The signs started where the road entered Bull Canyon from the east. The first promised the picnic grounds a short way ahead. A little farther on, another said “Three Miles.” At an old sawmill site, with sawdust still heaped where the saws had run for months, a board offered “Hay for Sale.” Then came “Wrong Road,” and finally “No, Here It Is.” A few steps over the brink, the visitors were on the grounds.
The committee’s joke greeted everyone who came to the three-day picnic the Washington people of Arbon Valley held in June 1916, in Bull Canyon at the Summit end of the valley. Until that year the settlers from Washington had kept the celebration mostly to themselves. This time they asked the whole county.
A newspaper mailed to Dayton
As far as the papers show, it began with one copy of the American Falls Press. On April 17, 1909, the paper gave its front page to a feature on the Arbon valley, which then lay in Oneida County. Paul Ellis of Aberdeen sent his copy to R. E. Smith of Dayton, a wheat town in southeastern Washington near Walla Walla.
Smith came to see for himself. On May 19 he and two other Dayton men filed on homesteads in Section 11 of Township 12 South, Range 33 East, about eight miles south of Arbon, and the Press of May 22 carried his verdict. “We find the country better than we expected,” he said. “It looks mighty good to a Washington man to find level land.” More Dayton people would be coming, he promised, “as soon as we get home.” The land office list on that page gave the three as Isaac S. Broyles, Roy F. Payne and Ray E. Smith. In October Mrs. Mima Johnson of Dayton took up the last quarter of the section.
The Daytonites
Others followed over the next several years, from Dayton and elsewhere in eastern Washington. In September 1914 five railroad cars of settlers’ goods reached American Falls from Endicott and Farmington, in the Palouse wheat country, and Tracy Lee, John Farrington and others went on with them to the Arbon country, by then part of the new Power County, formed in 1913. Late in March 1915 Tom Donnelly and two more Dayton men unloaded two carloads of livestock and farm machinery. Donnelly planned a stock ranch, and the Press noted that the Donnelly brothers already had many friends in the valley, a good share of them old Dayton acquaintances. The Arbon correspondent counted “quite a settlement of Washington people here.”
The valley columns of 1915 followed the newcomers one by one. Jack Folsom brought his bride from Dayton to settle. The Hatley and John Bryant families set out overland from Washington late in May with their stock and household goods. A Mr. Fletcher of Dayton bought Clarence Barrett’s homestead, while Mrs. Fletcher stayed with her parents, Mr. and Mrs. Phil Hatfield. Thomas Zimmerman of Dayton bought the S. Randall place, a full section, and in November the father and family of Leslie Gosney arrived from Dayton to stay. When the South Arbon boys took the ball field, they played as the “Daytonites.”
The group already had a picnic tradition. In July 1915 the South Arbon column mentioned their “annual picnic” in a canyon whose name the scan has garbled, and a week later it described a picnic “given by the Washington people”: more than seventy grown people, crowds of children, a program, and ice cream, candy and lemonade. The two notices may describe the same day.
Not every story ended well. In February 1916 Ben Messinger, one of the Dayton homesteaders, was found dead of gas in a rooming house in Ogden, and his body went home to Dayton for burial. His death is told among the site’s Stories.
Everybody invited
On June 8, 1916, the Press put the coming picnic on its front page. The Washington settlers would gather in Bull Canyon on the 15th, 16th and 17th, it said, and they invited “all other residents of the county.” The paper reckoned that “probably fifty families, formerly from the state of Washington, have located practically in a body, in the Arbon valley,” with another group across the mountains at the head of Rockland Valley, and it believed Power County had more people from Washington than from any other state. A Washington society would probably be organized at the gathering. The canyon itself, with good water and shade, was “a sheltered nook little affected by winds.”
The picnic actually opened a day late, on Friday morning, June 16, and ran until Sunday evening. Guests came from the head of the Rockland valley, from Holbrook, Sheep Creek and Cache Valley, from Pauline and from Crystal. John Bryant’s family, overland travelers the summer before, came over from Crystal for it.
A dance platform went up, and Mrs. Lee Van Horn lent her piano for the Saturday afternoon program. P. W. Lee kept a stand with hot lunches, and E. H. Davis sold confections and drinks at another. Horse races, ball games and dances filled the days, and camps lined the groves and hillsides.
The one mishap came on Saturday morning, when a ball struck Emmett Lee over the eye and opened a deep cut. Dr. Schlitz of American Falls, “a former Washington man himself,” happened to be on the grounds and closed it with a couple of stitches. It hurt, but it was not serious. Marshal Johnson and Mr. Zimmerman of American Falls also came out, partly on business and partly to visit old Washington friends. On Saturday night the dance at Central Hall drew a big crowd, many of them picnic visitors, and it went on until morning.
The Arbon column of June 22 said the “big Washington Society picnic” had “come and gone,” and that many guests were tired for a few hours afterward. Whether the society was ever formally organized, or the picnic held again, the papers found so far do not tell.
The Dayton names kept turning up. A week after the picnic, Roy K. Smith sold his ranch to “a Mr. Zimmerman from Dayton, Washington,” for $4,000. And in 1924, when the Press reported the burial of John Messinger, “an old timer of Dayton, Washington,” it noted that the old residents of Dayton and its neighborhood knew him, “many of them living at present in Power county.” The paper did not say whether he was kin to Ben. Fifteen years after one mailed newspaper, Dayton had a sizable piece of itself living in Power County.
