Nobody in Power County paid more for roads and schools than the people of Crystal, and in the spring of 1924 some of them said they had little to show for it. On April 3 the American Falls Press carried their grievance on its front page. Their highway district, they said, had been run with no public oversight. No lawful election of its officers seemed to have taken place since the district began in 1918, and the men holding its offices had been appointed. The mail, the paper added, was “quite unsatisfactory.”
That mail came over the mountains. Letters from Pocatello reached Arbon Valley up Mink Creek canyon, across the divide into the Crystal country, and on to Pauline and Arbon. The divide was a county line as well. Pocatello and the canyon belonged to Bannock County, while Arbon Valley, part of Oneida County until 1913, now answered to Power County and its seat at American Falls. Anyone who went “over the top of Mink creek divide,” the Press told its readers in 1917, had crossed into Power County. In September of that year the paper’s traveling correspondent rode up the canyon with the mail carrier Lorin Bailey, whose route was the first mail route from Pocatello. In places, he wrote, the road was “so narrow that if two outfits ever meet one of them will have to back up to a wider part of the road.”
A district of its own
Crystal looked after its own roads. On May 27, 1918, its voters approved the Crystal Highway District, 63 to 0, a little more than two weeks before Arbon’s voters created Highway District No. 3. Arbon’s district and the 1919 highway from Pocatello are told in the first state highway. Crystal’s reached east as far as the Bannock County line, where the road came across from Pocatello.
Six years later the Crystal district’s money was always running short, and some of its taxpayers wanted its business handled “along more conventional lines.” The tax burden they spoke of was real. In 1922 the Press had found that two school districts lying inside the Crystal Highway District carried a combined levy of 35.6 mills, the heaviest of any common, or rural, school district in the county. A grand jury had called for an audit of the highway district’s books in the fall of 1923, but by report no one had made it. No later word of an audit or an election has turned up.
Tipped over and broken down
Cars and trucks brought the mail out from Pocatello. Theo Daniels of Pauline had held the Pocatello–Crystal–Pauline–Arbon route since 1922, by the account in the Daniels family history on this site. In late March 1924 the Pauline schoolchildren, who wrote a column of their own for the Press, told of two mishaps on the run. “Jewel Horten took the mail to Pocatello, March 17th,” they wrote. “On the way back the car tipped over hurting his arm.” Two days after that, going by the column’s dates, Daniels’s truck “broke down coming from Pocatello with the mail.” More on that corner of the valley is in the history of Pauline and West Fork.
The stage in Mink Creek
By 1925 the Arbon mail rode a motor stage between Pocatello and the valley. On Wednesday, September 2, 1925, headed for Crystal, the stage left the road and tumbled down an embankment into Mink Creek. A faulty steering rod was blamed. Mrs. Mose Fannin of Crystal was badly cut, and her daughter Ethel’s arm was broken. The baby was thrown into the creek, the Deseret News reported, and his sister pulled him out at once. The driver, whose name neither paper prints clearly enough to read with confidence, came through unhurt. The Fannins’ Crystal homestead had its own place on the road as a stage station, as told in the first stage lines, and the wreck has its own Stories entry, the Arbon stage goes off the road into Mink Creek.
Six miles through the forest
Bannock County wanted the canyon road rebuilt. In December 1926 its road supervisor, W. H. Hall, showed the county commissioners his letters about new sections of highway through the Cache National Forest along Mink Creek. He had urged H. W. Gregory, Idaho’s director of highways, to do all he could for a six-mile stretch through the forest. If the bureau of public works or the national forest service could find the money, Bannock County would help pay for the part running from south of Mink Creek to the forest boundary.
The need was pressing, Hall said, according to a Pocatello dispatch in the Salt Lake Tribune. “The heavy hauling of grain from the Arbon valley” and the Bannock Creek country had torn up the roads, and the star mail routes, run by contractors, gave another reason to hurry. The papers read for this post do not say whether the six miles were ever built.
Other ways out
Other towns had their eye on the valley’s trade. On October 12, 1925, the new directors of the American Falls chamber of commerce put on their winter program “the improvement of the mountain road to Arbon valley which is used for light traffic.” It ran by way of Sunbeam, a foothill district a few miles east of American Falls, and the meeting was told it “can be repaired sufficiently for light travel with the expenditure of a comparatively small sum.” There is no report that the repairs were made.
A good share of the wheat went north instead, across the Fort Hall Reservation to Michaud on the Oregon Short Line. Big trucks were already hauling it there from the grain platforms at Pauline in 1917. In January 1929 the new board of the Pocatello chamber of commerce took up a highway between Michaud and the Arbon Valley and named a committee to look into it, O. R. Baum and a Mr. Burton among its members. On March 19 Congressman Addison T. Smith sat down at Judge Baum’s home with the chamber’s president, Fred A. Burton, its secretary, Paul V. Nash, and C. A. Valentine. Along with water for the Michaud Flats, they talked over “getting a government appropriation to improve the Michaud to Arbon road,” and Smith promised to work with the local committee.
Whether any of these roads got their money, the papers read for this post do not say. Five years later the wheat was still taking its toll. In March 1934 Idaho’s governor, C. Ben Ross, was due to meet the federal Indian Service at Pocatello about a road across the reservation to carry the valley’s crops to market. The old one, he said, had been broken down by the wheat hauled over it every year.
The original article
American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
CRYSTAL PEOPLE
Are Dissatisfied With Administration of Highway Affairs—Now Pay Highest Road and School Tax in County With Little to Show for Expenditures.
Complaints have come in from Crystal highway district as to the administration of the business affairs of the district and the fact that no public supervision of the district has been given the taxpayers in that section of the county. It appears that there has [illegible] been a legal election held for highway district officals since the district was organized in 1918. Officials who have the offices since that time have been appointed.
The treasury has continually been in a more or less depleted state and some of the taxpayers in the district at least, feel that the affairs of the district should be run along more conventional lines. Crystal Highway District now pays the largest school and road tax of any section of the county. The mail service is reported to be quite unsatisfactory and the general feeling seems to be that action should be taken to stabilize business affairs of the community. The grand jury that was called last fall recommended that an audit be made of the Crystal Highway books but this, according to reports, has not been done.
Sources
- American Falls Press, October 3, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 18, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, October 9, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 13, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, June 25, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, July 30, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 21, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 4, 1925, page 9
- Deseret News, September 4, 1925, page 14
- American Falls Press, October 15, 1925, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 11, 1926, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 4, 1929, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 20, 1929, page 9
- Salt Lake Telegram, March 20, 1934, page 7
- Daniels family history, on this site
