About 35 people crowded into the Bannock County courthouse on the afternoon of June 17, 1969, and roughly a dozen of them took the stand with the same request. They farmed, ranched, hauled and stored grain in the country west of Pocatello, and they wanted the state to give Bannock Creek and Truckersville back the full freeway interchange it had just taken away.
The freeway was Interstate 15-W, the branch running west from Pocatello toward American Falls. Its next piece, about seven and a half miles across Fort Hall Reservation land and estimated at $2.6 million, would close the gap between the western end of the finished road outside Pocatello and the Igo overpass short of American Falls. For eight to ten years, a Power County Highway District man told the hearing, the plans had shown a full interchange at Bannock Creek, where the blacktop from Arbon Valley comes down along the creek.
A plan redrawn
That spring the state and the Shoshone-Bannock Tribal Council talked the route over, and the full interchange moved to Gasline Road, roughly three and a half miles farther west on the reservation. The Idaho State Journal later wrote that the tribe had asked for the move; the papers give no reasons for it. The state said it could not pay for two full interchanges, so Bannock Creek and the Truckersville road would get only an overpass. Power County was to build a three-quarter-mile county road south of the freeway with federal secondary-road money, tying that overpass to the Bannock Creek highway. From there valley drivers would take frontage roads east to the airport interchange or west to Gasline Road.
The first public protest came from Lamond “Buck” Bailey. On May 4 the Journal’s “Buzz of the Burg” column ran his letter, written to his neighbors in Arbon Valley and on Bannock Creek and to the Michaud families east of the creek. His full name, nickname and valley land all match the Buck Bailey on the Bailey family page, so he is almost certainly the man who grew up on his father’s Arbon Valley homestead; by 1969 he also ranched on Michaud Flats.
For fifty years or more, Bailey wrote, anyone heading from the valley to Highway 30 had gone the long way around by the Schiller or Rudeen crossing, and the new plan only traded those detours for frontage roads. The valley’s oiled farm-to-market road climbed up from Snowville and Malad, crossed Arbon Valley and followed Bannock Creek down, and now it would dead-end at the freeway. He suspected special interests were behind the change, reminded readers that Rockland had been given an interchange, and asked whether they would settle for “second class.”
His readers knew those crossings well. Schiller was one of the railroad sidings where the valley’s wheat was loaded, the scene of the 1923 buying war at Schiller, and the road down Bannock Creek had been fought over across reservation land since the road controversy of 1915 and through the wheat road of the 1930s.
A day at the courthouse
The State Highway Board called its hearing for June 17. Wayne Summers, the department’s executive secretary, came up from Boise to run it with Orion Grunerud, the Pocatello district engineer. Grunerud put the price of a second full interchange at about $100,000 more. Idaho, he said, usually set its interstate interchanges six to eight miles apart, and that was about the distance between the airport interchange and Gasline Road.
The witnesses answered with trucks. Traffic at the creek, they said, came off Arbon Valley farms, out of the General Mills elevator and the Power County Grain Growers’ Association elevator, and from the Zimmerle warehouse and the potato warehouses along the Union Pacific near the creek. Blaine Shoemaker, a Pocatello rancher, counted 21,000 truckloads of beets bound for Idaho Falls, plus 7,000 of potatoes and 1,600 of grain, and said Bannock Creek carried more traffic than Gasline Road. State Representative S. Albert Johnson pointed out that every one of those crops left by truck.
Bailey spoke as well. Deeded Indian land north of the freeway line already had 16,000 acres under water, he said, and the north end of Arbon Valley looked for water on another 8,000. Produce trucks used Truckersville Road to reach Syphon Road and U.S. 191 to the north. He, Shoemaker and others called the one existing link, a narrow gravel road cutting across to the airport interchange, a hazard.
Bob Ewing of the American Falls Chamber of Commerce welcomed the Gasline Road interchange but said Bannock Creek had earned one too. Bob Ward, who owned Truckersville, and Weaver Douglas, who held property close by, both said the state’s right-of-way agents had promised them a full interchange. Russell Lindley, speaking for the Power County Highway District and the man who recalled eight to ten years of plans, faulted the state for dropping them.
Colman Paniogue, a Shoshone-Bannock tribal member from Michaud Flats, also asked for the interchange, and he made plain that he spoke only for himself, not for the Tribal Council. Without one at Truckersville, he said, the people who leaned on that road hardest would be the ones shortchanged. No one came to speak for the tribe.
Vince Schimmler of Boise, the area man for the federal Bureau of Public Roads, said the call for roads to airports was growing everywhere in the country, not only in Idaho. To Shoemaker’s traffic figures he replied that social and economic needs weighed in alongside the count of vehicles.
Summers promised a ruling later in the summer and left the record open for letters through July 1. LeRoy Lindley, a Power County commissioner, said the commissioners would send one.
Yes from Washington
The board came around by late July and said it would back a second interchange. Its supporters gathered the figures, and the board took them to the Bureau of Public Roads. On September 23, 1969, board chairman C. Ed Flandro announced the answer: a full interchange at Bannock Creek and Truckersville, on top of the one at Gasline Road.
It was an exception, Flandro said, since federal practice would normally allow a single full interchange on a stretch that short. He set the extra cost at more than $100,000, most of it federal money. He shared the credit among farmers, industry and the Bureau of Indian Affairs, and thanked the Indian bureau most warmly of all. The Journal noted that the American Falls Chamber of Commerce, the American Falls school board and the City of Pocatello had joined the request, and that the airport commission had pressed the city council to back it.
The rest of the spring plan held. Power County would still build its three-quarter-mile road from the interchange over the Union Pacific tracks to the Bannock Creek–Arbon Valley road, with a signal proposed at the crossing. Cattle would get their own trail under the freeway along the west bank of the creek, and the creek itself, where it ran through the construction, would get a concrete-lined channel.
The 1969 forecasts called for bids late that year or in the spring of 1970 and construction in 1970, but the interchange work went out to bid later than that. By August 1971 the job was two concrete underpasses, one at Gasline Road and one at Truckersville Road, and the Journal reported Goodwin Construction Co. of Blackfoot as the apparent low bidder at $430,407. The papers read for this story do not say when the interchanges opened or when the county road was done.
The valley’s road down Bannock Creek, and the ranchers of Arbon who had argued for it, would not stop at the freeway after all.