. That spring and summer, before the government had called a single man, Arbon Valley’s young men were going on their own, and the papers wrote them down a name or two at a time.
The war itself had reached the American Falls Press on April 5, when it printed the resolution by which Congress declared a state of war with Germany. Arbon had belonged to Oneida County until 1913. It was a Power County town now, and the Press, published at the county seat, carried its news.
The first to go
Three weeks after the declaration, the “Arbon Gossip” column had Jesse Secrist off to Logan to be married and the Pauline mail carrier giving up his car for a sleigh. In the middle came this: “Reese Waylitt has enlisted in the U. S. army at Pocatello and has left for the training camp.” The county’s 1918 honor roll spells him Reese Waylett, and it is likely the same young man.
The Salt Lake papers kept daily lists of recruits, and on May 14 the Salt Lake Telegram gave one Arbon boy a headline of his own: “Spurred to Enlist by Half-Brother Serving in China.”
Ormandel Darling of Arbon, Ida, presented himself this morning at the marine recruiting station for enlistment, was examined, and will be sent away to training headquarters this afternoon. He is a native of Idaho.
It was letters from that half-brother, Darling said, that decided him. Nelson was a Salt Lake man posted at Peking with the Thirty-ninth Company of the legation guard; his surname is too blurred to read in the digitized page. No Ormandel appears on the county honor roll as it was digitized, but an Ora Darling does, and in 1916 an Ora Darling had helped haul brush for the bowery at Arbon’s Pioneer Day. They may well have been one man.
Hiram Bandy, a son of the Arbon farmer George W. Bandy, left a fainter trail. On June 3 the Salt Lake Tribune counted “Hyrum F. Bandy, Arbon, Idaho” among the men who had come to the army recruiting office the day before. Back home, the Arbon column of June 5 understood only that he had gone to Pocatello “on an extended visit.” Within a week his family had heard the truth from him: he had joined up and was in training at Fort Douglas, the army post at Salt Lake City.
That same June 5 was registration day for the new selective draft, and every man aged 21 through 30 had to sign. William Allard took the names for the Arbon precinct at the Central school, and Ed England took them at Pauline.
Into the navy
Nunnelley and King were not quite the first sailors. On July 12 both the Tribune and the Herald-Republican printed “A. King, Arbon, Idaho” with the navy’s new men at Salt Lake. The Arbon News, two weeks behind, told it the valley’s way:
James Nunnelley and Arlie King are going to be patriotic and do their bit and have joined the navy. They were sent to California.
The column also had a card that Ed Keeler had received from Claude, his oldest son, writing from Portland that he had enlisted. Louis, a younger son, had gone into the marines six years earlier. And the column closed on the other road into the service: under the new draft law, several young men of the Pauline and Arbon precincts had been drawn.
The army recruiter at Pocatello sent the Press a roll of Power County volunteers that week, with a plan for every home to hang a service flag “indicating how many men that home has sent.” None of the names that are still legible belongs to the valley.
A second Keeler went in that fall. Jesse W. Keeler of Arbon joined the navy at Salt Lake on November 19.
Crystal’s fourteen
Up at Crystal, in the high basin watered by Midnight and Rattlesnake creeks, the October 2 column joked that a Mr. McClain’s ranch, three miles northwest of the settlement, was “entitled to the distinction of being designated as a recruiting station for Uncle Sam’s army.” Four of his harvest hands had traded the fields for uniforms. Melvin Meadows was in the navy, and had been since before the war; in September 1918 the column put his enlistment more than two years back. Art Hottel had gone with the Second Idaho, Ambrus Moore with the army, and John Jackson, called for the national army, was to leave that week.
Two Crystal sailors, John and Casper Fannin, sons of Moses Fannin, came home on leave from Bremerton, Washington, at Thanksgiving before they were to ship out for France. Melvin Meadows had already sailed when the column of December 11 added another name:
Another Crystal boy has volunteered his services to Uncle Sam. Alma Butterfield enlisted last week and will leave for Camp Lewis in the near future. This makes a total of fourteen boys from Crystal who have gone to fight for freedom.
How many of the fourteen had volunteered and how many had been drafted, the writer did not say.
Three stars in the window
The new year did not slow it. That winter Leroy Johnston of Crystal went into the aviation corps and was shipped to Texas, and on May 31, 1918, Alfred R. Whiting of Crystal signed with the army at Salt Lake.
