Nobody ever voted John Payne into office as mayor of Arbon. The American Falls Press simply handed him the job. He had come to the courthouse on business on Saturday, October 23, 1915, and when the paper noted the visit it called him “John Paine, mayor of Arbon,” a post it said he had filled so long that it belonged to him “by right of continuous and beneficial use.” Nobody challenged him for it; “he does not have to defend the title.”
It was a joke, but a friendly one, about a man the paper counted among the oldest settlers in the Arbon country. Over the two years that followed, its columns filled in the rest of the man.
His full name was John Henry Payne, and in 1916 the Press wrote of him as John one week and Jack the next. The site’s Stories section calls him an English-born railroad man. He was married to Emily, a daughter of George Arbon, whose name went first to the post office and later to the whole valley. The Paynes ran one of the valley’s first stores, and in 1911 travelers put up at the Payne hotel. Their son, James Lester Payne, married into the Davis family.
A justice on the Republican ticket
The mayoralty was make-believe, but Payne did hold a genuine office. Until 1913 the Arbon area had belonged to Oneida County; now it lay in the new Power County, governed from American Falls. In December 1915 the North Central Arbon column reported “Justice of the Peace, John Payne,” home from business at the county seat, and said he was “coming out on the Republican ticket” for county commissioner at the next primary.
Front-page news from the valley
He was in American Falls again on May 31, 1916, and talked with the paper about home. His visit led the front page the following day under the heading “Arbon Activities.” The Press said he had filed on his homestead twenty-two years before, among the very first in the valley, and had lived to see nearly all of it broken to the plow. He had watched the county itself grow up, too. He had run an engine while the Oregon Short Line was being built, remembered American Falls in its early days, and had put in better than thirty-two years with that railroad, starting as a section hand and finishing as an engineer.
“Arbon is moving right ahead,” he told the paper. The farmers had nearly finished plowing for fall grain, the frost had done little harm, the grain looked well, and the valley could use a bit more rain. He carried his neighbors’ news as well: farms changing hands, a new addition on L. B. Evans’s house, J. R. Bailey’s first trip in a new Dodge, and the burning of W. A. Nunnelley’s sawmill with some 16,000 feet of lumber, a loss told in the Stories section.
The twenty-two years do not fit the records. Counting back from 1916 lands on about 1894, the year Ren Evans made the earliest dated land claim in a valley not yet surveyed. The land-office registers on the Arbon family page show Payne’s first entry as a desert-land claim in section 23 on May 3, 1901, and in 1909 the Press gave notice that he would make final proof on a homestead entered in April 1906. By November 1917 he was telling the paper he had farmed there twenty-one years, which would mean about 1896. No 1894 filing of his has turned up, and the papers never account for the gap.
Trustee for a family in need
On Monday, July 10, 1916, Payne spoke for the Lowery family of Arbon Valley before the county commissioners. The board “acted favorably on the representation made by Mr. Payne,” the Press wrote, “and granted a monthly allowance of $12.00.” Its proceedings declared Mrs. Oliver Lowery and her family “indigent and in destitute circumstances” and directed that a $12 warrant go each month to John Payne of Arbon, as her trustee. How long the payments lasted, the papers checked for this story do not say.
A race that never reached the ballot
That same July 20 issue printed his formal announcement as a candidate for commissioner from the third district, to be decided by Republican voters at the September primary. On August 31 the Press said he would “make the race,” calling him “a pioneer” who “has many friends throughout the county who will be glad to give him a boost.”
Yet when the paper published the abstract of the September 5 primary on September 14, Payne’s name was missing. G. A. Brahmstadt of Arbon stood alone as the Republican for the third district, and nothing in the papers explains why his name was left off. In January 1917 Brahmstadt took his seat as the first county commissioner from the valley.
Wheat and lumber
Payne had other work to fill his days. In June 1916 a valley column noted that “Jack Payne moved his engine up to his sawmill” and expected to begin cutting soon, one of the valley’s sawmills. When Mrs. E. A. Logan wrote her history of Bannock Valley for the Press in March 1917, she listed him among the railroaders who had turned grain growers with success: “John Payne, an old engineer, has made good here, owning a good farm and a good saw mill in Knox canyon.”
That November the paper’s traveling correspondent, who signed himself “the Pilgrim,” came by after threshing. Payne had taken off roughly 2,500 bushels, all dry-farmed. His 100 acres of Turkey Red averaged 18 bushels to the acre and was selling at $1.69 to $1.72 a bushel, while his smaller plantings of Odessa and Bluestem had yielded better. Not once in twenty-one years of farming there, he said, had the valley lost a crop outright. The Pilgrim agreed that yields had sometimes dropped “almost reaching the total minus point,” but never so far that the farmers ran short of flour before a better harvest, and he summed up his host as “an optimist” who looked ahead rather than “wasting energy in deploring conditions that have passed into oblivion.”
The last years
The county board approved his bond as justice of the peace for Arbon precinct in January 1919. Some time after that he left the valley. He died in December 1924, and a coroner’s jury found that he had shot Mrs. Martha Tuttle and then himself, as recorded among the valley’s tragedies. His son, James L. Payne of Arbon, told the jury he had never known his father to own a gun.
The Press had made him mayor in jest. The jobs he truly held were humbler and more useful: justice of the peace for his precinct, trustee for a family in want and, for one summer, a pioneer seeking a seat on the county board.
The original article
American Falls Press, June 1, 1916, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
ARBON ACTIVITIES.
Nunnelly Mill Burned With Considerable Loss—Real Estate Sales.
John Payne was here from Arbon yesterday, bringing accounts of many activities there. Mr. Payne filed on his homestead there twenty-two years ago, one of the very first made in the valley, and has had the satisfaction of seeing almost the entire valley put under cultivation. He has, for that matter, seen the entire county develop, having been on an engine during the construction of the Oregon Short Line, and is familiar with the early days of American Falls. He worked for the Short Line for more than thirty-two years, beginning as a section hand and working up to engineer.
Arbon is moving right ahead, according to Mr. Payne. Nearly all the farmers are through with their plowing for fall grain. A little more rain would be welcomed. Frost has done little damage there and grain is looking well.
Among recent real estate transfers of importance, he said, were the sale of the Parley Bailey place to his brother Willard, and the D. P. Roderick place to Mrs. S. Kennedy.
L. B. Evans is building a fine addition to his house. Mr. Evans is, like Mr. Payne, one of the pioneers.
J. R. Bailey, another pioneer, has fallen a victim to the automobile fever and is driving a Dodge. He made his first drive to Wellsville, Utah, where he attended Decoration day services.
W. A. Nunnelly’s sawmill was recently destroyed by fire. About 16,000 feet of lumber was burned.
Sources
- American Falls Press, September 18, 1909, page 3
- American Falls Press, October 28, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, December 23, 1915, page 7
- American Falls Press, June 1, 1916, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 22, 1916, page 8
- American Falls Press, July 13, 1916, page 5
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1916, page 4
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1916, page 8
- American Falls Press, August 31, 1916, page 2
- American Falls Press, September 14, 1916, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, page 7
- American Falls Press, November 13, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, January 24, 1919, page 9
- Deseret News, December 16, 1924, page 2
