When the Pocatello Tribune reported the funeral of George Stahl Butler on October 24, 1931, its headline called him a Power City man, and most of the brief special dispatch from American Falls dealt with his years in that town. One line reached further back, to a quarter section on upper Bannock Creek, where more than twenty years earlier Butler had been one of the Kansas settlers at the head of Arbon Valley.
He died of pneumonia in the Deaconess hospital on Monday, October 19, 1931. The Methodist church held his funeral on Wednesday afternoon.
From Americus to Bannock Creek
Butler was born at Americus, Kansas, on March 31, 1872. He was one of several Butler brothers whose cousin Frank Swim also took up land in the valley, and the Swim family history follows the Swims, Butlers and Johnsons from Americus to Bannock Creek.
His homestead filing ran in the American Falls Press on November 21, 1908, in that week’s list of land entries: “Geo. Stahl Butler, ne qr 26-10-33.” The quarter sits on upper Bannock Creek, roughly three miles south of where Pauline stands today. The 1931 dispatch dated the homestead to 1909, which more likely marks the year he moved onto the land than the year he filed; in 1912 the Press put his arrival about three years back.
He was soon in the middle of valley affairs. In January 1911, when Arbon met to decide whether to join the proposed new county, he was among the men who went from house to house gathering voters, and the meeting carried 109 to 30 for joining (Arbon votes for Power County). That spring, by an account written in 1917, the valley’s first Protestant Sunday school was organized in his home. In 1912 the Press told how his father, visiting from Kansas with his doubts, was won over by the potatoes and vegetables his son had raised (Arbon potatoes and the Kansas father who changed his mind).
A move to town
According to the 1931 account, the family moved to American Falls in 1914. The same dispatch said he had lived there 21 years, but by its own dates it had been seventeen. By the spring of 1917 the Arbon correspondent of the Press was writing of the Butlers as former neighbors, passing along word that a baby girl had arrived at their home in town. She was probably Florence, the first of the children named in 1931.
In town he took part in the farm organizations. In January 1917 a G. S. Butler, very likely he, was listed with the Cove members of the advisory council of the new Power County farm bureau. At the close of 1918 he signed, as secretary-treasurer, a notice calling the stockholders of the Dry Farm National Farm Loan Association to their annual meeting at the county court house. In March 1918 the Press noted that his brother Herbert had come from Nevada to visit, and in December 1919 his son Stahl came home from Gooding College to spend a weekend with his father.
The family research behind this site records two turns the dispatch left out. His first wife, Margaret “Madge” Jaquith Butler, died at American Falls in May 1919. In September 1920 he married Violet Black, a rural teacher in Power County.
Those he left
Violet headed the list of survivors. Eight children outlived their father. Six lived at American Falls: Florence, Ruth, Mary, Betty, Peter and Margaret. A son, George, was at Cave Springs, Georgia, and a daughter, Helen, at Pasadena, California. His three sisters, Mrs. Mabel Weaver, Mrs. Hazel Woodmansee and Mrs. Ethel Bell, all lived in Kansas.
Three brothers survived him as well, and two of them lead back to Bannock Creek. Herbert, who had homesteaded next to his brother Jack and their cousin Frank Swim, was given as living at Contact, Nevada. Jack was very probably the John W. Butler who filed beside Frank Swim in 1908. The Tribune placed him at Arbon and Dale at Dunlap, Kansas, but the two places may have been switched in print: J. W. Butler had gone back to Kansas by 1919, and Dunlap was his wife’s family’s home, while Dale was living at Pauline by 1916 and was counted in Arbon Valley’s Crystal precinct in 1930.
Violet B. Butler stayed on at American Falls with the younger children. By 1940 the former rural teacher was superintendent of schools for all of Power County.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, October 24, 1931, page 6
- American Falls Press, November 21, 1908, page 1
- American Falls Press, January 21, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 21, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, January 11, 1917, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 26, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, March 5, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, January 31, 1919, page 4
- American Falls Press, December 12, 1919, page 7