Arbon Valley had seen little but snow for three weeks in the fall of 1920. Cars could not get through, and the roads were bad for any kind of rig. Still, a big crowd came out for the auction at the B. L. Dickinson ranch, the place Lucien McLarry had owned until lately. The day stayed cold, gray and soaking, and nobody left until the last lot was bid in. Livestock and machinery alike brought high prices, and a free lunch went around at noon.
J. N. Arbon ran the sale. John Bullock kept the clerk’s book, and L. W. Cotant came over from Rockland to cry it. The Arbon column of the American Falls Press gave the sale one paragraph on November 12, 1920. As the page scan reads, it put the day at Wednesday, November 8, but the 8th fell on a Monday that year, and the advertised date, Wednesday, November 3, is the likelier one.
That advertisement had run on October 22, a sale bill signed “Lucien McClarry Estate” and “B. L. Dickinson, Owner.” Up for bid were sixteen work horses, twenty-two range horses, a jack, three cows, two calves and seventeen sheep. There was a Deering combine “in fair condition,” one of the valley’s early combines, along with drills, harrows, a gang plow, weeders, a rake, a mower, a Bain wagon, a hack and a fanning mill, twenty-five tons of alfalfa and the household goods. Anyone buying more than $10 worth could settle with a bankable note at 8 percent, payable in a year. Farm auctions were still fairly new to the valley; the first one had been held only in 1916.
The word “estate” on the bill did not mean McLarry was dead, for court notices in 1921 and 1922 name him as a defendant. Neither paper explained why his stock was being sold or how his ranch had come to carry Dickinson’s name. The sale closed out about two and a half years on the old Bailey place.
From Dayton to the Bailey place
McLarry was from Dayton, Washington, and he likely had a ranch at Arbon as early as 1911. That September the Arbon column had a Lucien McLeary home from the Washington harvest and getting set to sow Turkey Red wheat. For several years he appears to have split his time between the two states. In October 1915 the Press called him “of Dayton, Wash.,” in the valley “to see after a bunch of hogs he wants to fatten for the winter market.” Two years later he was “formerly of this place” and “contemplating selling his homestead here.”
Instead he bought more. On March 18, 1918, Arbon held a farewell party at the Central school for Parley H. Bailey, who was leaving for Richmond, Utah. In the same column came word that Lucien McLarry, his wife Irene and their son were moving onto “the Parley H. Bailey place,” which McLarry had just bought. Parley’s homestead and desert-land claim lay in Sections 13 and 14 of township 11 south, range 33 east, part of the Bailey block on what is now Bailey Road, as told in the history of the Bailey family.
By August he owned a second farm, the Press reported:
Mr. Kramer has sold his quarter section ranch south of Pauline to Lucian McCleary, a newcomer from eastern Washington, who last year bought the Parley Bailey ranch and is now a resident of Arbon valley.
The seller was William Kramer, who had taken up a homestead south of Pauline nine years before. Hail had wiped out his wheat the previous season. This year his winter wheat was going nearly 25 bushels to the acre, and he expected to make his home on the coast.
The price McLarry paid never appeared in print. Classified ads in the Salt Lake Tribune show what land was going for. In October 1917 Mrs. S. A. Cram of Arbon was asking $7,000 for a fenced ranch near Arbon with a two-room house and a 16-by-45-foot barn. In November 1918 M. P. Peterson of Crystal wanted $10,000, half down, for a 320-acre wheat farm twenty miles out of Pocatello, and would sell horses and implements with it.
A hand in valley affairs
The newcomer took his place in the valley quickly. In the fall of 1918 he went to Wyoming hunting big game with E. H. Davis, Roy Lindley and Joe Arbon, worked the general election and was put in charge of the rabbit and squirrel campaign for the Arbon district. In January 1919 the Farm Bureau made him its Arbon district leader. In the spring of 1920 a new range association, organized “to keep the sheep out of the canyons,” chose him secretary-treasurer, and by summer he was the Republican committeeman for the Arbon precinct.
That May he and Irene were among five couples who joined Mrs. J. N. Arbon in hosting a farewell at Central Hall for Mr. and Mrs. David Ripley, who had sold out and were bound for Oregon. The paper noted that every part of the valley was there.
Behind the public life, the land was changing hands within the family. A court notice printed later shows that McLarry deeded property to his wife on April 21, 1919, and again on September 8, 1920, less than two months before the sale.
Into the courts
In June 1921 Irene McLarry came back to Arbon with her father, “Mr. Dickinson of Dayton, Washington,” “to look after their interests here.” That December the Press mentioned a D. L. Dickenson of Dayton, “a prominent sheep man of that section, and father to Mrs. Lucien McLarry of Arbon.” The Dickinson who now owned the ranch was most likely Irene’s father.
When district court convened at American Falls, the Power County seat, on June 13, 1921, the calendar listed Irene McLarry against Lucien McLarry and others, to be heard June 16. Only the names of the parties were given, and no record of what the case concerned or how it came out has turned up.
