By the middle of February 1962, the people who lived along Bannock Creek could not drive out. Two floods in about a month, both of them bad, had broken the oiled highway up the creek in two places, and the Idaho State Journal went out to look on February 14.
The road was one of the ways out of Arbon Valley. It ran north from the valley down Bannock Creek, across the Fort Hall Reservation, to U.S. Highway 30. Roughly six miles south of the highway, the water had cut a gap about 50 feet across the pavement. Farther south, near Pauline, a bridge had gone out. Any car caught on the 10 to 15 miles between those two breaks was stuck there, and the side roads were no better. People who needed to get somewhere went on foot, on horseback or on a tractor.
The paper ran two pictures. One was of the 50-foot gap. In the other, a rough barricade stood near the camera, the only warning a driver would get that the weekend flood had severed the highway at that spot, while in the distance rain kept coming down on the valley’s melting snow. Fields were flooded, and the shoulders of the road had turned to mush.
A warm wind in January
The first flood had come in the second week of January, when a warm wind, very nearly a chinook, swept through and took the snow off in a hurry. The Journal said meltwater poured into the creek from almost the full length of the valley, from the Arbon settlement past Pauline and on down Bannock Creek.
The creek ran high most springs. Still, W. M. Hatch, the Arbon Valley mail carrier, who lived on the Batise road and had known the country for twenty years, told the paper on Friday, January 12, that he had never seen it higher. He thought bridges on several side roads would need major repairs.
The hardest hit, as Hatch saw it, was the Nancy Jack place, where ice and water surrounded the farm buildings. Nancy Jack was about 90, and her large household took in several small orphaned children. With ice everywhere, just getting firewood was work, and the well may have been fouled by the flood. Hatch laid the blame on the new highway. Ever since it was built, he said, its culvert had been too small to carry what came off the hills, and the overflow landed on the Jack farm. He wanted a dike put in.
The second flood
A month later, over the weekend of February 10 and 11, high water spread across much of southeastern Idaho. By Monday, February 12, Superintendent Wesley Frazier had every American Falls school open and meant to keep them that way unless the flood reached town. The Arbon children, though, faced a week to ten days without a bus. Power County commissioner LeRoy Lindley told the Journal the flood had badly damaged county roads along Bannock Creek; several bridges were believed lost, along with the oiled road laid in 1955. The rest of his remarks continued on a page that has not been found, so what he planned to do is not known.
Down on the reservation, the flood had all but stopped the Michaud reclamation project. Crews had pulled every big machine onto high ground during the January flood. Some of it was brought back, and then a hard freeze that set in on January 20 shut down nearly all the work. By mid-February, project engineer John Brooks said, only the well drilling went on, and the drillers could reach it only by walking or riding a heavy tractor. Merrill Construction Co. of Boise had moved its machines up high, except for a compressor and some heaters left standing in water about eight feet deep.
Nobody could say when the road would be repaired or when the reclamation crews would get back to work. On Sunday, February 18, the Idaho Sunday Journal surveyed the flood damage across Power County and concluded that probably no road in the county was worse off than the one up Bannock Creek, the link between Highway 30N and Arbon, Pauline and Crystal. Its bridges were gone and its surface was in poor shape. The Arbon bus had not run all week, and there was no word on when it might. Elsewhere, Highway 37 was closed between Rockland and Malad, and the county roads around Arbon were still impassable.
A third rise
Six weeks or so later the creeks came up again. At the end of March, as told in Floods cut off Arbon Valley, March 1962, the Salt Lake Tribune reported the Bannock Creek road to American Falls washed out at several points, and fills placed in the Mink Creek road after the February floods were gone too. The Deseret News said bridges there had been swept away for the third time that year and crews were working on them. The site’s Stories entry on the 1962 flood follows that spring. None of these papers says when the road reopened or when the Arbon bus ran again.
It had happened before
The creek had taken the road before. In February 1957 Bannock Creek flooded on the reservation below the valley, and water in the basement closed the Bannock Creek Elementary school on February 14. It was still shut when the Idaho State Journal reported from Fort Hall on February 27. Frell M. Owl, who ran the reservation, said the water north of the school, by the Zimmerli farm, had taken to the Arbon Valley road. For two days state highway crews from American Falls and agency crews had used about a dozen trucks to haul gravel onto the road, and a new surge that Saturday washed it all away. Out on the road Monday, Owl found the water “running straight down the middle of the road.” The older pupils, who took a bus to school in American Falls, stayed home too. The paper did not say when that road opened again.
Water at Rooster Rock
It happened again the next winter. On Friday, February 1, 1963, Charles Spencer, then superintendent of the Fort Hall Indian reservation, went out to inspect and reported water about two feet deep flowing over the Arbon highway. It covered the road at Rooster Rock, and nothing could get through. The flood had reached the homes of Wilson Jack and Charley Divinney. Neither family wanted to move out, so food and drinking water were being taken to them.
Rooster Rock had been a landmark on that road for a long time. In the Pauline school news in the American Falls Press of April 3, 1924, a pupil wrote that Park Lusk and Joe Doman had gone “down by Rooster Rock to grade the road,” work that ties the place to the Lusk family. The papers never pin down exactly where Rooster Rock was, any more than the Zimmerli farm, the Nancy Jack place or the lost bridge near Pauline.
More of the creek’s history is told in the flood of 1911 and the Bannock Creek bridges and when the Bannock Creek lands were allotted, and the places at the far end of the road in Pauline and West Fork and Crystal. The bus those children waited on traces back to the valley’s first school bus. Graders in 1924, gravel trucks in 1957, bridge crews in 1962: each generation built the road up Bannock Creek, and each time the creek came back for it.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, February 14, 1962, page 9
- Idaho State Journal, February 27, 1957, page 1
- Idaho State Journal, January 12, 1962, page 9
- Idaho State Journal, February 12, 1962, page 1
- Idaho Sunday Journal, February 18, 1962, page 3
- Deseret News, March 28, 1962, page 7
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 29, 1962, page 10
- Idaho State Journal, February 1, 1963, page 2
- American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 4