The first time the valley’s papers printed Luther Estep’s name, it was over a small grave. The last time was over his own. In the fifty years between, he turned up only now and then, a line or two at a time, but those lines add up to the life of a farmer who came to Pauline from Kentucky and never left.
He died suddenly at American Falls on Monday, September 27, 1965, at 72, and the Idaho State Journal carried his obituary two days later. Though the paper gave American Falls as the place of death, he was an Arbon man.
From Kentucky by way of Illinois
Luther Martin Estep was born in Pulaski County, Kentucky, on November 23, 1892, a son of Jess and Amanda Burkhart Estep, and he grew up in that state. On February 20, 1914, he married Lucy M. Randall there. The young couple went first to Bloomington, Illinois, and stayed only a short while before heading on to Arbon Valley. Lucy’s brother, Oscar Randall, was already farming there, part of a group of settlers from the Somerset, Kentucky, country whose story is told in Somerset to Arbon.
Their arrival was marked by loss. In October 1915 their son Oscar, nine months old, died while being carried to Pocatello for a doctor, and he was laid to rest in the Pauline cemetery. The American Falls Press described his mother as “a recent arrival from Kentucky.” The baby’s death is retold in The long road to the doctor and among the Stories.
Hail, juries and a trial
The Esteps settled at the north end of the valley, in the Pauline and West Fork country. In 1917 the Press published the Power County men enrolled for the draft, and “Luther Martin Estep, Pauline” was on the list. That August a hailstorm came over from Landing into the valley, and the paper counted O. S. Randall, Luther Estep and Clint Miller among the farmers it hurt. The following spring an American Falls insurance agency ran an advertisement listing the 1917 hail claims it had settled, with a “Randall Estep” account named twice. That was likely a partnership of Luther with one of the Randalls, though the advertisement leaves it unsaid which one.
By 1920 he was doing his share of public duty. His name was on the Pauline jury list that spring. That summer he and Lucy, with a number of Pauline neighbors, put their names to the Nonpartisan League’s petitions, a story told in Pauline votes the League ticket. In November the county board made him a judge for the general election, and his name was drawn again for the 1921 jury list.
In the summer of 1921 the county paid Schwarz Brothers for a witness certificate of his that they had taken in. The county’s list leaves the case unnamed. Because the certificate sits among those of posse men who testified, it very likely came from the trial over the St. Patrick’s Day shootings near Pauline. What Estep said on the stand went unreported.
At least one winter the family spent in town. In April 1921 the Arbon column noted that the Esteps had gone back out to their place above Pauline after the cold months in American Falls.
In the children’s columns
During 1923 and 1924 the Pauline schoolchildren wrote their own news for the Press, as told in When Arbon Valley schoolchildren wrote the news, and the Esteps appear in their reports. In February 1924 the pupils sold hatchets tied with red ribbon at the store for a dollar apiece. The next line is partly garbled in the surviving copy but appears to credit Florence Estep’s mother with making them. Florence, very probably a daughter of Luther and Lucy, made the primary honor roll that March, and one young reporter passed along that “Luther Estep is going to start plowing next week.”
A son lost in Tunisia
After 1924 the papers searched for this story fall almost quiet about the family until the Second World War. At the close of 1940 the Pocatello Tribune named Luther Estep among the Arbon Valley and Crystal farmers who had signed for electric service at a meeting in the Pauline schoolhouse. In May 1942 he was put on the Arbon crew formed to fight rural fires.
The war took a son. Carl Estep, born at Arbon in 1918, had given his father’s name, Luther Martin Estep, on his draft card in 1940. He was reported missing in Tunisia on February 14, 1943. His story is among the Stories and in Arbon Valley men in uniform.
Another son, Luther Jr., known as Louie, married Eileen Ward in 1947, and the two farmed at Arbon until they retired. Their family is followed in The Wards between Malad and their Arbon farm, and her own obituary is at Eileen Ward Estep.
From renter to owner
The 1965 obituary filled in two things the older items never mentioned. Estep had begun by farming rented ground and in time bought land of his own, and he belonged to the Power County Grain Growers Association. It does not say where his farm was or when he bought it.
Davis Mortuary was in charge. Friends could call at the mortuary Thursday afternoon until 5 and Friday from 8 a.m. until the funeral, which was set for 2 p.m. Friday at the Methodist Church in American Falls. The Rev. Richard Frank Burdon was to conduct it, and burial would follow in Falls View Cemetery.
He was survived by Lucy; two sons, Luther Jr. of Arbon and Robert of Sequim, Washington; two daughters, Mrs. Ray (Beulah) Galloway of American Falls and Mrs. Richard (Maude) Chiaro of Pocatello; 17 grandchildren and four great-grandchildren. Also surviving were a brother, Harvey Estep of Bobtown, Kentucky; a sister, Alma Stogstill of Shopville, Kentucky; and two sisters in Cincinnati, Ohio, Myrtle Lovins and Della Ball. Because the obituary named only the living, it left out Oscar and Carl, and Florence too, who seems also to have died before her father.
He had come to the valley a young man burying a son. He left it with a son still farming at Arbon.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, September 29, 1965, page 2
- American Falls Press, October 28, 1915, page 7
- American Falls Press, July 10, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, August 10, 1917, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 9, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, April 16, 1920, page 6
- American Falls Press, August 20, 1920, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 22, 1920, page 5
- American Falls Press, February 11, 1921, page 8
- American Falls Press, April 8, 1921, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 22, 1921, page 11
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- Pocatello Tribune, December 31, 1940, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, May 8, 1942, page 7