For most of 1982, the fate of the little Arbon elementary school hung on a question of farm taxes. On the last day of the year, word came out of American Falls that the question had been settled.
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints owned 6,742 acres in Arbon Valley, more than ten square miles of land. Power County wanted property taxes on it, and the church argued the farm should be exempt. The Associated Press reported from the county seat that the church had given way and would pay, and the Salt Lake Tribune ran the dispatch on December 31 beneath the headline “LDS to Pay Taxes on Farm.” It is the only account of the dispute found so far, and in the archive’s machine-read copy its columns run together with the television listings and other stories on the page, so the story below is pieced back together from what can be read.
A welfare farm or an investment
The trouble began in February 1982, when the church asked the county to exempt the Arbon farm from taxes. The dispatch never gives the county’s answer. But by December the church had an appeal pending before the state Board of Tax Appeals, so the county had most likely said no.
Ben Cavaness, the county’s deputy prosecuting attorney, explained what the county disliked. The church had hired the man who used to own the land to run the farm, he said, and only part of what the farm earned went to welfare, the church’s program for people in need. By tradition, the dispatch noted, a welfare farm belonged to the members of a local ward, a Latter-day Saint congregation, who worked it and paid its costs out of their own pockets. Who that former owner was, and when or how the church came to hold the land, the report does not say.
The fight soon spread to a second farm. The church also ran a welfare farm on Michaud Flats, close to the Pocatello airport, and that farm had gone untaxed for two years. When the Arbon exemption request came in that February, the commissioners took away the Michaud Flats farm’s tax-free standing as well.
Meeting halfway
By late December, Cavaness said, the two sides had come to terms. The church had already put a check for $4,292 in the mail, half the tax due on the Arbon land. It would give up seeking an exemption there and drop its state appeal, and the farm would be moved over among the church’s investment holdings, which are taxed. The county, for its part, would give the Michaud Flats welfare farm its exemption back.
The deal still needed a final vote from the county commissioners, who were expected to take it up at their next meeting. Commissioner Louise Bauer said that week that she was “not in favor of it,” though she thought it would stand and would quiet the matter for the present. She hoped the church would keep the farm among its income-producing property and not ask for an exemption again. Whether the commissioners did approve it at that meeting is not recorded in the dispatch.
Cavaness said the settlement had, in effect, ended the fear that the Arbon school would have to close. The report never spells out how the tax fight had put the school in danger, or how much of the district’s money the farm’s taxes made up. Valley families may remember, and the local papers of 1982 and 1983 may hold the rest.
Still open
The school outlasted the quarrel. In 2016 KPVI News 6 reported that the 16 students at Arbon Elementary had spent close to three years raising $12,000 to tear out a badly cracked blacktop and pour a concrete playground, much of it from the Idaho Lottery’s Scratch for Schools program and the rest from other fundraising; the site keeps a reprint of that story. The district’s notices turn up here too, among them the 2014 supplemental levy election.
There is more on the Arbon area and on the valley’s first school and other firsts, and School memories has a photograph of the Arbon school taken about 1980, around the time its future rode on a church farm’s tax bill.