Charlotte Dawson’s claim was more than five years old when her name went into the American Falls Press in January 1914. She had filed on the northeast quarter of section 21, township 10 south, range 33 east, on November 25, 1908. Lawrence E. Dawson had filed on the northwest quarter beside it two months later. Now the land office at Blackfoot gave notice that both would make “final three year proof” on March 3, 1914, before Theo Turner, the U.S. commissioner at Pocatello. Each named the other as a witness, along with Albert Thompson, James D. Dawson and William E. Dawson, all of Arbon. The notice ran weekly from January 15 to February 19.
It was one of dozens of such notices the Press printed from 1909 to 1914, and read together they show how the valley’s homestead claims became owned land, and which neighbours stood up for one another. Until 1913 Arbon lay in Oneida County; that year it went into the new Power County.
A claim, not a deed
Filing a homestead entry gave a settler a claim on government land but not the title. The patent came only after final proof, when the settler showed, with witnesses, that he or she had lived on the place and farmed it for the full time the law required. Every proof was announced weeks in advance, and every notice named four neighbours who would swear to the claimant’s “continuous residence upon and cultivation of said lands.”
A settler could finish in one of two ways. One was to stay the whole term, then five years. Nephi Jenson of Arbon, as the notices spelled him (probably Nephi Jensen of a north-end family), filed in May 1906, and in October 1911 he gave notice of “final five-year proof.” The other was to commute: pay for the land rather than wait out the term, though the law still demanded at least fourteen months of actual residence.
John Payne of Arbon took that second road. He was almost certainly the John Payne who kept one of the valley’s first stores, and his later life is told among the site’s Stories. On April 18, 1906, he had filed on 80 acres in section 26, township 11 south, range 33 east. In September 1909 the Press carried his notice of “final commutation proof,” set for October 18 before Turner at Pocatello. All four of his witnesses were from Arbon, among them James L. Payne, probably his son James Lester. The federal land records show his patent, a cash entry, issued on September 26, 1910. The site’s Stories also weigh which claim was the first homestead proved up in the valley.
Three years instead of five
On June 6, 1912, Congress shortened the term to three years, let a settler be away from the claim as much as five months a year, and made the change apply to entries already on the books. Proof now meant the settler and “two credible witnesses” showing a habitable house on the land and three years of living on it and working it.
That brought the valley’s entries of 1908 to 1910 due all at once. Through 1913 the Press printed notices of “final three year proof” week after week, and the same names turned up again and again as witnesses for one another. Lawrence Gibbons and Lorin H. Bailey held claims in the same section 3 of township 11 south. Each listed the other, both listed Hyrum D. Powell, and Powell listed them back; all three were due before Turner at Pocatello on October 8, 1913. Lorin Bailey’s family history recalls the well that his family and the Gibbonses drilled on the section line and shared. Waldemar Jensen and David T. Lusk stood for each other in notices of 1912 and 1913. Elias Horton appeared as a witness at least four times between 1910 and 1913.
Women proved up claims in their own names. Emma Jane Dawson, “formerly Emma Jane Beebe,” had filed on May 17, 1910, and her proof was set for October 6, 1913. Her patent came on May 6, 1914, and the index carries it under both names.
Charlotte and Lawrence Dawson’s patents were issued together, on October 29, 1914. The notices never say how the two were related. The site’s research notes suggest Charlotte was probably a widow from Weston whose sons included Lawrence and William.
Empty claims
The law as rewritten in 1912 also said that a settler who never moved onto the claim within six months of entry, or who left it for more than six months, could lose the land back to the government after due notice. In the Arbon cases the Press printed, it was a neighbour who started the contest.
In May 1910 Jewel Horton contested the entry that James Berry of Arbon had made on May 2, 1904, on a lot in section 30, township 10 south, range 34 east. Horton’s affidavit, as the notice put it, alleged
that said Berry died about 2 years ago at Deweyville, Utah; that he never did establish a residence or make any improvements upon the entry: that the land is in its native state; that the said Berry left no heirs known to this affiant
A hearing was called at Blackfoot for June 27, 1910. How it came out has not been found. By August 1913 the Press named a Jewell Horton, probably the same man, as justice of the peace at Arbon.
