Arbon Valley farmers had been saying it for years: elk were coming down out of the hills in hard weather, knocking down fences and tearing into the hay meant for the farmers’ own stock. In the fall of 1930 a committee went up into the Pocatello game preserve to see whether the herd had grown too big and some of it ought to be killed. It came back with the opposite answer. The herd had not outgrown its range. It had been cut in half, and poachers had done the cutting.
Grain lost at Crystal
The trouble had been building for some time, as told in The State’s Elk at Crystal and the Hired Elk Puncher. In August 1930 elk and deer from the preserve ruined grain on J. N. Williams’s farm at Crystal, and State Game Warden R. E. Thomas said he would put the question of an open season to the governor.
The Bannock County Sportsmen’s association took the matter up on the evening of September 11, 1930, with C. D. Clay, its president, in the chair. The next day’s Tribune reported the plan. Late in the month Deputy Game Warden Will S. Hayes, D. S. Austin of the sportsmen and S. R. Justice, supervisor of the Cache forest, would go over the preserve, count its elk and size up the winter feed, and the association would ask for an open season or not depending on what they found. The paper set out the ranchers’ grievance in a single line: “the elk break down fences and otherwise damage property during severe weather.” Hungry elk, it said, raided the haystacks. Nobody knew how many there were; guesses ran anywhere from 200 to 1,000. The sportsmen also voted to ask the state to patrol the preserve from October 15 to May 15, and promised to cover $125, one month’s pay, if it came to that.
Eighty head counted
The committee’s report went to Governor H. C. Baldridge, and the Tribune printed every word of it on October 6, 1930. The men had seen about 80 elk. Since only part of a herd shows itself at any one time, they put the true number at about 250, down from better than 500 three years earlier. The difference, they said, had gone to poachers working through the winter months, when the Forest Service had nobody in that country.
Hunger was not driving the elk out. The preserve ran to more than 20,000 acres, most of it inside the Pocatello watershed, where no domestic livestock was allowed to graze, so every blade grown there was the herd’s. The range where the elk were feeding that fall showed hard use, but they would move in winter to ground in excellent shape, and the committee judged there was feed enough to carry them through any winter the country was likely to see.
What worried the investigators was the makeup of the herd. Roughly half the animals they counted were old cows and old bulls. The bulls had been pushed out of the herd, and the cows had no calves at their sides. Of the 80, just 7 were calves, too few even to replace the animals lost each year, let alone build the herd up. Something was wrong with the calf crop, they wrote, and someone should find out what.
They wanted no hunting on the preserve. It should be held closed as a breeding ground, raising elk to stock the surrounding counties for hunting in later years. The state should seek a law letting some of the old, barren cows and bulls be taken out, and J. M. Wilkins, the deputy game warden at Pocatello, should be put on the preserve full time from October 16, 1930, to May 14, 1931, to guard the elk and deer.
The report had nothing further to say about the valley. Apart from Williams at Crystal, the papers named none of the farmers who complained or said how many elk got onto their land, and they never reported whether Wilkins got the job or whether any law was sought.
A second look in 1931
By the next fall the question was back. An Associated Press story out of Boise, carried in the Tribune on November 2, 1931, said farmers believed the herd had grown big enough to damage both the range and their crops, and that no fence could keep in an animal that could jump it. The state game department was looking into whether its preserve in the Cache National Forest held more elk than it should. If so, perhaps 100 might be thinned out by hunters chosen in a drawing, each paying the department a small fee, and the department was considering a rule that half of every animal killed go to a charity to feed people out of work. Talk of a kill had come up two years before, the dispatch noted, and been dropped when people objected. On the same page the Tribune said that Arbon Valley ranchers protested every year about fences broken and haystacks raided, and that a committee named by Governor C. Ben Ross would go over the ground on Tuesday, November 3.
