The diamond at Arbon lay under about six inches of dust on the Sunday that American Falls came out to play, and by the end of the afternoon the official scorekeeper had blamed it for every one of the seventeen errors and fourteen of the runs. American Falls beat the Arbon Bears 21 to 5 that day in June 1921, in the most colorful game of a few summers when the valley’s neighborhoods kept ball teams of their own.
Pauline had a team, Arbon had its Bears, and South Arbon had its Cubs. The weekly American Falls Press, the paper of the Power County seat, followed their games with one another and with the American Falls town nine. The valley had been part of Power County since 1913, and of Oneida County before that.
Pauline at the Natatorium
The first of those reports came on Sunday, June 12, 1921, when Pauline took on American Falls at the Natatorium grounds in town. Pauline scored twice in the first inning and was even at three runs apiece in the third, but four late runs carried American Falls to the win. The final score is too unclear on the digitized page to read with confidence. The Press had warm words for the visitors’ pitcher:
Dave Lusk pitched well for the Pauline team. His control was the best seen on the local diamond this year. He lacked speed but made up for the lack of it with his superb control.
He was probably David Thomas Lusk of Pauline, then thirty-two. His family’s history remembers him and his brother Park as Pauline ballplayers, both known for their athletic ability.
Ball games for an oil well
Less than two weeks later the valley invited its neighbors out to celebrate its first oil test, on Thomas S. Toyn’s ranch six miles south and a mile east of the Pauline store. The program promised a ball game on Saturday, June 25, and on Sunday a game between American Falls and Saturday’s winners.
The account of Saturday is hard to untangle. Pauline played the Arbon Bears, and there was another game with “the Daniels team.” “Pauline annexed the last game three to two in a ninth inning rally,” the report said. “The Cubs had been taken into camp with a comfortable margin of victory.” It never says who won the first game or who the Cubs were that day, nor why it was the Arbon Bears, and not Pauline, who faced American Falls on Sunday.
Benching the umpire
G. M. Oliver, the official scorekeeper, wrote up Sunday’s game for the Press from the American Falls side and played it for laughs. “Everything possible to see in a baseball game was seen at Arbon Sunday,” he began. He counted twenty-six runs, twenty-four hits, seventeen errors and twenty-five or thirty overthrows. The dust, he wrote, raised a “smoke screen” around the base runners, “much to the sorrow of the opposition and the umpire.”
The umpire was Lee French, the county auditor, and he “satisfied everybody until the fifth inning.” Then an Arbon player sent a ball down the first-base line. The Arbon captain said it was fair. French, “whose eyes were full of dust,” ruled it foul. Ordinarily the player would have gone to the bench, Oliver explained, but Arbon had nobody to spare, and some 500 spectators along the sidelines had been calling the game all afternoon anyway. So French was benched and one of them got a turn.
Johnson pitched for Arbon and was “touched for 19 hits.” Lund, pitching for American Falls, gave up only five. The paper listed the Bears by surname and initial alone: Van Horn, Phelps, Payne, E. Lee, T. Lee, King, Donnelly, Johnson, Hardman and Isaac. Elsewhere in the same issue the editors got in a joke of their own: “As a baseball umpire, Lee French is a very efficient county auditor. Ask the boys at Pauline.”
Pie for the team
In February 1922 the Pauline correspondent wrote that “the pie dance given for the benefit of the baseball team” had been a success, with an extra large crowd, “each lady bringing a pie.” In June the Arbon column told how “the Cubs of South Arbon played the Pauline baseball boys,” and Pauline won 18 to 17.
That summer American Falls put on its first big Fourth of July celebration in years. Pauline was set to play Ross Fork, the agency town on the Fort Hall Reservation, on July 3, with the winner to meet American Falls on the Fourth. The Press called the visiting teams “reported the strongest they have been for several seasons.” No result from July 3 was printed, but it was Pauline that took the field on the holiday, and the day belonged to the home team: “The ball game between American Falls and Pauline resulted in a burlesque in favor of the Falls.” No score appeared. Afterward the Arbon column noted that a large crowd from South Arbon had spent the Fourth at Malad, “while all from Pauline went to American Falls.”
