The last anyone saw of Gene Bailey, he was on foot and heading for the mountains above Arbon Valley, a .22 caliber pistol with him. He was seventeen. For a week his family and their neighbors combed the country on their own. On Monday, May 17, 1954, the Power County sheriff’s office took up the hunt in earnest.
The word went out from American Falls, the county seat, over the United Press wire. Sheriff Rulon Neal said Gene had left home on May 9. He had driven away from the family’s ranch house, stopped roughly half a mile off and abandoned the car there; a report printed the next year made the distance about a mile. Then someone saw him walking toward the high country.
The Baileys looked for him first with relatives and neighbors, and turned to the sheriff only after they had found nothing. Just when that happened depends on the account. One puts the call on Friday, May 14, while another, printed in 1955, says the family hunted for eight days before asking for help.
What the searchers turned up suggested a boy who had planned to be out a while. Neal said there were signs Gene had carried food along, and that he seemed to have heated a can of soup over a small fire. The Twin Falls Times-News reported the search still going that Monday.
It did not go on long. By the next day the sheriff had suspended it “until further notice.” Gene was believed to be in Utah visiting relatives, the report said, though it never said why anyone thought so. Months later the Box Elder Journal added that he had left his parents a note saying he was leaving home, and that no word had come from him afterward.
A Pocatello boy with valley roots
Gene’s parents were Leland F. and Fay Bird Bailey. They made their home in Pocatello, where Gene attended Pocatello High School and was a member of the teachers quorum in the Ninth Ward, a Latter-day Saint congregation in town. Summers he spent at the family place in Arbon Valley. When the census taker came through in April 1950, Leland’s house in the valley was standing empty.
Leland was a son of Lorenzo and Chloa Bailey, and the Lorenzo H. Bailey account carries his sisters’ memories of him. They recalled that he ran many of the dances at the Green Top school and cut the valley’s hair for a good many years. Gene’s mother, called Fay in the obituaries, was born Dartha Fae “Dottie” Bird. The Bailey family history records that she came from Buist when she married Leland in 1934. Her father, Henry Bird, had taken up a homestead at Buist, down at the south end of the valley, and by 1955 he was living in Brigham City, Utah.
A rider in the hills
Nothing more about Gene has turned up in print until the autumn of 1955. On the afternoon of Tuesday, September 27, a man the papers named only as A. M. Anderson, an Arbon Valley rancher, was crossing the hill country of southeastern Power County on horseback. On a hillside he caught sight of a body lying “all but hidden deep in a thicket.” He was probably A. Mark Andersen, Andrew Mark by his given names, who had taken over his father’s Arbon farm in 1946, though no paper says so.
Power County officers went out that night, joined by friends and relatives of the Baileys, and they confirmed it was Gene. A .22 pistol was found close by, and a .22 bullet had killed him. The reports place the spot only in the remote southeastern hills of the county, the corner that takes in Arbon Valley, and give no distance from the Bailey ranch.
The county coroner, H. L. Davis, went over a pathologist’s findings and talked with other county officials before deciding against an inquest. The wound, he said, was probably self-inflicted. With that ruling, the United Press reported, the authorities closed the file on his disappearance.
The papers did not agree on every detail. The Salt Lake Tribune gave his birth date as September 11, 1936, which squares with his age in 1954; the Box Elder Journal had it as September 11, 1938. His Find a Grave memorial, under the name Gene Le Roy Bailey, follows the 1936 date but gives his death as May 5, 1954, four days before the day the papers said he left home. One paper set the funeral for 1 p.m., the other for 2.
Services were called for Monday, October 3, in the Ninth Ward chapel in Pocatello, with Bishop George E. McOmber in charge, and he was laid to rest in Pocatello’s Mountain View Cemetery. Besides his parents, the obituaries named two sisters, Mrs. Leola Daniels and Ila Gay Bailey, both of Pocatello; his grandparents, Mr. and Mrs. Lorenzo Bailey of Arbon; and his grandfather Henry Bird of Brigham City, with the Tribune naming Mrs. Bird as well.
The Pocatello and American Falls papers from those months could not be consulted for this post, so his story here comes from the wire reports and two Utah obituaries. His is one of the losses gathered among the valley’s tragedies and hard times. Sixteen months after he set out on foot toward the mountains, a valley rancher on horseback found him in the hill country of his own county.
Sources
- Provo Daily Herald, May 17, 1954, page 12
- Times-News (Twin Falls), May 17, 1954
- Provo Daily Herald, May 18, 1954, page 3
- Provo Daily Herald, September 29, 1955, page 15
- Provo Daily Herald, September 29, 1955, page 24
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 29, 1955, page 33
- Times-News (Twin Falls), September 29, 1955
- Box Elder Journal, September 30, 1955, page 8
- Find a Grave, memorial 43057233: Gene Le Roy Bailey