The news came out of a state office in Boise, not out of the valley. On Monday, November 21, 1949, the Salt Lake Telegram reported that the Standard Oil Company of California had applied to lease state land west of Arbon, in Power County, Idaho. By January 1950 the company held state leases in Arbon Valley. Nearly thirty years had gone by since the valley first went looking for oil.
A derrick on the Toyn ranch
That earlier hunt began in June 1921, when the Idaho Research and Development Co. of Pocatello raised a derrick on Thomas S. Toyn’s ranch, six miles south and one mile east of the Pauline store. The company had already taken leases on several thousand acres around the site. It was the valley’s first oil well.
In December 1923 a second outfit, the Gem State Petroleum Co., unloaded at Pocatello a rig said to be “the largest oil drilling rig unloaded in the state of Idaho” and shipped it straight on to Arbon Valley. Its members were Pocatello and American Falls men along with five from the valley: L. B. Evans, E. C. England, Edward H. Davis, T. H. Hill and William Allard. The well was probably drilled on land of the Evans family.
The Gem State hole went down slowly, year after year. In June 1927 the Telegram passed along word that it stood near 2,300 feet, with natural gas flowing. By November 1928 the Salt Lake Tribune put it at about 3,000 feet, said to make it the deepest well in Idaho. The work was slow, the paper added, and many oil geologists placed the test near the farthest western edge of the country where marine fossils had been found. In February 1929 the crew was still drilling under more than eight feet of snow, with supplies hauled by sled for roughly eight miles of the way in. After that the papers searched for this story fall silent, and no producing well is recorded. The Arbon area history lists the oil tests of the 1920s in its timeline.
A seismic play
The 1949 item ran in “Up and Down the Street,” the Telegram’s business column, under the headline “Standard Oil of California Asks Idaho Lands Lease.” Records of the state land board, the column said, showed the company seeking a large block of state land spread over several townships, north of the Utah line and west of the Arbon community, in a valley given over to farming. The digitized text is too blurred to read the acreage, most of the township and range numbers, or the distance from the state line with any certainty.
The writer called the venture “purportedly a seismic one.” A seismic survey maps rock layers far underground by sending sound waves down and timing how long the echoes take to return, and a geophysical crew was due back soon to look the ground over a second time. Standard had also picked up patented farm land and other private holdings in the district. Patented land was land whose title had passed from the government into private hands, as the valley’s homesteads did once they were proved up. In a lease play that probably meant oil and gas leases on privately owned farms, though the item does not say so.
The column set Standard’s move beside other Idaho prospects. To the east, in the Elk Mountain country of the Caribou National Forest, a company that appears to have been Sun Oil Co. (the name is garbled in the digitized text) had a wildcat going down, a test well in unproven ground. To the south, in Oneida County, the Utah-Southern Oil Co. had announced on Saturday, November 19, that it would join Phillips Petroleum Co. in drilling a wildcat on the Juniper structure. By the column’s account, the only other oil or gas work on record was a dry hole sunk 1,400 feet some years earlier south of Rockland, in the next valley west. It said nothing of the Arbon wells of the 1920s.
Leases in hand
Two months later the company’s purpose came a little clearer. On January 18, 1950, the Telegram reported that Standard was opening a new exploration division based in Salt Lake City, covering the country between the Sierra Nevada and the Wasatch Range, which apparently took in Nevada, the west half of Utah, and Idaho. Geological parties would head into the Great Basin that summer, though the company stressed it had no plans to drill there. The last line of the report noted that Standard had “recently acquired state leases in Arbon valley Idaho.”
Neither report names a valley landowner. No later account has turned up to tell what the leases paid, whether the geophysical crew came back, or whether Standard ever drilled. The record stops with the leases on the books in Boise, and with whatever oil the valley holds still lying where the drillers of the 1920s left it.
Sources
- Salt Lake Telegram, November 21, 1949, page 22
- Salt Lake Telegram, January 18, 1950, page 21
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 6, 1923, page 1
- Salt Lake Telegram, June 3, 1927, page 25
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 14, 1928, page 16
- Utah Statesman, February 28, 1929, page 3