Fifteen years after the Argonne, Park Lusk had to stop in the middle of his own story. On Wednesday, October 18, 1933, the Arbon Valley wheat farmer sat in the witness chair of the federal court at Pocatello and led a jury back through the advance of 1918, and at one point the words would not come. The court sat in silence for several minutes until he could pick up again. The reporter who wrote it up for the Pocatello Tribune could only guess at the reason.
The case on the docket was Park Lusk vs. the United States, before Judge C. C. Cavanah. The Tribune, which ran its account on page 2 the following day, called it a war risk case. It never spelled out what Lusk was asking for. The testimony it did report circled three questions: whether he had been gassed, how long gas takes to show its effects, and why he was so short of breath. The paper took care to call the gassing alleged.
The soldier from Pauline
The Tribune named him only as Park Lusk, a former sergeant in a machine gun detachment. Everything it said fits Edward Park Lusk of Pauline, born at Malad on Christmas Day 1895 to John W. and Annie Lusk, whose family ranched at the valley’s north end. The valley papers of those years name no other Park Lusk. His uncle Perry Park Lusk of West Fork shared the middle name, but the papers always called the uncle Perry and never reported him in uniform, and the sergeant’s rank matches what the American Falls Press printed during the war.
Lusk went in the draft call of September 1917. He was one of seven valley men honored at a social at Central Hall before they left, as an earlier post tells. Inside of six weeks the Press had him a corporal in A company of the 347th machine gun battalion, and then second duty sergeant. He came home from Camp Lewis on furlough in April 1918 with a sergeant’s stripes, and by the family history he married Erma Bailey, a daughter of J. R. Bailey of Arbon, during that leave.
A ravine, a canal and a village
What he told the jury in 1933 began on September 26, 1918, when the Ninety-first Division opened its drive in the Argonne Forest with his detachment among its units. He took it step by step. Before the signal, he said, his company lay on the ground in clothes soaked by rain. Once they moved, the leading companies had to cross a deep ravine, and there the division’s own artillery dropped shells among them. He described the slaughter that error caused. After that came a German barrage, a canal the men waded under fire, and the far slopes, with American guns still firing. It was there that he broke off.
When he went on, he told of a village the Americans took from the Germans, where enemy machine gunners cut down his company man after man. He spoke of an orchard reddened with American blood and of the day after, which the men called Bloody Sunday. Moving through one forest, the division saw shells and bullets bring the trees down around them “like a field of lucerne,” the older name for alfalfa.
A doctor who had breathed the gas
Lusk’s witness was Dr. Ellis Kackley of Soda Springs, a veteran of the same campaign. In 1918 he had been on duty in the Argonne front line himself, near where the gassing was said to have taken place. On cross-examination the government’s attorney seemed taken aback that a witness would dispute the government’s own experts on how long a gas case takes to develop. Kackley answered that he had swallowed some of the gas himself, which the government could not claim.
He drew the day’s laughter while talking about Lusk’s shortness of breath. The farmer, the doctor said, could never manage the government attorney’s job, because “it requires too much wind.” The jurors laughed, and Judge Cavanah broke into a broad smile.
The Tribune expected the case to reach the jury late on Thursday, October 19. No report of a verdict has been found, and no published court decision under his name has turned up.
Wounded in France
The courtroom account left one thread loose. In February 1919, three months after the Armistice, the Press had reported that his young wife had word he lay wounded in a French hospital, with no idea how badly. Several of her letters to him had come back with the word “wounded” written across them. No source says whether that wound was the gassing he described in 1933. The Stories page lists it among the valley’s hard news as Wounded in France.
He was home by August 1919. Erma died of pneumonia at Pauline in February 1922, at 21, leaving two small sons. By the family history the boys were raised by his brother Dave and her sister Anna, as The Lusk brothers and the Bailey sisters of Pauline tells, and the site’s pages on Edward “Park” Lusk and Erma Bailey and on the Lusk family follow the family further. In the spring of 1924 the Pauline School News column found him at ordinary valley work, grading the road down by Rooster Rock with Joe Doman.
Park Lusk died in March 1960, at 64. The Salt Lake Tribune gave his home as Fort Hall and noted his service in the First World War. For many years, it said, he had been a farmer at Arbon.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, October 19, 1933, page 2
- American Falls Press, September 18, 1917, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 18, 1917, page 4
- American Falls Press, October 30, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, April 9, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, February 7, 1919, page 6
- American Falls Press, August 1, 1919, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 10, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 24, 1960, page 31