Arbon Valley’s wheat had a friend in Boise by the late summer of 1944. Joe Wood, Idaho’s commissioner of public works, wrote to Ed Dufford, head of the Pocatello chamber of commerce’s highway committee, that he favored adding the Arbon Valley road to the nation’s roster of U.S. secondary highways. Dufford’s committee and a group from the valley had just met in Pocatello to ask for exactly that.
Their argument was the war. The road was, in the paper’s words, “an important artery in the matter of war food production,” and the committee had figures to prove it: better than 800,000 bushels of grain hauled to market, plus 3,500 animals bound for market and a butterfat total of 95,000 pounds. Over how many months or years those loads were tallied, nobody said.
The Pocatello Tribune ran the news on August 25, 1944, as a short paragraph in its “Around Town” column. A little above it sat a forecast borrowed from the Power County Press of American Falls, that Power County would harvest 2,000,000 bushels of wheat that year, with the new crop already pouring into the elevators. The item closed a string of wartime stories about the roads that carried the valley’s grain out.
Three ways to market
No railroad ever reached Arbon Valley, and by the late 1930s its wheat left by truck. The Tribune laid out the options in July 1938. A hauler could climb the Mink Creek road across the mountains to Pocatello, wait on the Garden Creek Gap road, which was still unfinished, or drive about twenty miles of dirt south across the Fort Hall Indian Reservation to the Schiller siding on the highway between Pocatello and American Falls. The long quarrel over that reservation route between 1934 and 1939 has its own post, Arbon’s wheat road across the reservation, and the siding had its moment in the 1923 buying war at Schiller.
One of those roads already belonged to the state. In December 1940 the weekly road reports from the state highway bureau rated State Route 38, the Pocatello-Arbon-Roy route, as poor, with crews at work on three miles between East Fork and the divide. East Fork lies on the Mink Creek side, so the work was most likely on the mountain road and not the Bannock Creek one. A state highway from Pocatello to Arbon goes back to 1919, as the site’s first state highway entry tells.
American Falls weighs in
The American Falls chamber of commerce took up the cause in January 1940, looking for a road that would tie the valley to the state highway below Rockland. A Mr. Fox, who managed the Civilian Conservation Corps camp at Rockland, came to a chamber meeting to explain how the town could help get it built. L. R. Scott, the chamber’s president, then put E. C. England and Robert Ewing, jr., in charge of working out the particulars with the camp.
The road surfaced again a year later. The chamber’s chief concern at its meeting in January 1941 was getting a guard posted at the American Falls dam, the Sunday Tribune-Journal reported on the 19th, but the members also talked over a better route into Arbon Valley. Power County’s commissioners and its auditor, H. C. Allen, planned to go to Boise within days and ask the state to make the road part of its highway system. The paper did not name the road. A muddled column in the Ogden Standard-Examiner of January 2, 1941, seems to describe another gathering that backed completing a road from State Highway 37 near Holbrook, through the valley, to the highway near American Falls. No word has turned up on how the Boise trip went.
Dust, ruts and a death
By 1943 the pressure was coming from Pocatello and from the growers themselves. At noon on June 28 the Pocatello chamber’s highway and road committee sat down with the Fort Hall reservation’s superintendent, C. L. Graves, and with men from the Arbon highway district to look for a way to get Washington and the state to fix the road. The reservation was the snag. The Tribune figured that about 23 miles of the route, from the valley to its junction with the highway west of Pocatello, crossed reservation land. It also explained why the road mattered so much. Trucks carried Arbon’s dry-farmed wheat over it to Pocatello, and hardly any farm-to-market road in Idaho bore a heavier load. Only a small share of the valley’s grain went south to market through Malad.
Harvest was under way that August. On Saturday evening, August 14, 1943, Leslie E. Nelson of Arbon, 39, was killed twelve miles east of American Falls when his crowded pickup collided with an empty wheat truck driven by Irvin Walz, also of Arbon. Riders told the Salt Lake Tribune that dust thrown up by a car in front had made it hard to see the gravel road. His death is recorded in Stories: Leslie Nelson, 1943.
Six days later, on August 20, the Pocatello Tribune said the state farm bureau federation would gather the next day at the Bannock hotel under J. N. Dayley of Burley and planned to drive state highway officials over the Arbon–Schiller road, where a bumper crop still waited to be trucked out. Jess Keeler of Arbon, president of the Power County farm bureau, was to go along. He was probably Jess T. Keeler, son of Ruth Evans Keeler, whose family appears on the Evans family page. Alfred Cordon, the bureau’s lawyer, said dust and a rough roadbed were keeping farmers from moving their wheat, and the article recalled Nelson’s death on that road the Saturday before. On August 24 the paper reported that the state had not yet fixed a day to inspect the road, which farmers considered dangerous for its dust and ruts, and that a date would come later in the month. Whether the inspection ever took place has not been found.
Waiting on the designation
The 1944 item gave no description of the route. But the chamber committee that pushed it had spent 1943 on the reservation road, so the road Wood endorsed was most likely the one down Bannock Creek, through the north end of the valley described in the Pauline and West Fork history.
Whether Washington ever made it a secondary highway, the papers read for this post do not tell. In December 1946 the state still rated Route 38 in Arbon Valley as fair as far as the summit and poor past it. The story of when the valley’s roads at last got a hard surface is followed in the first oiled road. For the wartime farmers who hauled 800,000 bushels over dust and ruts, the endorsement was a promise, not yet a pavement.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, August 25, 1944, page 10
- Pocatello Tribune, July 25, 1938, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, January 18, 1940, page 7
- Sunday Tribune-Journal, December 15, 1940, page 5
- Sunday Tribune-Journal, December 22, 1940, page 10
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, January 2, 1941, page 10
- Sunday Tribune-Journal, January 19, 1941, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, June 28, 1943, page 5
- Salt Lake Tribune, August 16, 1943, page 9
- Pocatello Tribune, August 20, 1943, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, August 24, 1943, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, December 30, 1946, page 8