All winter a pile of sacked wheat sat out in the weather at a grain platform at Pauline, bought the fall before and still waiting for wagons. By spring the pile had become a political fight, and the Pocatello Tribune told it two ways in the space of a month.
The Pauline correspondent of the American Falls Press saw the trouble first. On March 29 the column reported “lots of grain spoiling at the Zuring platform due to stormy weather,” with sacks rotting and wheat spilling onto the ground.
Photographs for Hoover
Then the Nonpartisan League arrived. The League was a farmers’ political organization, and Ray McKaig, its field secretary, came into the valley with an organizer, C. Theuson. They stayed several days, signing up members and taking pictures of the wheat. McKaig wired Herbert Hoover, the federal Food Administrator, about the pile “near Pauline, Arbon Valley,” and the League carried the story in its own papers. Our earlier post on the Pauline wheat pile follows the League’s side, and it could hear the other side only as the League quoted it. In the Tribune that other side speaks for itself.
The Tribune first took up the matter on May 2, under the headline “Orders Grain Moved From Arbon Valley.” Its subheading put the damage on an unnamed grain agent: “Grain Agent Says Some Wheat Damaged by Exposure During Winter.” The report itself was blunt:
It is stated that approximately 20,000 bushels remained at that point throughout the winter, and without particular shelter, in consequence of which a considerable quantity of it spoiled, and had to be used for hog feed, which raised some dissention at a period when there is strong demand for the conservation of wheat. No wilful negligence is apparent in the situation.
The grain corporation of the federal Food Administration had looked into it by the middle of April, the paper said, and MacAlpine, the government’s local agent, was still on the case. In April he had gone to Zaring Brothers of American Falls, who had bought the wheat for the American Falls Milling company. Both firms told him the grain was moving as fast as the mill could take it and promised quick handling. In letters that arrived on April 22, MacAlpine “took the agencies to task,” and he had been assured that every available facility would go into moving the wheat.
The Tribune guessed that the League’s photographs were meant to sell its plan for warehouses built by the state. It printed McKaig’s telegram to Hoover and said he had sent it without knowing that government men had been at work on the pile for weeks.
“Rank fiction”
By June the paper sounded very different. The League’s Idaho Leader had run its story, and on June 3 the Tribune answered with “Arbon Grain Not Damaged in the Least.”
People in the valley, it wrote, were “naturally much incensed” at the charge. The president of the League’s own local in the valley, “a Mr. Saulsbury,” had denied it at the time. Several Power County citizens and the government grain agents had gone to see the pile for themselves, and they reported all of it in fine shape and fit to sell. Even the few sacks “sweating under the weight” could be used. The paper again put the wheat at 20,000 bushels and said it was going out as fast as it could be hauled, with the job being finished up.
The Tribune was no neutral witness. It called the League’s story propaganda aimed at “coddling the credulous,” and it reminded readers that several League officers had been indicted for disloyalty.
The two reports cannot both stand. In May a considerable quantity had spoiled and gone to the hogs; in June there had been no loss from exposure and every sack was sound. The June article never names the citizens who looked at the wheat. Nor was the hauling nearly done: on August 13 the Press reported that Fred Hochbaum had just brought “the last load of 1917 wheat from the Zaring platform at Pauline” to the Michaud siding. The rest of that summer’s grain moving is told in the 1918 wheat haul, and the valley’s long wait for storage in the first grain warehouse.
The League man from Pauline
The paper gave Mr. Saulsbury neither a first name nor initials. He was most likely H. M. Saulsbury of Pauline, whose name was also spelled Saulsberry. That April Mrs. H. M. Saulsbury sold Liberty bonds for Pauline, and in May H. M. Saulsbury gave a talk at the Red Cross war-fund night at the Arbon Central school. Later glimpses of him appear in H. M. Saulsberry of Pauline. The Press of April 30 seems to mention a Nonpartisan meeting at the Central school, though the scanned text is damaged there.
If he is the right man, the League had a local in the valley led by a Pauline man, and by the Tribune’s telling he publicly rejected the charge his own field secretary had wired to Hoover. The League did not lose Pauline over the quarrel. Two years later Pauline voted the League ticket.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, June 3, 1918, page 2. Transcribed from the page scan. The printer’s spellings “McHaig” (for McKaig), “Thuesoh” (for Theuson), “repudited,” “sttement,” “demonstration,” “sitizens” and “us” (for “as”) are kept as printed.
ARBON GRAIN NOT DAMAGED IN THE LEAST
Report by Nonpartisan Organ Shown Up as Rank Fiction.
A short time ago a couple of representatives of the Non-Partisan league, which is operating extensively and endeavoring to build a third political party in Idaho during war times, and working on the bases of playing on what may be construed us a sort of sentiment interesting to farmers, on the public warehouse plan—built at public expense—drifted over into the Arbon valley to spread the propaganda.
As chronicled at the time the two representatives, Messrs McHaig and Thuesoh, organizers, took a number of photos of what was represented as grain that had been ruined by careless exposure to the elements, the theory of the careful photographing, of course, being an argument to reinforce the agitation in favor of state construction of warehouses for storage.
The people of the Arbon valley section were naturally much incensed at the statement of the Non-Partisan factors, and the president of the local over in that basin, a Mr. Saulsbury repudited the sttement at the time. The organizers in the meantime sought all sorts of publicity on the matter, and even wired Food Administrator Hoover and others, and after all affairs were checked up, and as intimated at the time the government agents in this section had full knowledge of the grain supply, which was estimated at 20,000 bushels, and several investigations demonstration that there was no wastage because of exposure and the stored quantity was being hauled as quickly as possible, and is being finished up at the present time.
For the purpose of furthering the Non-Partisan league propaganda, the official league organ, the Idaho Leader, carried a story inspired to induce farmers to believe that the grain had been neglected and permitted to rot for the purpose of coddling the credulous into fathering the partisan ideas of the Non-Partisan league, several officers of which have been indicted for disloyalty.
With this in mind, and taking the rather vigorous statement of the president of the Non-Partisan unit of Arbon valley, in repudiation of the charge, several sitizens of Power county made a personal investigation as did the government grain agents, and the assertion that thousands of bushels of grain had been ruined because of neglect is shown up as incorrect, and the statement of the Non-Partisan league organizers is not borne out. The grain was all found in fine shape and marketable, and even the few sacks naturally sweating under the weight were found usable.
The story as presented by the league organ had no basic foundation save for the purpose of questionable propaganda on a political basis, and the claims as presented are denied by Arbon valley people, as well as by fully competent authority that investigated the situation before the organizers found a theme for agitation.