Its members were L. A. Lehrbas, assistant chief deputy game warden; S. R. Justice, back for a second year; and B. A. McDevitt, secretary of the sportsmen’s association. They handed the governor their report on November 4, and the Tribune put it on the front page that same day. The farms, they found, had suffered little, and what harm there was came from a few stray animals rather than the whole herd. Nor was a lack of feed to blame; forage on the preserve was in fine shape. Some wandering onto private land was to be expected, they said, no matter how small the herd. They advised against any open season on the preserve and against killing elk for any reason at all, and the headline said they wanted the governor’s support in guarding the herd and stopping the poaching. The rest of that story continued on an inside page that has not been read.
Neither year’s papers said whether these elk had anything to do with the calves the state had turned loose near Crystal years earlier. More on the parts of the valley the complaints came from is on the Crystal and Arbon pages.
Twice the farmers asked for the elk to be thinned, and twice the men sent to look came back to say the herd needed protecting more than it needed hunting.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, October 6, 1930, page 6. Transcribed from the page scan. Periods missing or too faint to see at the ends of some sentences have been supplied.
FIFTY PER CENT LOSS OF ELK ON POCATELLO GAME PRESERVE REPORT LOCAL COMMITTEE
Investigators Recommend Preserve Not Be Opened to Hunters But Maintained As Breeding Ground
That poachers have taken a heavy toll of elk on the Pocatello game preserve is indicated in the report of the committee appointed by Governor H. C. Baldridge to investigate conditions and make recommendations as to disposal of the reported surplus of animals. The investigation was prompted by repeated complaint of farmers in Arbon valley to the effect that the elk had made continued inroads on their property, breaking down fences and attacking hay stacks.
A decrease of half the number in the past three years is reported by the investigators who also state a very bad condition is present in that of the elk observed a majority are old bulls and cows, only a few of which are with calves.
The complete report as assembled by Game Warden William Hayes, S. E. Justice, district forest ranger, and D. S. Austin, representative of the Bannock County Sportsmen’s association, and submitted to Governor Baldridge, is printed herewith in full.
Number of Elk in Preserve
The committee counted approximately eighty head of elk during the survey but estimate there are 250 within this preserve as only a part of them may be seen at any one time. The number has decreased from over 500 three years ago to the present number, on account of the large numbers killed by poachers during the winter months when the Forest Service has no men in that locality.
General Range Conditions
The committee finds the forage conditions to be good and an abundance of feed on the preserve for the present number of elk. On the area occupied by the herd at this time of the year, the forage shows considerable grazing, but the main herd is ranging on an area of but approximately 3,000 acres, however, they will move to other range during the winter which is in excellent condition. The committee also believes there is ample feed on this preserve to take care of the present number of elk during any such winter as may be expected in this locality. This Game Preserve consists of over 20,000 acres, most of which is land within the Pocatello Watershed and closed to the grazing of all domestic livestock so that all forage produced on this area is available for this herd of elk.
General Condition of Elk
All of the elk are in good condition, however, the number of animals of each class are not properly balanced. Approximately fifty per cent of the number counted are old cows and bulls. These old bulls have been driven out of the herd and the old cows have no calves with them. It was also noted, that of the 80 head counted, only 7 of them were calves, which are not more than enough to take care of the annual loss, without considering an increase to the herd. There were quite a number of yearlings and other young animals seen but there is something affecting the calf crop and steps should be taken to determine the cause.
Recommendations
We, the committee recommend that the Pocatello Game Preserve be not opened to hunting but it should be kept closed to afford a breeding ground to produce game animals to stock the surrounding counties which could be opened for hunting in the future.
We, also recommend that steps be taken to secure legislation providing for the removal of some of the old non-productive cows and bulls so as to place the elk herd in a more productive condition.
We further recommend that J M Wilkins Deputy Game Warden of Pocatello be immediately appointed patrolman to commence work on October 16 1930 and continue until May 14 1931. His entire time to be used on the Pocatello Game Preserve for the protection of the elk and deer. His duties to be further defined by the State Game Warden.
Respectfully submitted,
WILLIAM HAYES, Assistant Chief Deputy Game Warden
S R JUSTICE, District Forest Ranger
D S AUSTIN, Representative Bannock County Sportsmen’s Asociation
