For nearly three years of war in the Pacific, Ralph G. Butler kept a record of what he saw, though sailors were warned early on to write none of it down. In August 1944 he brought the little book home on leave and left it with his mother. Four months later his destroyer went down in a typhoon, and he went with her. Twenty-seven years on, the Idaho State Journal reported on November 24, 1971, the diary was being made ready for publication.
The editing had been done at Idaho State University. Dr. Mark McKiernan, an associate professor of history, worked on it with Arnold G. Buckendorf, a senior history major from Buhl, and the deputy director of naval history in the office of the Chief of Naval Operations in Washington, D.C., helped them. The plan was to print it in Idaho Yesterdays, the state’s quarterly of history. Whether it ever ran there, and where the diary is kept today, this site has not been able to confirm.
Kansas cousins on Bannock Creek
Ralph’s father, Dale Everett “Pete” Butler, was from Americus, Kansas, the youngest brother of J. W. Butler. J. W. was among the Kansas cousins who began homesteading on upper Bannock Creek south of Pauline in 1908, a story told on the Swim family page. Dale married Blenda C. Jones of Malad at Malad on November 16, 1916, and by a 1978 Journal notice of an open house for her eightieth birthday, the pair went out to his Arbon Valley homestead on their wedding day. Family records on this site put that claim in the late-surveyed corner between Pauline and Rattlesnake Creek, with a patent dated June 5, 1919.
The 1971 article tied Dale to a place it called Idahome, in Arbon Valley. Older papers put an Idahome out in the Raft River country west of the valley, and nobody has yet explained how the name came to be pinned on Arbon Valley.
Early in 1920 the American Falls Press carried one line of local news: a son born to “Mr. and Mrs. Dale Butler of Pauline,” at the hospital on Christmas Eve. The baby went unnamed. Ralph, the 1971 story said, enlisted in December 1941, just after Pearl Harbor, and turned 22 within days of joining, which would put his birth between roughly mid-December 1919 and the first days of 1920. The Christmas Eve boy was very likely Ralph, though no record found for this site gives his name.
Most of the Kansas kin moved on, but the Butlers stayed. The census of 1930 counted Dale and Blenda in the Crystal precinct. Farming remained their living for most of the years after, the 1978 notice said, with spells at Lava Hot Springs and American Falls, before they settled in Pocatello in 1950. Dale died in June 1959. Of Ralph’s boyhood in the valley, nothing more has surfaced in the papers searched.
Coral Sea to the Komandorskis
The diary followed Ralph across much of the Pacific war. Its battle pages, by the paper’s account, covered the Coral Sea, where the Navy lost the carrier Lexington, and Midway, where the Yorktown was crippled, along with Tarawa, Guam, the Gilberts, the Marshalls and the Solomons, as well as duty in Alaskan waters. Other entries were about life aboard ship and the South Pacific islands, which struck him as lovely even in wartime. One told how glad he was to see the lights of San Francisco on his way home.
Most of those names line up with the record of the USS Monaghan, the destroyer where Ralph served as a gunner’s mate; the paper spelled it “Monoghan.” Naval histories have her screening the Lexington in the Coral Sea campaign of May 1942, though she was detached to carry messages before the carriers fought, and reaching the damaged Yorktown at Midway that June. She served in the Aleutians, fought at the Komandorski Islands in March 1943, and went on to the Gilberts landings, the Marshalls and Guam. The article never says when Ralph went aboard, but he likely served on her for much of the war. After Guam she went to Puget Sound for an overhaul in the late summer of 1944, close to the time of his leave.
McKiernan, in a foreword, made the case that people with small, unseen parts in history often see it best. Ralph’s pages counted, he wrote, because they came from a sailor in the thick of the fighting with “little control over his own destiny.” The young man had decided what he witnessed deserved a place in history and set it down anyway.
Lost in Typhoon Cobra
On December 18, 1944, the Monaghan was guarding fleet oilers headed to refuel the Third Fleet’s carriers when the storm now called Typhoon Cobra hit. She lost power and steering, capsized and sank before noon. Three days later six of her men were picked up alive; about 256 died. The Hull and the Spence, two more destroyers, sank in the same storm. The 1971 article counted 765 dead in the three ships, while histories of the typhoon put the fleet’s losses nearer 790.
Blenda Butler was living in Pocatello by 1971, and it was she who had lent her son’s diary to McKiernan to be published. Her 1978 birthday notice listed six children: Morgan, George, Maxine and DeRene, and two sons who had died before her, Ralph and Cliff. Ralph is one of the valley’s sons lost in the Second World War, and others who served are listed among Arbon Valley men in uniform, 1941–1946. If your family remembers him, or knows where his diary ended up, the site would be glad to hear from you.
He had been told not to keep it. Because he did, and left it with his mother, his account of the war outlasted both him and his ship.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, November 24, 1971, page 63
- American Falls Press, January 2, 1920, page 5
- Idaho State Journal, January 4, 1978, page 20
- American Falls Press, November 16, 1917, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 2, 1920, page 1
- Oakley Herald, November 16, 1923, page 1
- History of War: USS Monaghan (DD-354)
- Wikipedia: USS Monaghan (DD-354)