A batter hurt at Central
On Sunday, August 20, 1922, the team from Juniper, “near Holbrook,” came to play Pauline at Central, the school and store neighborhood at Arbon. In the second inning a pitch struck the Juniper batter, John Retmaster, on the back of the head. He made it about halfway to first base, grew dizzy and soon collapsed unconscious. He was carried to the home of Mr. and Mrs. T. B. Evans, and a physician was called from Pocatello. At about 8:30, after he had rallied a little, he was taken to the hospital there. On Monday morning Mrs. Evans, the valley’s telephone operator, had word that he was much better. The name Retmaster turns up in no other report found, so its spelling cannot be checked.
“The spirit of the game was lost after this accident,” the report said. The game was “recalled,” and Juniper won 9 to 4.
A track meet in 1924
The teams were still at it two years later. In March 1924 the school news from Crystal reported a baseball meeting at Mr. Dickerson’s, and the Pauline items announced “a party for the baseball boys next Friday.” On Sunday, May 18, Pauline met American Falls once more and lost 25 to 3. The game, said the Press, “was turned into a track meet shortly after the first inning opened.”
The papers kept the scores, the crowds and the surnames, but little else about the men who played. Most of their full names are not recorded in the pages found, and neither is the outcome of that first Saturday game in June 1921. What the record keeps best is the dust.
The original article
American Falls Press, July 1, 1921, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
Twenty Six Runs, 24 Hits, 17 Errors, 30 Overthrows, 25 Underthrows, and Benching of Umpire C. Lee French Feature Remarkable Game at Arbon Sunday.
By G. M. Oliver, Official Score Keeper.
Everything possible to see in a baseball game was seen at Arbon Sunday when American Falls beat the Arbon Bears 21 to 5. Here’s the features:
Twenty-six runs.
Twenty-four hits.
Seventeen Errors.
Twenty-five or 30 overthrows and about that many underthrows benched.
The diamond was covered with about six inches of dust and this aided the base runners by throwing up a “smoke screen” around them, much to the sorrow of the opposition and the umpire, especially the the umps.
Umpire French Benched
The dust also served as an alibi for the fielders when they made an error, so we have charged all of the errors and 14 runs to the dust in the official averages.
Lee French started the game as umpire and satisfied everybody until the fifth inning. Here’s where the dust enters again. An Arbon player knocked a ball down the first base line. The Arbon captain claimed it was a fair ball but Lee, whose eyes were full of dust, thought otherwise and called it fowl.
The usual procedure in a case of this kind is the player to be benched but Arbon didn’t have any extra players and there were about 500 people on the sidelines who had been trying to umpire so Lee was benched and one of them given a chance.
Johnson Pitched
Johnson, pitching for Arbon, fouled 11 American Falls men but was touched for 19 hits which coupled with errors and overthrows put Arbon out of the running early.
Lund, pitching for the locals, was very expective and with any support would have held Arbon to two runs. He fouled eight men and allowed five hits, three of them of the scratch variety.
An Effective Trio
Reed, P. Evans and Barnard lead in hitting, getting three apiece and scoring ten runs.
Lund and Stitt played the best [illegible] game, Stitt also getting 1000 per cent in umpire [illegible] during the latter part of the game.
American Falls has no game scheduled for July 4.
The teams lined up as follows:
The Arbon Bears—Van Horn cf. Phelps 2b, Payne lf and 3b, E. Lee c, T. Lee 1b. King 3b, Donnelly rf, Johnson p, Hardman ss, Isaac lf.
American Falls—Hooker ss, Reed 1b, G. Evans cf, P. Evans 3b, Lund p, Davis lf, Stitt c, Barnard 2b, Martens rf. Umpire French (for five innings).
Sources
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 24, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 1, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 1, 1921, page 6
- American Falls Press, February 24, 1922, page 7
- American Falls Press, June 15, 1922, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 29, 1922, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 29, 1922, page 7
- American Falls Press, July 6, 1922, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 13, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, August 24, 1922, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1924, page 1
