Somewhere along Midnight Creek in the late summer of 1933, a rancher was losing sleep over his wheat. Night after night, the Pocatello Tribune heard, he sat up to keep elk out of the field. The paper did not print his name, but his trouble was the reason the state was about to do something it rarely did: open the Pocatello game preserve to hunters.
The game department had settled on 150 permits for bull elk, good from September 25 through October 5. For years farmers on the Arbon Valley side of the mountains had complained that elk from the preserve tore through their fences and helped themselves to their haystacks. When the Tribune ran the department’s reasons on its front page of September 22, it called the season an exception made that year only. Bulls had grown too many on the preserve, the department said, and they were bunching into big bands that did real harm to farmland.
Fifty-one elk from Yellowstone
The herd was not native to those hills. A Tribune column of August 15 took its history back to 1916, when L. A. “Dutch” Lehrbas, chief deputy game warden at Pocatello, decided the Mink Creek watershed would make good elk country. Pocatello businessmen and sportsmen paid the freight to bring stock down from Yellowstone Park. Twenty-seven head came in April 1916 and were hauled in a van to the mouth of Gibson Jack Creek. A second 27 arrived in April 1917, were turned out at the stockyards and driven up White’s canyon by Lehrbas and a crew of helpers. Three of them died along the way, so the planting began with 51 animals.
By 1933 Lehrbas put the herd at more than a thousand: roughly a thousand grown elk, he figured, and another 300 or 400 calves dropped that spring. Three years earlier the count had been far smaller. In 1930 a committee was sent over the preserve after what the Tribune called repeated complaints from Arbon Valley farmers; it saw about 80 elk and guessed there were 250 in all. The papers never reconcile the two numbers. They also leave open whether the elk the state once released near Crystal, told in The State’s Elk at Crystal and the Hired Elk Puncher, came from Lehrbas’s Yellowstone stock or from a separate planting.
The column drew the preserve’s edges only roughly. By its account Crystal, Midnight, Gibson Jack and City creeks all had their heads inside the preserve, along with the whole length of the West Fork of Mink Creek. The 1930 committee had found most of it inside the Pocatello watershed. A Midnight Creek is one of the two streams that drain the Crystal basin into Bannock Creek, so the preserve’s high ground likely reached the head of a valley creek, though the column did not say which Midnight Creek it meant. The Tribune later described the hunting ground as about five miles across and eighteen long.
Cattle on the same range
Not everyone was pleased. The August 30 Tribune reported that several cattlemen running stock on the Pocatello district of the Cache National Forest had objected to the season. They feared a hunter shooting at an elk would hit a cow or a steer instead. Lehrbas had a remedy in mind: push the elk off every piece of grazing land the livestock used before anyone was allowed to fire. He and Amos Eckert, the state game warden, were talking it over.
Some of the men the elk had cost money would help run the hunt. A number of the eight or ten special deputies to serve under the game officers were to be ranchers who had suffered losses, and the Midnight Creek man’s sleepless watch over his wheat was the example the paper gave.
A short item in the same column looked past the season to Pocatello’s poor. Some animals would surely be wounded rather than killed, so when the hunt closed the deputies and officers planned to comb the ground for cripples. Those elk would be killed and dressed, and the meat held in cold storage in town to be handed out over the winter. With officers in the field beside the hunters, officials expected there would not be many.
Old bulls only
The rules were plain. A permit allowed one old bull. Applicants mailed $10 to the game department at Boise by September 15, the drawing was set for September 20, and losers got their money back. Lehrbas hoped to stagger the hunters, letting in about 50 a day for the first three days. Every hunter signed in at the West Fork’s mouth and signed out when he left, and the department asked each one to wear something red, a cap or a jacket. One elk was protected no matter what: a white bull, thought to be one of only three in Idaho.
Elk were not the only game on that range. On September 6 the Tribune told how W. G. Ward, a sheepman, had killed three cougars between Elk Meadows and Midnight Creek over August 25, 26 and 27. Each measured better than six feet from nose to tail, and Lehrbas had heard of no others taken in that part of the state that year. Idaho paid a bounty on the big cats for what they did to wild game and to sheep and cattle, and the paper asked anyone who saw one to let Lehrbas know, since he kept a dog for hunting them. The paper did not say where Ward lived, and nothing read here ties him to any Ward family on this site.
How it ended is not known
The papers read for this story do not say how the hunt turned out: how many bulls fell, whether the elk were cleared off the cattle range first, whether valley ranchers wore deputies’ badges, or whether any wounded elk reached Pocatello’s needy. The list of permit holders printed on September 22 carried over to a page that was not read.
The elk did not go away. In August 1937 the state game warden said that short range feed might bring a hunt for 100 elk in the Cache National Forest that October, four years after the Midnight Creek rancher kept his watch over the wheat.