Six lines in a country correspondent’s column were enough for the editor of the American Falls Press. On August 31, 1911, the Arbon news reported nine threshing machines at work in the valley behind some forty headers, with still more headers wanted for next year. To most readers it was a routine item. To a man who had first seen Arbon less than three years before, it was the whole story of a settlement coming into its own, and he said so on the front page.
The paper kept close watch on the Arbon harvest that year, from the guesses of July to the wheat wagons still on the road in December. Arbon was the old Bannock Valley, lying south of American Falls and Pocatello. In 1911 it belonged to Oneida County, and it would not become part of the new Power County until 1913. It was dry-farming land, and newcomers were still arriving to take it up.
Steam comes to the valley
The machinery came first. Writing on January 14, the Arbon correspondent noted that “a thirty-two horse power engine threshing machine and plow attachment and saw mill rigging arrived here during the holidays.” By March the Dawson brothers were plowing with steam. The site’s research makes them probably J. D. and W. E. Dawson. No paper ties their outfit to the January engine, but it was likely the same one, since by September the brothers were also leasing out a sawmill. The site’s Stories pages tell of the valley’s first steam engine and steam thresher.
A guess at 200,000 bushels
On Sunday, July 16, a carload of American Falls people motored around Bannock Peak. The Press ran their account on the front page of July 20, next to a look at the Arbon crop. Their neighbors figured that four farmers, G. S. Butler, John Butler, G. W. Allard and Mr. Keeler, “all new settlers,” would “have 25,000 bushels of wheat to market this fall.” Three years before, the forty-odd families then in the valley had grown perhaps 45,000 bushels all told. “This year estimates run as high as 200,000 bushels.” John Payne, who kept the store, thought 150,000 to 200,000 bushels would have to be hauled out. The writer looked ahead to the day the valley would ship a million bushels a year, and he saw the difficulty coming: “The marketing of their grain is a growing problem.”
Nine threshers
By the last day of August the heading was almost finished. The column counted roughly forty headers in the valley and nine threshers, three of them driven by steam. A header clipped only the heads off the standing grain, and these were stacked until a threshing machine could reach them. The Dawsons had put through 800 bushels in six hours.
That was the paragraph the editor seized on, under the headline “Tells a Story in Few Words.” Thirty-one and a half months earlier, on his first visit, Arbon had held about forty families, and a single threshing machine could have finished their whole crop if the grain had all been gathered in one place. Since then four men had come in and harvested some 25,000 bushels between them. “The people of Arbon have made a record of which they may well be proud,” he wrote. In fairness he added that Landing, Rockland, Pleasant Valley and the farms close around American Falls had kept pace.
Seven bushels a minute
On Friday, September 8, the editor drove out to Vic Randall’s farm, where the Dawson machine was threshing, and wrote it up on September 14 as “Seven Bushels a Minute.” He watched the big self-feeder, run by a large traction engine, pour out Turkey Red wheat at that rate while he stood there. A horse working a big fork lifted the grain off the stack to the men feeding it. Randall’s ground was running near thirty bushels to the acre, and when the machine pulled out he had 1,224 bushels of Turkey Red, a hard winter wheat, off forty acres. The editor could see two more outfits working within sight, “but time to visit them was lacking.”
Not every farmer waited his turn for a hired crew. J. E. Keeler Co. hauled a new machine out from American Falls. It was probably the self-feeder belonging to “Butler, Keeler, Swim et al.” that a man from the Case company looked over on September 15. Eight men ran it, the grain hauler among them, “all the labor being performed by parties interested in the machine,” and the paper judged that threshing the partners’ own crops that season would more than cover its price. The partners were most likely Ed Keeler, Frank Swim and one of the Butlers, G. S. or John, with others left unnamed. Both the Butlers and the Swims turn up in the Swim family history.
Julius Abter ran the machine owned by J. T. Guthrie. William Ferguson brought his over from Malad, and the site counts it as the first thresher at the south end of the valley. The same pages cover the first harvesting machines to reach Arbon.
The returns
The yields came in on September 28. G. W. Houke had 1,844 bushels off 80 acres. E. H. Davis had 3,076 bushels from his dry farm. J. N. Arbon had 3,256, some of his land making close to 34 bushels an acre and some only 17. Both men’s families are traced in the Arbon and Davis histories. “Arbon valley is a fine dry farming district and a fine place to live, as there is no sickness here,” the correspondent added.
E. E. Zaring, who bought grain at American Falls, returned that week with contracts for many thousands of bushels. Threshing had all but stopped, he said, while the farmers got their fall seeding in. The same issue had Turkey Red at $1.25, against $1.05 three weeks earlier, on orders from Kansas buyers for about twenty-five cars. The scanned text is too damaged to tell whether the price was by the bushel or by the hundredweight.
Fifty teams at one camp
Getting the wheat out took the rest of the year. In November I. H. Nash, once the Oneida County assessor, told readers of the Malad Enterprise he had seen in the Press that “wheat is being hauled from Arbon in such quantities that 50 loaded teams were seen at one camping place at one time.” The Caldwell Tribune picked up his words on November 24 and declared that “Dry land farming is at last a success in Idaho.” The Press item Nash had read has not turned up.
On December 7 the Press told of forty Arbon farmers rolling into Michaud, a siding on the railroad between American Falls and Pocatello, with about 160,000 pounds of wheat, close to 2,700 bushels. They traveled together as one wagon train and loaded the cars “so that they will not have to stand on the tracks.” Not many years before, the paper observed, a train like that would have carried away everything the valley grew. Now it barely dented the pile.
The papers searched for this post never give a final figure for the 1911 crop, so the July numbers stand only as estimates. The Arbon area history follows the valley past that year. What the editor read in six lines, forty farmers at Michaud showed with their wagons: Arbon was growing more wheat than it could haul away.
The original article
American Falls Press, August 31, 1911, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
Tells a Story in Few Words.
A six line paragraph in the Arbon correspondence this week tells a wonderful story of development. It merely states that nine threshers are at work following forty headers, and that more headers will be needed next year. To one unacquainted with the situation these lines are almost meaningless, yet to one who first saw the Arbon country less than three years ago, they speak volumes.
At that time the settlement contained about forty families, and the season’s yield of grain was estimated at 45,000 bushels. This year four men, all of whom have gone there since the writer made his first trip there, thirty-one and a half months ago, have harvested about 25,000 bushels. Now nine threshing outfits are at work in the valley, and 40 headers will not be able to harvest next year’s crop. Three years ago not many headers were required, and one threshing machine, had the grain all been collected to save frequent moves, would have made short work of the whole job.
The correspondent caught the spirit of development. Elsewhere he refers to a man with twenty large stacks of grain, to headers in operation, to new settlers who came only last April having large fields ready for seeding—even an entire stranger can not help catching glimpses of enterprize and development from such information. The people of Arbon have made a record of which they may well be proud. Yet their record has been duplicated at Landing at Rockland, in the Pleasant Valley settlement, and in the country directly surrounding American Falls. On the irrigated tract Aberdeen, Springfield and Sterling are keeping apace, and as soon as the farmers can recover from the burdens imposed by rapid and extensive development this will be one of the most prosperous sections of the west.
The number of threshers at Arbon has a counterpart, in indicating development, in the other new country south and west of American Falls. Two years ago the first combine came to the country. Now there are seven or eight, and more will be needed next year.
Sources
- American Falls Press, January 14, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 11, 1911, page 4
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 31, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 31, 1911, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 14, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 21, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 4
- Caldwell Tribune, November 24, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 7, 1911, page 1