By May the Keeler household had three sons in uniform. Claude wrote from France, Jesse was aboard the Alabama, and a third son, whose name is blurred on the page but was probably Louis, was with the army at Laredo, Texas. “Mr. and Mrs. Keeler have their service flag of three stars in the window,” the Arbon column reported. In October Claude was over the Spanish fever, Louis was still in camp in Texas and “very anxious to go across,” and George W. Bandy had a letter from Hiram at Camp Devens, Massachusetts: his company expected to be leaving soon “to get the Kaiser.”
When the fighting was over, the Power County Chapter of the Red Cross compiled an honor roll of 366 names, and the Press printed it. Because “the local draft board’s records do not include the volunteers,” the chapter had added the men who enlisted before the draft law. The valley’s volunteers are there: Ora Darling; Hyrum P. Bandy, where the Tribune had printed the middle initial as F.; Reese Waylett; Melvin Meadows; Casper Fannin; Alma A. Butterfield; Arthur L. Hottel; John Le Roy Johnston; a Reese Whiting who was probably Alfred R.; and three Keelers, James C. (likely Claude), Jesse W. and Louis A. Two names are missing from the digitized text, Arlie King and James Nunnelley, the pair who had gone off to the navy together that July.
Some never came home, and some came home hurt. Corporal David Davis, who had once lived at Arbon, was killed in France. The Keelers’ nephew Mirlan Hallett was among the men who returned wounded, and John Emer Daniels of Pauline died at Camp Fremont. The towns they left are traced in the area histories of Arbon, Pauline and West Fork and Crystal.
The original article
American Falls Press, July 27, 1917, page 5. Transcribed from the page scan.
ARBON NEWS.
Mr. and Mrs. Oscar Swenson are rejoicing over the arrival at their home a few days ago of a nine pound girl. Everyone doing nicely.
G. A. Brahmstadt, our commissioner here, went to American Falls on business matters last week.
Mr. and Mrs. McCauley have leased their ranch to Arnold Mock and the McCauleys intend to depart soon for Palouse, Washington.
Ed. Keeler received a card last week from his oldest son, Claude, at Portland, that he had enlisted in the U. S. army. Another son, Louis, joined the marines six years ago.
The Craffee Bottling Works of Pocatello came out last week with a large truck load of pop for John Noble and E. H. Davis stores.
James Nunnelley and Arlie King are going to be patriotic and do their bit and have joined the navy. They were sent to California.
The sky has been dark and cloudy the past few days and indications were that we were going to have a rain but nothing doing as yet. It is hot and sultry here during the day.
Joe Arbon went into Malad on business last week.
Mrs. E. A. Logan entertained at dinner Sunday the 22nd, in honor of Mr. Logan’s birthday. The guests present were: Mr. and Mrs. Marsdon Talion, Mrs. F. Kennedy, Mr. and Mrs. Roy Porter and babies, Charles Allard, Margaret Allard and Thelma Rust and Conrad Weidermann.
C. W. and John Hughes bought a Case tractor a few days ago.
Mrs. Logan visited down in the south end of the valley last week at Highland and Buist.
Melvin Bailey went into Pocatello last week to make final proof on his homestead. Messrs. Newell Leishmann and Conrad Weidemann accompanied him as witnesses.
Mr. and Mrs. John Bullock are rejoicing over the arrival of the stork at their home last week leaving a fine baby boy. All concerned are doing fine.
Joe Evans and Perry Howell are the proud possessors of new cars which they purchased recently.
Several young men of the Pauline and Arbon precincts were drawn in the new draft law.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 3, 1916, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 5, 1917, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 26, 1917, page 3
- Salt Lake Telegram, May 14, 1917, page 7
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1917, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, June 3, 1917, page 24
- American Falls Press, June 5, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, June 12, 1917, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, July 12, 1917, page 8
- Salt Lake Herald-Republican, July 12, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, July 24, 1917, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 27, 1917, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 2, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, October 30, 1917, page 3
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 20, 1917, page 9
- American Falls Press, November 30, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 11, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, January 29, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 16, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 24, 1918, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, June 1, 1918, page 10
- American Falls Press, September 10, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, October 8, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, December 10, 1918, page 2
