Snow was coming down hard on Thanksgiving morning, 1964, when two families set out on the road that runs north out of Arbon toward Crystal and Mink Creek. At 11:30 a.m. their cars came together head-on. By Friday, eight people from the two cars were patients at Bannock Memorial Hospital in Pocatello, and neither car was worth fixing.
One car carried the Permanns of Arbon, with Vernon Permann at the wheel. The other carried the Denny family of Pocatello, driven by Clyde Denny. James Hager, the state patrolman stationed at American Falls, worked the wreck, and he found that the two had met squarely, front to front, in the falling snow. Beyond the storm, the paper gave no cause.
The Idaho State Journal put the story on its front page that Friday, November 27. It placed the crash in Power County, eight miles north of what it called “the Arbon junction near Crystal.” When the paper took up the case again in 1966, it called the road the Mink Creek Road and set the spot eight miles north of Arbon. Either way, this was the valley’s way over the hills to Pocatello by Crystal and Mink Creek, a route whose early years are told in Mail, grain and the Mink Creek road to Pocatello, 1924–1929. Crystal’s own beginnings are in Crystal, the hidden settlement up Rattlesnake Creek. Just where on that road the cars met, the papers do not say.
Two families in the hospital
Five of the eight were Dennys: Clyde, his wife, their daughters Jolynn and Laura Lee, and their son Curtis. The other three came from Arbon: Vernon Permann, his wife and their son, printed as VoniDean in 1964 and as Vaun Dean two years later. The hospital reported on Friday that five of the patients had passed a good night and three a fair one.
The Permanns were well known in the valley that fall. On the day before the crash, the Journal had listed Vern Permann among the directors of the Arbon Valley Protective Association, a group formed to fight theft and vandalism, which had just returned Sod Williams to the presidency.
His wife went unnamed in 1964. The 1966 report calls her Lorita, and she was very likely Lorita Sharlene Bolingbroke, born in 1938 to John Henry Bolingbroke Jr. and Lois Davis Bolingbroke. She was raised on the family farm in Arbon Valley and attended the Arbon school, and her obituary records that she married Vern Permann in August 1956 and had three children, John, Joni and Vaun. Her father’s people appear on the Bolingbroke family page and her mother’s on the Davis family page. One point does not fit: the 1966 paper names her husband Vernon D. Permann, but her obituary gives his middle name as Haggard.
Suit and countersuit
Each side came to blame the other. Five Permanns took the matter to Fifth District court: Vernon, Lorita and their children John Douglas, Joni Sue and Vaun Dean. They charged Clyde H. Denny with negligence, said they had suffered serious injuries, and asked $75,000 in general damages and $2,836.60 in special damages, the expenses they could count. Denny filed a counter-claim laying the blame on Permann’s driving. He too sought $75,000 in general damages, with $3,858.74 in special damages, and other members of his family joined him, all said to have been injured. The paper printed their names as “Elda Laurdie, Jo Lynn, Jean and Curtis Denny.”
Those names raise questions of their own. The spellings shift between the two reports, from Jolynn to Jo Lynn and from Laura Lee to Laurdie. Jean Denny was not on the 1964 hospital list. With no comma between Elda and Laurdie, it is unclear whether they were one person or two; if two, Elda may have been Mrs. Denny, listed first, though neither paper says so. On the Permann side, only one child was named among the injured in 1964, so whether John and Joni were also in the car is not known. Some of the people in this story may still be living, and for them it keeps to what the papers printed.
Judge Gus Carr Anderson had set a jury trial for Thursday, February 10, 1966. It never began. That day’s Journal reported that the two families, both described by then as living in the Pocatello area, had reached a settlement out of court. No terms were made public.
So no judge or jury ever said whose driving caused the crash on the snowy road north of Arbon. More of the valley’s hard days are gathered in Stories: Tragedies, but this one ended, fifteen months on, with the two families settling it between themselves.