In December 1912 a Howell of Arbon contested Herman J. Kramer’s entry of May 13, 1910, in section 20 of that township. The scan garbles his given names, but he was almost certainly Leslie B. Howell. Kramer, he said, had never lived there, never built a house and never improved the land, and unless Kramer answered, the entry would be cancelled. On October 5, 1916, Howell received his own patent for 160 acres in section 20, probably on the same ground.
Byron Messinger’s contest in April 1913 was addressed “To the Unknown Heirs of James N. Heusser, Deceased.” Heusser had filed on land in the same section 30 in August 1911 and had died since; Messinger alleged that neither Heusser nor any heir had lived there. Who ended up with that land does not appear in the records found. In March 1914 Charles Higgins contested Thomas Craven’s 1912 entry on the southwest quarter of section 33, township 11 south, range 33 east, saying Craven had “wholly abandoned” it. The patent Higgins received on March 9, 1916, includes that quarter.
Onto the tax roll
The Arbon and Pauline and West Fork area histories follow those farms on from there. By February 1917 Power County had 289,968 acres of patented land, and the Press marvelled at how quickly the change had come. “It is only a few years,” it wrote, “since nearly all of this land was government land, producing only sagebrush.” Land the government held had paid nothing toward its upkeep. “These new lands are now bearing their share.”
The original article
American Falls Press, January 22, 1914, page 5. Transcribed from the page scan.
NOTICE OF PUBLICATION
Department of the Interior U. S Land Office at Blackfoot, Idaho. January 10, 1914.
Notice is hereby given that the following named settlers have filed notice of their intention to make final three year proof in support of their respective claims, and said proof will be made at the office of Theo Turner, U. S. commissioner at Pocatello, Bannock county, Idaho, on the 3rd day of March, 1914.
Charlotte Dawson, of Arbon, Idaho, who, on November 25, 1908, made homestead entry, No. 01580, for the NE¼, section 21, township 10 south, range 33 east, Boise meridian.
She names the following witnesses to prove her continuous residence upon and cultivation of said lands: Lawrence Dawson, Albert Thompson, James D. Dawson, and William E. Dawson, all of Arbon, Idaho.
Lawrence E. Dawson, of Arbon, Idaho, who, on Jan. 27, 1909, made homestead entry, No. serial 02095, for the NW¼, section 21, township 10 south, range 33 east, Boise Meridian.
He names the following witnesses to prove his continuous residence upon and cultivation of said lands: Charlotte Dawson, Albert Thompson, James D. Dawson, and William E. Dawson, all of Arbon, Idaho.
1-15—2-19 Henry W. Kiefer, Register.
Sources
- American Falls Press, September 25, 1909, page 7
- American Falls Press, May 28, 1910, page 11
- American Falls Press, October 22, 1910, page 6
- American Falls Press, October 12, 1911, page 8
- American Falls Press, December 12, 1912, page 4
- American Falls Press, December 19, 1912, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 24, 1913, page 3
- American Falls Press, August 7, 1913, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 4, 1913, page 7
- American Falls Press, January 22, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, April 30, 1914, page 11
- American Falls Press, February 22, 1917, page 1
- Act of June 6, 1912, amending the homestead laws, 37 Stat. 123
- Patent to John Payne, 1910 (BLM IDBL 0003116)
- Patent to Emma Jane Dawson (Emma Beebe), 1914 (BLM IDBL 0008194)
- Patent to Charlotte Dawson, 1914 (BLM IDBL 0001580)
- Patent to Lawrence E. Dawson, 1914 (BLM IDBL 0002095)
- Patent to Leslie B. Howell, 1916 (BLM IDBL 0013978)
- Patent to Charles Higgins, 1916 (BLM IDBL 0018326)
