On a Saturday in September 1910, Mrs. Jennie Price came down out of Bannock Valley to put her daughter on the train for Twin Falls. She stopped in at American Falls while she was there, and the American Falls Press took note: the woman from Arbon was the Republican choice for treasurer of Oneida County, and she was pleased with how the primary had gone.
The valley, known today as Arbon Valley, still belonged to Oneida County in those years, and the county was run from Malad. Power County would not be carved out until 1913.
A ballot of women
Every person who wanted to be county treasurer that summer was a woman. On August 13 the Press ran the county auditor’s official notice of the August 30 primary, naming each candidate who had filed, with party, office and home town. Three Republicans sought the treasurer’s post: Mrs. Lucy Davis and Maggie Wilks, both of Malad, and Mrs. Jennie Price of Arbon. The lone Democrat was Cora Dudley, also of Malad. Maggie Wilks already held the office, as the county board’s records from the next spring make plain.
Idaho women had been voting since 1896, and the same notice showed women in the statewide contest for superintendent of public instruction.
The method was new as well. Idaho’s direct primary law put the choice of each party’s nominees in the hands of voters rather than party leaders, and that week the Press reprinted a Boise Statesman editorial warning that the law was on trial across the state. With the vote less than three weeks off, the Idaho Supreme Court held that in any race with more than two candidates, a voter must mark a second choice along with a first. When nobody reached a majority, the two were added together. The Republican fight for treasurer, with its three names, was a race of exactly that kind.
“Entirely competent”
No tally from the primary has turned up, but Mrs. Price came out the nominee. When she came to town on September 17, the Press spoke warmly of her. She was, the paper said, “entirely competent,” and deserved the voters’ consideration as a woman working to make a living “under adverse circumstances” on a new farm. It named neither the daughter nor the hardships.
The November election went the other way. The Press published the county’s corrected returns precinct by precinct on November 26, but the scan of that table is unreadable, so her count remains unknown. The result shows up the following spring. On April 29, 1911, the paper printed the commissioners’ proceedings, in which the board accepted the report of Maggie Wilks as former treasurer and directed that the money in her office’s bank account go to Cora Dudley, county treasurer. The Democrat had taken the seat.
The homesteader on the West Fork
The paper never gave her more than “Mrs. Jennie Price.” She was most likely Jennett Daniels Price, daughter of the Welsh pioneer Thomas Daniels of Malad. Family-tree records gathered for this site call her Jennie, and the Daniels family history follows Jennett, her brothers and the next generation on the West Fork. On March 12, 1901, she filed the first homestead entry on record for the West Fork township, listing Arbon as her residence. She went on to prove up, living on and working the land as the homestead law demanded, and the patent was issued in her own name on May 4, 1909, as told among the Valley firsts. The Pauline and West Fork area history describes the Big Meadows, where the family took up land.
The identification is not certain. Malad had more than one family named Price. A “new farm in a new locality” fits her only loosely, since she had filed on the West Fork land nine years earlier, though her patent was barely more than a year old. One family-tree record says she was Oneida County treasurer for several years; the papers read here show her running in 1910 but not serving.
Five years on, the paper still placed her in the valley. On July 22, 1915, the Press noted that Mrs. Jennie Price of Arbon had been in town early in the week and started home on Tuesday morning.
The original article
American Falls Press, September 17, 1910, page 6. Transcribed from the page scan.
Mrs. Jennie Price, nominee for treasurer on the Republican ticket, was here from her home at Arbon Saturday. She came down to bring her daughter to the railroad, the latter leaving for her home at Twin Falls. Mrs. Price is much gratified at the vote she received at the primaries. She is deserving of every consideration at the hands of the voters of the county, being entirely competent, and struggling under adverse circumstances to make a living on a new farm in a new locality.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 13, 1910, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 13, 1910, page 11
- American Falls Press, August 13, 1910, page 12
- American Falls Press, September 17, 1910, page 6
- American Falls Press, November 26, 1910, page 7
- American Falls Press, April 29, 1911, page 4
- American Falls Press, July 22, 1915, page 5
- Women’s suffrage in the United States, Wikipedia
