The last anyone heard from the little Stinson was a radio call at 3:25 on a Friday morning. Nearly eleven hours later, two men circling Arbon Valley in a search plane looked down and saw it lying broken in the snow.
The privately owned cabin plane had left Bozeman, Montana, for Salt Lake City and came down early on December 29, 1944, in the mountains southwest of Pocatello. No one aboard lived. Both the Pocatello Tribune and the Salt Lake Tribune carried the news on Sunday, December 31.
Leonard Lynch, 38, was flying. He operated the Lynch flying service at Belgrade, Montana. Riding with him were Mrs. Garrett L. Starmer, 35, of Bozeman, given in the Salt Lake paper as Ethel Mae Starmer, and her infant son, Garrett L. Starmer Jr. The Pocatello paper made the boy six months old; the Associated Press said four. None of the three had any tie to the valley. Mrs. Starmer had chosen to go by air, an AP dispatch from San Jose, California, explained, because her mother there, Mrs. Clara W. Davis, was critically ill and awaiting an operation. When that dispatch was filed, nobody had yet told Mrs. Davis about the crash.
Ice on the wings
At 3:25 a.m. Lynch raised the Pocatello municipal airport by radio. He reported 7,000 feet of altitude and, so far as the damaged newsprint still shows, ice building up on his wings. The Salt Lake paper called it his “last frantic radio message” and wrote of a plane caught in a storm. The Pocatello paper fixed the crash at about the same minute.
Spotted at 2:10
The call started a search. A. A. Bennett, a veteran Idaho flier who had just become the state’s aeronautics director and who ran the Bennett flying service, took up his own plane with Dwight Reynolds, an inspector for the Civil Aeronautics Administration. At 2:10 that afternoon, while they were circling over Arbon Valley, they sighted the wreck. Neither newspaper explains what drew the search to the valley.
A rescue party followed on the ground. The Pocatello army air field sent an ambulance, a utility truck and eight men, and with them went Deputy Sheriff Ray Reynolds and Walter Woodworth of Bennett’s flying service. In the Salt Lake account Bennett led the party; in the Pocatello account Woodworth was the first man to the plane. One paper put the snow at waist deep, the other at three feet or more, and either way it made the going slow. The party got to the wreck around 6:30 p.m. Maj. Clinton Hollister, a doctor from the air field who was along, judged that all three had likely died at once. They were still in the cabin, and freeing them was hard work.
The ambulance could get only partway in. Hiking from it to the plane and bringing the dead back took three hours, and at 10 p.m. the searchers reached Michaud. That railroad point was where sixteen wagons once hauled Arbon wheat, as the Arbon family history remembers. Power County coroner Hazel Davis received the bodies, and Deputy Reynolds helped carry them on to American Falls. The Salt Lake paper printed the coroner’s name as H. L. Davis. She was most likely the Miss Hazel Davis of American Falls who held the Power County office in 1939, when an AP item listed her as one of two women coroners in Idaho. Whether the deputy and the inspector, both named Reynolds, were related, neither paper says.
Down a ridge into the aspens
Tracks in the snow told how the Stinson fell. Headed west, it caught a ridge that ripped away its landing gear, which lay at the crest. The plane then dropped and bounced down the slope over two low rises, its wings breaking apart, until the fuselage stopped at the foot of a gully “in a quaking aspen grove.” The Salt Lake text is scrambled at this point but appears to make the ridge about 6,500 feet high.
Deputy Reynolds placed the site roughly three miles southwest of Kinport Peak, “in the Midnight canyon area, just above the Hubbard ranch.” That was probably the canyon of Midnight Creek, which joins Rattlesnake Creek in draining the Crystal basin into Bannock Creek, as the Crystal history describes, so the plane likely fell in the hills around that basin. Neither report names the county, though the bodies went to Power County’s coroner. The Salt Lake paper’s distance from Pocatello is garbled in what survives, which Hubbard family held the ranch that year is unknown, and neither account names a valley resident among the searchers.
On Saturday, the deputy said, a brother of Lynch arrived in American Falls to take charge of the bodies. Mrs. Starmer’s husband was in Chicago and was due on Monday.
The valley saw other planes lost in its hills. A training bomber went down near Arbon Valley earlier that same year, in January 1944; a light plane crashed at the valley’s upper end in 1950; and in 1963 two charter planes vanished in a snow squall. In December 1944 it was a pair of fliers circling overhead who found the Stinson, and a party on foot who brought its three travelers down out of the snow.