A sheepherder in Arbon Valley on Sunday, May 23, 1954, came across the body of a man. It ended a search of nearly four weeks for Dene Earl Sutton of Pocatello, and in his clothing were the keys to a pickup that had gone missing two months before.
A United Press dispatch out of Pocatello carried the news the next day, Monday, May 24, in the Provo Daily Herald and the Twin Falls Times-News. Both copies survive only as badly garbled machine-read text, but read side by side they give most of the report. They disagree on Sutton’s age. The Herald made him 22 and the Times-News 32, and it is not certain which figure is the misprint.
A ride home from Lava
The trouble began, as Sheriff Alma Marley told it, on March 17, when Sutton went to Lava Hot Springs with “two other Pocatello youths.” The dispatch does not name his county, but Marley was probably the Bannock County sheriff; Pocatello and the resort town of Lava Hot Springs both lie in Bannock County, while Arbon Valley has belonged to Power County, with its seat at American Falls, since 1913.
The two companions later said their car broke down on the trip and that Sutton proposed stealing another one to get back to Pocatello. They refused, they said, and went home in their own car.
A pickup truck was taken at Lava Hot Springs that same day. On March 20 it was found in Arbon Valley. The hunt for Sutton himself did not begin until April 28.
Found in the valley
The herder’s name was printed as Domingo Solodo. He carried word of what he had found to a rancher, Ted Norton, who telephoned the Bannock County sheriff’s office. The 1950 census lists a Ted Norton among the households of Crystal, the settlement whose history the site tells on its own page, and he was probably the same man, though the dispatch places the find no closer than Arbon Valley.
Officers learned that a ranch house about half a mile from the body had been broken into. The rest of that sentence in the dispatch speaks of several cans, but it cannot be read in either copy beyond a few scattered words about fruit. Dr. E. B. Webb, a Pocatello pathologist, said the remains were too far gone for an autopsy. The officers’ theory was that Sutton “was the one who ate the poisoned fruit” and that it killed him.
Much was left unsaid. The readable text does not tell where in the valley he lay, whose house had been entered, how close the pickup had been left, or what the poisoned fruit was. It does not say why the call went to Bannock County rather than to the Power County sheriff. The link to the theft rests on the companions’ story and the keys. No report of an inquest or a funeral has turned up in the papers searched so far.
Twenty ranchers sign on
Five months later, from American Falls, came a different kind of news out of the same country. On October 31, 1954, the Salt Lake Tribune reported that ranchers in the remote Arbon and Crystal valleys had joined together as the Arbon and Crystal Valley Vigilantes. Their aim was to guard their farms and homes against what they saw as a growing run of pilfering, thieving and looting.
Power County Sheriff Rulon Neal had called the meeting after several valley farmers asked him to, and twenty ranchers organized under him. Over the winter they planned to take turns patrolling the valley, “on skis if necessary,” and to watch from the air once the snow came. The founding members were to set out right away to enroll every man in Arbon and Crystal.
Neal had already sworn in deputies. The first named was Lloyd Brower, probably the Crystal rancher J. Lloyd Brower. The second name is damaged in print but seems to read Sherman Roper. A third deputy, and perhaps a fourth, was still to be chosen for the south end of the valley. The members also meant to get advice on their lawful rights in carrying guns and on what protective measures they could properly take. For all the name, it was a sheriff’s organization, and one that wanted to know where the law drew its lines.
The Tribune named no particular theft, suspect or victim, and it said nothing of Sutton. The two papers never tie the stories together, and they are told side by side here only because they belong to the same valley in the same year. The vigilantes also have a short entry among the valley’s tragedies and hard times. Whether the patrols ever went out on their skis that winter, and whether they caught anyone, the papers have not yet said.