The original article
American Falls Press, June 22, 1916, page 8. Transcribed from the page scan.
ARBON ITEMS.
Charles Allard who has been attending the Idaho Technical college at Pocatello, is home for vacation.
Thelma Rust of Pocatello is here visiting during the summer months.
Mr. and Mrs. W. A. Nunnelley went over into the Lost River country on a fishing trip.
Roy Smith and Mr. Lindquist motored to Lava Hot Springs the other day on a pleasure trip.
The ball game this last Sunday between Pauline and Center went 28 to 33 in favor of the Center boys.
Dr. Schlitz of American Falls was out during the week to be on hand at the Washington picnic. Dr. Schlitz is a former Washington man himself.
Mr. and Mrs. Herman Noth are in American Falls visiting for an extended time.
Clifford Gerkins who has been residing on a relative’s farm near West Fork, recently lost a valuable mare. It is believed to have been poisoned by a poison weed. Lou Reese also lost a fine horse in the same manner.
Miss Yenna Bullock is visiting relatives in Pocatello.
Wm. Allard made a business trip to Pocatello the other day.
Elgin Johnson, nephew of Mrs. Julius Abler, is visiting here.
Mr. Kowallis of Pauline has purchased a new Dodge car.
The dance held at Central Hall Saturday evening, June 17, was largely attended and a fine time was enjoyed by all until morning. Many visitors attended who had come over for the Washington picnic.
Miss Jane Cairns is visiting in Malad, Idaho.
Marshal Johnson and Mr. Zimmerman of American Falls were in Arbon on business the latter part of the week, also to chat with old friends, from Washington at the picnic.
Dan Roderick and family have moved to Malad, Idaho, [illegible]
Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence Gibbons are visiting with Mrs. Gibbons’ parents near Albion.
The big Washington Society picnic held in Bull canyon has come and gone. Many were rtied for a few hours after the expiration of the picnic, but they all feel that they had a splendid and joyous time. Many families from Washington have moved into the Arbon valley and vicinity the past few years of which there is a large settlement. The washingtonians formerly have celebrated alone, that is those in the valley and whoever wished to attend, but this year they decided to renew old acquaintances and invited everybody from far and near. Many came over from the head of the Rockland velley, Holbrook, Sheep Creek, Cache Valley, Pauline and Crystal and other near places. It was a three-day picnic this year commencing Friday morning, June 16th and ending Sunday evening. A nice place was selected in Bull canyon for the event. A platform was erected for dancing and a nice program was rendered Saturday afternoon. Mrs. Lee Van Horn kindly loaned her piano for the occasion. P. W. Lee had a stand where hot lunches were served which was greatly appreciated by the hungry, also E. H. Davis had a stand where confections and other good things to eat and drink could be had. Horse races, ball games and dancing were the amusements for those in attendance. The hill sides and groves were lined with camping parties and everyone enjoyed themselves immensely. The committee in charge of this great event and all others should be highly praised for their good work and from the large attendance it shows the committee have worked both in advertising and also signs that those who entered Bull canyon from the east were confronted. The first sign read. “[illegible] Mile to Picnic Grounds.” of course the parties thought they would soon be there but a little ways further was a sign, “Three Miles” the next “Drive On.” Where a saw mill had been in operation for several months and much sawdust was piled up, was a “Hay for Sale,” then came the “Wrong Road,” and the last sign, “No, Here It Is,” and over the brink a few steps we were on the grounds. Nothing was left undone that would make the celebration a success and visitors were greeted with cordiality. The only accident was when Emmett Lee, while playing ball Saturday morning, was hit over the eye cutting a deep gash, Dr. Schlitz who was on the ground took a couple of stitches in the wound and while quite painful the injury was not serious.
A fine social time was enjoyed by those present at the Pauline meeting house Friday evening, June 16. Refreshments were served.
The Eliason brothers recently finished the shearing of their sheep in Knox canyon.
Jack Payne moved his engine up to his sawmill and will soon commence sawing.
Joe Dawson was over to Downey a few days ago on business.
John Bryant and family came over from Crystal to attend the Washington picnic.
Hyram Powell is moving to Shelley having sold his ranch to Anderson brothers of Arbon.
Mrs. Chauncey Payne returned after an extended visit to Meridian, Utah, [illegible] She reports every thing looking fine in that part [illegible]
Bishop Kowallas and family, accompanied by W. E. Dawson and wife, motored around the valley of Arbon Sunday, taking observations of the crops and sight seeing in Mr. Kowallas Dodge car.
The ball game between the Cubs and the Pauline team was well played the score being 23 to 7 in favor of the Cubs.
Joseph Arbon has purchased the Dell Dalton house and is moving the same to his place about two miles south of the old Dalton place.
Howard Madden, our village blacksmith, is being kept busy. No time to loaf but he a hustler and a fine mechanic.
[illegible] on an extended fishing trip to Lost River country.
Mr. Turner of Arbon had the misfortune to lose one of his best horses [illegible]
E. H. Davis, our live merchant, has gone to Pocatello after another big load of merchandise for his store.
Jas. R. Bailey, our road overseer, has been out repairing the roads. They are in fine shape now.
Sources
- American Falls Press, April 17, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 16, 1909, page 3
- American Falls Press, September 17, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 1, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 29, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 24, 1915, page 8
- American Falls Press, July 8, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 15, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 16, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, September 30, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, November 11, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, February 10, 1916, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 8, 1916, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 22, 1916, page 8
- American Falls Press, June 29, 1916, page 6
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1924, page 5
