Sim Hatch put down his clippers for good in the fall of 1971 and locked the door of his barber shop at Arimo. He told the Idaho State Journal that quitting would be harder on him than on the men who sat in his chair. But when correspondent Fern Hartvigsen sat down to write up his working life, the part that reached back furthest had nothing to do with haircuts. Before the First World War, he and his brother Abe ran horses in Bannock Valley and then on Dairy Creek, in the hills to the east, and for a few years they meant to make their fortune there.
Most of the profile, which ran on November 8, 1971, belongs to Marsh Valley. Short items in the valley papers of the 1910s, and the government land records, fill in the Arbon side of his story.
A Moreland boy and the sheep
Sim was born at Orangeville, Utah, the fourth of eight children of Abe and Emma Miles Hatch, who moved the family to Moreland in 1895. He grew up there. In 1908 he first saw Marsh Valley, in charge of three bands of sheep that came by rail to McCammon and were then walked to Crystal Springs to graze. A Blackfoot sheep company hired him next, though its five stallions took more of his time than its sheep did. After that he married Teresa England, a Moreland girl.
He was willing, he said, to take on “anything that was honorable.” Over the years that meant every rung of the sheep business, from herder and shearer to owner, along with farming and raising cattle and horses. He rode ditches for the Portneuf Marsh Valley Canal Company and on the Mink Creek cattle reserve, and he spent about eight years in the saddle for the forest reserve.
Hatches at Pauline
He did not tell Hartvigsen when he and Abe came over the hills, but the papers place them in the valley by the summer of 1914. On July 30 that year the American Falls Press printed the Power County bills, and among the valley men paid for road work were A. M. Hatch, Sim Hatch and Jerry Hatch.
The following winter a valley correspondent sent word that Noble, whose family had kept the Pauline post office, had made a barber shop of the building beside his store, and that callers should let the “tonsorial artist, Sim Hatch” give them a trim. The post office itself had gone from the Nobles to the Kowallis home in 1914, as told among the firsts. The 1971 article put the start of Sim’s barbering in 1939, but he was cutting hair at Pauline almost twenty-five years before that.
Family turned up in the columns too. In June 1915 the Moreland news in the Blackfoot Idaho Republican said Jennie Lindson was home from a visit with her sister, Mrs. A. M. Hatch, “of Arbon, Idaho.” When the Press listed Power County’s draft registrants in July 1917, three Hatches gave Pauline as home: Jeremiah, Simmons Franklin and Abram Miles. Simmons Franklin was Sim. Abram Miles, with his mother’s maiden name in the middle, was almost surely Abe. The 1971 article never mentions Jerry, but genealogical records list him as another son of Abram Hatch of Moreland, so he was probably a third brother.
A hundred and thirty horses
The Journal gave the valley years only a few lines, but Sim was plain about what had brought the brothers there. They had 130 horses, and the ground they took in Bannock Valley, which the article also called Arbon Valley, was a place to keep them; crops came a long way second. At first they held it jointly with no more than a squatter’s right. They made improvements and later sold it to Ed Snyder.
Which Ed Snyder is an open question. The valley had two: the Ed Snyder who married Hannah Evans and farmed southwest of Arbon, and a younger man at Crystal. An Edward C. Snyder received a 280-acre homestead patent in 1921 in sections 3 and 4, beside Abe’s claim, and a Charles Edward Snyder of Crystal signed up for the draft in 1917. The evidence leans toward the Crystal man without settling it.
From Bannock Valley the brothers moved on to homesteads on Dairy Creek, and there they took up cattle as well. Of the 100 mares they ran on that range, most were saddle stock. The horse trade of those years is traced in Horses and the first tractors, 1916–1922, and the open range they used in When Bannock Valley was cattle range.
The families came and went with the seasons. Jerry Hatch took his family to Arimo for the winter in November 1917. On January 8, 1918, the Pauline column noted that Abe had come out from Keever to see to stock left on his ranch near Pauline, and in April the Press reported the Hatch brothers back in with their families after wintering at Keever. In October 1919 the Moreland column of the Republican told of the Hatch brothers driving their cattle up out of Bannock Valley on a Sunday.
The land office supplies the dates Sim left out. In June 1919 Abe, written as Avram M. Hatch, and Jerry B. Hatch were granted homestead patents on adjoining land on the Pauline side, in sections 4 and 9 of township 10 south, range 34 east. Jerry’s land later went into the Lusk ranch. Abe got a second patent in 1926. That same year Sim received 160 acres under the homestead law in Oneida County, and in 1929 he added a 480-acre stock-raising homestead there. All three claims sit in the high ground east of Arbon near the head of Dairy Creek, which flows southeast toward what is now Daniels Reservoir. They are likely the Dairy Creek homesteads he remembered, though none of the records consulted names the creek.
Broke after the war
The brothers also bought land at Garden Creek. Then came the depression that followed the First World War, and it bankrupted them both. Abe went back to Moreland. By November 1922 he was giving Robin as his address when he and W. E. Jordan of Moreland put a notice in the Press for three young black horses and a mule colt, strayed somewhere “between Rock Springs and where Rattlesnake creek empties into Bannock creek.” Sim held on, and in time bought the Quill Farr place at Garden Creek, which the Utah Mortgage and Loan Company was selling. The patents of 1926 and 1929 suggest the Dairy Creek claims outlasted the bad years, but when the Hatches last ran stock there is not known.
The barber of Arimo
Teresa died in 1933. Two years later Sim married Mable Brady, a widow, and each brought four children into the marriage; by 1971 the family counted 36 grandchildren and 38 great-grandchildren. Mable owned the Arimo flour mill and elevator, and for a time Sim ran them. Together they went into Shetland ponies, buying as far off as Texas. They added a small registered black stallion and bought out the whole string of a pony-ride outfit at Vernal, Utah. In 1962 they sold the last of the ponies to a family at Dillon, Montana.
The barbering the Journal dated from 1939 began with a course at a barber school in Boise and an apprenticeship under Hal Ragan at McCammon. For years Sim split each week, three days in McCammon and two in Arimo, until he sold the McCammon shop about three years before he quit. A few young men whose first haircuts he had given came home from the service or from missions with their hair grown out, saving the job for him.
In 1971 he and Mable lived at Arimo, and Sim still kept a garden. The horses were long gone, but the man who had once run 130 of them over the Arbon hills still had his hands in the ground.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, November 8, 1971, page 11
- American Falls Press, July 30, 1914, page 2
- American Falls Press, February 4, 1915, page 5
- Idaho Republican, June 11, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, July 10, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, November 9, 1917, page 8
- American Falls Press, January 8, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 9, 1918, page 3
- Idaho Republican, October 3, 1919, page 2
- American Falls Press, November 16, 1922, page 5
- Homestead patent to Avram M. Hatch, June 3, 1919 (IDBL 0030417)
- Homestead patent to Jerry B. Hatch, June 3, 1919 (IDBL 0030418)
- Homestead patent to Edward C. Snyder, May 19, 1921 (IDBL 0030501)
- Homestead patent to Simmons F. Hatch, January 14, 1926 (IDBL 0030409)
- Homestead patent to Abram M. Hatch, May 6, 1926 (IDBL 0030746)
- Stock-raising homestead patent to Simmons F. Hatch, November 18, 1929 (IDBL 0035142)