Early in December 1915 the farmers of Bannock Valley, as the papers often called Arbon Valley, gave up the old track across the reservation. “The old road over the reservation to Michaud has been abandoned the last few days,” the North Arbon correspondent wrote in the American Falls Press of December 2, and the wagons had moved to “the new county road which the Bannock farmers are very proud of, it being a level road and a good one at that.” It came between the first engineered road out of the valley, built in 1908, and the first state highway and graveled road, which arrived in 1919.
The farmers had their road. Power County had a fight over the bill, one a Rockland paper named “the Arbon road controversy.”
A way out before allotment
Arbon had belonged to Oneida County until 1913. Now it was part of Power County, run from the courthouse at American Falls. Its grain went to the railroad at Michaud, between American Falls and Pocatello, and the way there lay north across the Fort Hall Reservation. The Andersen family history remembers that in 1913 a load of grain bound for Michaud or Malad spent three days on the road each way, and that nobody lived along the Michaud route to offer a house or a meal.
In those years the government was dividing reservation land into allotments for individual tribal members, and anyone who wanted a road had to get ahead of it. On December 10, 1914, the Press reported that the state would soon survey its own road through the county, explaining that the government wanted the line fixed before allotment “in order to avoid possible friction.” That road, the paper said, would give “an excellent road part of the way to Crystal and Arbon people.” On December 28 the county board parceled the county out among its commissioners and gave the Arbon and Crystal district to its chairman, Walter S. Sparks of American Falls.
Eight miles in, five miles out
County roads in 1915 were the work of Highway District No. 1, which held 76.5 percent of the county’s taxable value. Its boundary took in only part of the road across the reservation. About eight miles of the route ran inside the district; the last 5.2 miles, between the district line and the valley, ran outside it.
On April 12 the board sent Sparks to bargain with the district’s commissioners, and in May he was named to the highway commission himself. On Sunday, June 6, the road camp moved to “the old rock ford, about five miles above Bannock,” “to work on the new road leading to Crystal and Arbon.” A week later the Arbon column described what travelers were putting up with in the meantime: “The bridges on the reservation over Birch creek and Michaud are in very poor condition. Many of the bridges are out completely, which makes travel very bad, especially with loads.”
On June 14 Sparks signed for the county. Highway District No. 1 would build the outside 5.2 miles with its own tools and machinery and bill the county for labor and materials alone. The county’s resolution spelled out the hurry. The government was “now allotting” the reservation lands in Bannock valley, and once the allotments were made, no permission for a highway would be given. Without the road, the people of Arbon or Bannock valley “would have no means of egress or ingress,” and the way across the reservation “would be closed for all times.”
Rockland gets the bill
The district’s bill came to $4,554.08. By then the county had a second highway district, No. 2, created by Rockland-area voters on June 22. The county auditor took the road debts of the county lying outside District No. 1, this bill among them, split them by taxable value and charged 66 percent to the new district. Its commissioners protested to the county board on October 13. Even the Press conceded that the charge could be fought, since steps toward the Rockland district had begun before the deal with District No. 1 was settled, and the road would do Rockland no good.
The board ruled that County Attorney Spencer L. Baird could not represent it, because his law partner, Ben W. Davis, was counsel for District No. 2, and it hired the firm of Bissell & Baum instead. On October 22 it entered in its minutes, nunc pro tunc (“now for then”), a July 12 resolution approving the contract, which it said had been left out by mistake. It ordered the bill paid in $200 warrants, each marked “Highway District No. 1, road work, Bannock Creek.”
Nine commissioners and seven attorneys
Rockland made sport of the whole business. On November 11 the Press reprinted a paragraph from the Rockland Times:
The Highway District law doesn’t seem to be working out very satisfactorily in Power County. At the present time we have nine commissioners and seven attorneys, (including the three additional attorneys employed as special counsel in the Arbon road controversy) to look after what could very easily be handled by three commissioners and one attorney. Of course, we expect to have a lot of fun, but it’s going to cost money.
Six days later Baird filed five appeals to the district court, and the Press carried them on its front page on November 18. Four concerned the road. The one the paper thought mattered most to taxpayers went after the warrants themselves. Baird argued that no contract had ever been made, that the board had no legal power to make one, that its resolution about the contract falsified the records, and that Sparks had sat on both boards that made it. The Press pointed out that the April and July minutes said nothing of the arrangement, and left the facts and the law to the judge.
Three years later
The road the farmers took to in December was probably the one built under the contract, though the papers read here do not trace its route, and they do not say what the Bannock Creek families living on the reservation thought of it. No report of the court’s ruling has turned up either.
The only word on how it ended came in August 1918, when the road apparently surfaced again in a hearing against the lawyer O. R. Baum. The Press editor, Barber, wrote then that the quarrel had cost him his partner. He had chosen to defend commissioners Sparks, M. E. Walker and C. F. Eggers against charges of bad intent, and within weeks John R. Jones was paid $2,000 for his interest and retired. Barber granted “irregularities in the making of the contract,” but said that when Baird’s appeals were tried, “the court sustained every contention the Press made in behalf of the commissioners, the decision commending the board for its apparent desire to do the right thing.”
By then the wagons from Bannock Valley had been rolling over the level new county road for nearly three years.
The original article
American Falls Press, November 18, 1915, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
COUNTY ATTORNEY BAIRD APPEALS AGAINST COMMISSIONERS.
Papers In Five Actions Filed and Cases Will Be Heard in Court
County Attorney Baird filed five appeals from actions taken by the board of county commissioners, late yesterday with Auditor Bulfinch. The most important of them, and the only one that will materially affect any part of the taxpayers, relates to the issuance of warrants approximating $4,600, which the commissioners issued at their last meeting in favor of Highway District No. 1, in payment for the building of that part of the Bannock valley road lying without Highway District No. 1.
Another appeal is against the action taken by the board in employing the law firm of Bissell & Baum in a threatened action by Highway District No. 2 against the apportionment of the cost of the construction of the part of the Bannock valley road lying without Highway District No. 1. The appeal filed by County Attorney Baird will obviate the necessity of this threatened suit, as the legal points at issue will all be involved in the action brought by Mr. Baird. A third appeal lies against the approval of the fee accounts of Auditor Bulfinch and the Sheriff, Jeffries, made at the last meeting of the board. This is a technical case only. When O. R. Baum was county attorney he gave an opinion to Auditor Bulfinch to the effect that no filing fee was required in cases brought by the county, as it was public business. Mr. Baird held otherwise when the matter was put up to him. The money has since all been collected and turned into the treasury, but it was not collected when the quarterly report for July, August and September was made up at the close of the quarter. The Jeffries case is [illegible].
One of the other actions is aimed at the resolution passed by the board of commissioners justifying the employment of special counsel in the highway warrant matter. The latter appeal is against the resolution put on the records of the September meeting of the board relating to the contract entered into by the county with the highway district for the construction of the Bannock valley road. Attorney Baird pleads that no contract was ever entered into and that the commissioners could not legally make such a contract.
The cases involve points of law and of fact, and the proper place for their determination is in the district court.
Sources
- American Falls Press, December 10, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 11, 1915, page 7
- American Falls Press, April 22, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, May 13, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 10, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 30, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 28, 1915, page 6
- American Falls Press, November 11, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, November 18, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 25, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 2, 1915, page 3
- American Falls Press, August 9, 1918, page 2