Another creditor was already at the door. S. Metz Sons, a partnership of four Metzes, filed notice of a pending suit against McLarry in August 1921. A firm by that name had offered registered Shorthorn bulls, stallions and jacks at the Farmers Barn in American Falls in 1919. Between January and March 1922 the Press ran its summons. The firm wanted both deeds to Irene thrown out, so that its judgment could stand as a lien on the land and be foreclosed. The deeds covered ground in Sections 13 and 14, Parley Bailey’s old homestead among it, and two more quarter sections.
The McLarrys were far from alone. Once the wartime boom ended, suits to foreclose on dry farmers crowded the legal columns all over the valley, as the Stories page on the foreclosures of 1920–1925 recounts. The papers searched do not say how the Metz case was decided. After the spring of 1922 the McLarry name drops out of them, and the Bailey land is last seen there as property in a lawsuit.
The original article
American Falls Press, November 12, 1920, page 2. Transcribed from the text of the page scan.
ARBON NEWS.
Miss Margaret Allard was hostess to number of her schoolmates at a Hallowe’en party, Saturday night. The house was prettily decorated in black and orange Jack o’lanterns and a real old witch imparsonated by Miss Fern Bullock. Two clown Lavone Affleck and Walter Evans, made things merry. Fortunes told by the witch, [illegible] hunt, and pinning the eyes in the pumpkin were the main amusements of the eventing. In the pumpkin [illegible] Bullock [illegible] Burge second prize and Walter Evans booby prize. Miss Alard was assisted in entertaining by Mrs. Wm. Allard and Mrs. Logan. Those present were: Miss Josie Peters, Miss Fern Bullock, Grace Bullock, Annie Davis, Clifford Burge, Raymond Burge, Dallas Hill, Lavone Affleck, Walter Evans, Welling Evans, Earl Davis, Vernon Logan, Margaret Allard, Mr. Wm. Allard and Mr. Ellis Logan. Delicious refreshments were served before the guests departed.
Mrs. Heber Woods, who has been quite ill at her home here is convalescent.
We have had considerable snow [illegible] the past three weeks, only a few hours sunshine, and another heavy snow fall. Traveling with cars is impossible. The roads are in a very bad condition for traveling in any kind of conveyance. Wheat and grass is growing fine under the snow. There is several tons of straw still in the fields that the farmers combined and have not been able to haul in, due to the recent storms. There are several farmers that have not got their threshing done yet. The threshers are running whenever the weather will permit.
The auction sale held Wednesday November 8, at the B. L. Dickinson ranch, formerly owned by Lucien McLarry, was largely attended. The day was cold and cloudy and very wet and disagreeable, but the crowd stayed until the last article was bidded in. Everything sold high, including live stock and machinery. A free lunch was served at noon. J. N. Arbon was manager, John Bullock clerk and L. W. Cotant of Rockland auctioneer.
John L. McKown of American Falls was a business visitor in Arbon election day.
Mrs. Cecil Davis, formerly Miss Ethel Johnston, who has been visiting the past several months at the home of her mother Mrs. Jerry Baker, returned to Malad Tuesday, where she will reside this winter.
Mrs. Ruth Keeler and little son Jess, visited last week in Pocatello at the home of Mr. and Mrs. George Donat.
Mr. and Jesse Secrist and children have moved into Pocatello for the winter.
Election day at the Arbon precincts was very quiet. There were 117 registered but only 72 came out to cast their vote. Several having moved out for the winter and bad roads made voting light. The judges were Wm. Allard, T. B. Evans and Roy Porter; Mrs. Jennie Logan and Joe Evans clerks.
Mrs. Joe Evans is visiting the past week in Kaysville, Utah.
Perry H. Howell has been suffering the past week with the LaGrippe.
There are several here suffering from bad colds.
The pupils of Central school are preparing for an entertainment near Thanksgiving time.
On Tuesday night, Nov. 16, a box super and program will be given by the Arbon school. The boxes will be sold to the highest bidder. A cake will be sold for the prettiest girl, the buyer to make the decision. The proceeds will be used to serve hot lunch to the school children. Come everybody and help a child to a hot lunch on a cold day. Work for our public schools.
Sources
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 14, 1915, page 6
- American Falls Press, October 9, 1917, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, October 9, 1917, page 19
- American Falls Press, March 26, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, August 27, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, November 1, 1918, page 5
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 9, 1918, page 17
- American Falls Press, November 15, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 26, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, January 24, 1919, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 18, 1919, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 7, 1920, page 5
- American Falls Press, May 14, 1920, page 2
- American Falls Press, May 28, 1920, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 9, 1920, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 22, 1920, page 2
- American Falls Press, November 12, 1920, page 2
- American Falls Press, June 10, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 24, 1921, page 2
- American Falls Press, August 12, 1921, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 16, 1921, page 9
- American Falls Press, January 27, 1922, page 4