The fire for the irons was going early on the morning the neighbors came to Sod Williams’s ranch. About a dozen of them helped him put up portable corrals and push the herd inside, and by the time the dust was rising they were roping calves the way Arbon Valley had always done it. Somewhere else, Sod said, that kind of work was turning into “a lost art.”
Tom Shanahan wrote and photographed the day for the Idaho State Journal in Pocatello, which gave it a full page on June 30, 1978. The paper did not say which day in the spring it had been.
By then the Arbon ranchers had made a custom of branding together. Every spring they combined their crews and worked through the herds one ranch after another until every herd was done. By the Journal’s tally, they would mark close to 1,200 head that year.
The Williams place
Sod Williams was Donald Thayne Williams (1922–2001). He and his wife Nelda, a daughter of the Ward family, had ranched at Arbon since the years after the Second World War. In 1978 Sod and their son Barry ran Simmental cattle, a breed the family was among the first to bring into southern Idaho. He was a horseman as much as a cattleman. From 1956 to 1970 the Utah papers kept track of him as a quarter-horse breeder, a show-ring rider and a teacher of reining, as told in Sod Williams of Arbon and his quarter horses and The Williams family of Arbon in the arena.
Rope, iron and needle
Once the cattle were penned, the work divided. Barry Williams and a few other ranchers rode in among the calves, which were two to six weeks old, roped them one at a time and dragged each across to the men on foot. The ground crew pinned the calf while Sod set the brand and another rancher gave it its shot. It was hot, dusty work.
Shanahan’s pictures caught Sod with an iron ready and Sherm Swim with his loop swinging over the calves. Sherm was very likely Sherman Hale Swim of the Swim family, then in his mid-fifties and running cattle in the valley himself. Another photo showed Louie Estep and Gail Wood holding a calf down for the iron. The paper called them ranching neighbors and left it there, but the site’s Ward family page lists Nelda’s sister Eileen as Mrs. Louie Estep of Arbon, so Louie was probably Sod’s brother-in-law. The page also printed two brands without saying whose they were, and the rest of the crew went unnamed.
At noon the work stopped for sloppy joes made by Sod’s wife and his daughter-in-law, whose name the paper did not give, with beer and soda on ice.
A way of life
Branding, as Williams put it, had two sides: the crew had a good time at it, and everyone was glad when it was finished. Plenty of ranchers elsewhere had gone over to chutes and other gear built to hurry the job along. In Arbon the neighbors kept to their ropes and kept trading days on each other’s places, and Sod was proud of how hard they worked and said they were “proud to help our neighbors out.”
He did not think his kind would last. Ranching was losing its romance and turning into a business, he said, and a business pressed its people to modernize. A real cowman, in his telling, gave himself to the work so completely that little else had room. What he hoped for was that the stories of the older ranchers would keep the open-range life, and the neighborliness that came with it, in memory.
At the Fourth of July rodeo
Within days Sod was roping in town. Pocatello’s Fourth of July Rodeo at the Bannock County Fairgrounds was put on that year by the city’s LDS West Stake. The Journal’s results for Monday night, July 3, listed Sod Williams of Arbon Valley in both of the Old Timers events, calf roping and steer stopping. The Tuesday results, printed July 5, put him first in each: 16.7 seconds on his calf, 7.5 on his steer. Old Timers events were open to ropers fifty and over. Two years later, in June 1980, the Journal noted that Sherm Swim had won the Old Timers roping title at the same celebration in 1979. His death in 2011 is noted among the valley’s Stories.
The art Sod feared for was slow to go. A 2010 post on branding found the valley still roping, throwing and branding its calves with the neighbors pitching in, more than thirty years after he called it a lost art.