When the mail reached Arbon at the end of March 1962, it came on foot across a few planks laid over a hole in the highway. For several days that spring, melting snow had turned the creeks loose and left the valley with no road out, no electric power and, for a while, no telephone.
Three Utah papers, the Deseret News, the Logan Herald Journal and the Salt Lake Tribune, followed the trouble from day to day. Between them they tell far more than the single entry on this site’s Stories page.
The third washout of the year
The valley had been through this once already that year. In early February, floods across southeastern Idaho had caused damage running into the millions, the Deseret News recalled, and since then fills had been put into the road between Arbon and Crystal, which the Tribune said went by the name of the Mink Creek road. By late March, the Logan Herald Journal reported, snow and ice were thawing as high as 8,500 feet, and nearly all of southeastern Idaho faced fresh danger. Guardsmen were out at Bancroft, and in the south end of Pocatello families left their homes ahead of the water.
Arbon, a town of some 300 people by the Deseret News’s count, lost its electricity at about six on the morning of Tuesday, March 27. A day later the lights were still out. Crews fixing bridges were slowed by strong wind and hard cold, and the paper said those bridges had gone out “for the third time this year,” without naming which ones they were.
No way in or out
By Wednesday, March 28, the valley was marooned. Its state highway, which ran north to Pocatello and south to Malad, had been broken by runoff in a number of places. A wire story in the Logan Herald Journal said high water on Bannock Creek had shut the valley’s northern entrance on Tuesday, and that the southeastern way in, from Malad, was closed as well. Power County officials at American Falls were trying to get through to find out how people were faring.
The Tribune, printing its account on Thursday, filled in the picture. The creeks had spilled out of their channels, cutting both the road to Crystal and the road to American Falls. The new fills on the Mink Creek road were gone, and the main road down Bannock Creek to American Falls had washed away at several spots. That left only the road toward Malad, and deep snow, mud and washouts had kept it shut for most of the winter.
On Wednesday morning the telephone line into Arbon went down too, and the Deseret News described the community, about 30 miles south of Pocatello, as “cut off from the outside world.” Officials told the Tribune no one there was in danger.
Just how many people were stranded depends on which paper you read. The Tribune put it at 25 dry-farm families in what it called “little Arbon Valley,” while the Logan Herald Journal and the Deseret News spoke of several hundred farm families trapped. With Arbon’s own population given as 300, the smaller number is likely the closer one.
The wider flood
The valley was only one corner of a larger emergency. Civil defense officials named Bonneville and Haystack mountains, on the Bannock–Caribou county line about 25 miles east of Pocatello, as the main threat. Snow on their eastern flanks, up to summits of 9,500 and 8,700 feet, was running off into the Portneuf drainage above Lava Hot Springs, much of it pooling in Pebble Basin. A quick warm spell, or a long stretch above freezing, could overwhelm the river, officials warned, and McCammon, Inkom and then Pocatello would feel it in turn.
At Pocatello the gauge read 6.3 feet by noon Tuesday, a foot over flood stage, then 6.42 feet that night and 6.52 feet before dawn Wednesday. Highway officials there feared they might have to close every main road between Pocatello and Bancroft. In Lava Hot Springs the temporary bridge carrying U.S. 30N through town was taken down before the river could take it, and Mayor Roy Judd sent traffic around by a steel bridge and a county road some six miles west. Bancroft kept its highway open even with 18 inches of water over one stretch and a street a block south flooded to the hubcaps. Snow fell on Idaho Falls Wednesday, water ran across State Highways 20 and 26 near Arco, and Gov. Robert E. Smylie’s emergency committee met that day, hoping the cold would slow the melt enough for the water to drain off to the south.
Planks across the gap
By Friday, March 30, the phone line was back, and the Logan Herald Journal got its Arbon news straight from the valley. Its source was Mrs. Lee Newport, who kept what the paper called “a private telephone exchange serving the valley.” That was very likely Gena Newport. She and her husband Lee bought the T. B. Evans farm in 1940 and ran the valley’s switchboard from the Evans house from then on; the Firsts page tells how it came to her from Susannah Evans.
Rattlesnake Creek, which carries water out of the Crystal basin into Bannock Creek, was dropping, Mrs. Newport said. Its first rush, though, had torn a gap of 40 or 50 feet in State Highway 38, the road joining the valley to Pocatello, at a point the paper placed about 20 miles south of that city. Someone had laid planks over the break. The mail carriers “walked the plank,” as the paper put it, and a car on the far side drove them on to Arbon.
There the record ends. None of the reports names the carriers, explains what brought down the power and phone lines, or says when the lights came back on, when the roads were repaired or how long the valley stayed shut in. The Idaho papers most likely to have followed it, the Power County Press and the Idaho State Journal, were not at hand for this post.
Again at Christmas
It happened again in less than three years. Floods ran across much of Idaho in the week of Christmas 1964, and on Sunday, December 27, an Associated Press roundup in the Salt Lake Tribune said most rivers had gone back within their banks, after at least two deaths and harm to as many as 100 homes. Washed-out roads still had families stranded at Atlanta and in three other places. James Imper, the state’s assistant civil defense director, said families in Arbon Valley had been isolated, but the scanned page is too scrambled to show how many, or what had given way.
Floodwater was nothing new on Bannock Creek, which had taken lives in January 1911, and the valley had been stranded before, in the winter of 1948–49, when the mail came by air. The first dial telephones arrived in 1965, and after that no call had to pass through Gena Newport’s switchboard. In 1962, though, it was her voice that told the outside world the valley was still there.