Ren Evans came down to American Falls on business on Wednesday, April 2, 1924, carrying a petition. On it, twenty-three Arbon Valley farmers had promised a year’s milk from 213 cows to a cheese factory that did not yet exist. The next morning the American Falls Press put his news on its front page: “Arbon valley is soon to have a cheese factory,” and it might be running within a month.
Evans reckoned he had signed “about half the cows in the community.” The money behind the venture belonged to Ernest Brog of Driggs, in the Teton Basin of eastern Idaho. The factory would be an independent concern, and Brog had said he would come into the district on the strength of the farmers’ promises. As the Press put it, “The price to be received for the cream will be based on the actual price of cheese.”
Cheese was not new to the valley. Family histories on this site recall homestead wives who made it in their own kitchens, Martha Daniels, wife of John Moroni Daniels, among them. Near Pauline, Maggie Bolingbroke’s cheese won her husband Charles the nickname “the cheese man” (the Bolingbroke family). The new idea in 1924 was a plant that would buy the valley’s milk and turn it into cheese on a commercial scale.
A winter of cheese factories
The valley was not alone in wanting one. Rockland, in the next valley to the west, had opened Power County’s only cheese factory at the end of 1923. In March a Pocatello report in the Press counted new factories going up across southeastern Idaho at “an average of one factory per week,” and said the Kraft company’s Pocatello plant would open on June 1.
Arbon’s own effort had begun in January. On the 24th the Salt Lake Tribune printed word from Pocatello that people of the Arbon Valley section were “enthusiastic over the prospects of a cheese factory.” That Saturday afternoon a meeting at Pauline, at the valley’s north end, would count how many cows could be had, with help from members of the Pocatello real estate board and farm bureau men from Bannock and Power counties. “Bishop L. B. Evans of Arbon” had gone to Pocatello on Monday to set it up. He was Lorenzo B. “Ren” Evans, among the first homesteaders in the valley and then bishop of the Arbon Ward (Lorenzo Bowen Evans and Anna Morse, and more in the Evans family).
No full account of that meeting has turned up, but the brief state-news columns carried by Idaho weeklies soon had the story. In early February the Oakley Herald wrote that “Citizens of Arbon valley are contemplating the establishment of a cheese factory, provided sufficient cows can be signed,” and that the Pocatello real estate men and the county farm bureau were “back of the venture.” The Rathdrum Tribune said residents had “signed up 300 cows for a cheese factory.” The Caldwell Tribune gave it a single line from Pauline: “Arbon valley cheese factory is organized.” On February 28 the Press, under the heading “A Potential Dairying Community,” reported Rockland’s factory taking in 3,000 pounds of milk a day and said a second one was “in process of organization in the Arbon valley.”
Machinery by summer
Evans’s petition brought the plan into focus in April. A week after his visit, on April 10, the Press reported that Brog expected to ship his machinery to the valley before the month was out, so the plant could be producing by early summer. Committeemen were still taking contracts, and about 200 cows were expected to be signed. “Arbon valley farmers are uniting in their support of the project,” the paper said. On April 16 a statewide roundup of industrial news in the Challis Messenger listed the valley too: “Arbon—Establishment of a cheese factory here is assured.”
The cow counts never quite matched. February’s report said 300, Evans’s petition held 213 from twenty-three farmers, and a week later the figure expected was about 200. None of the papers explained the difference.
Brog was most likely the Swiss-born cheesemaker Ernest Brog (1896–1985). His obituary, as transcribed on Find a Grave, says he made Swiss cheese in Wisconsin after reaching America and then moved west to Freedom, Wyoming, in Star Valley, and it credits him with pioneering Swiss cheese in the western United States. His wife, Martha Kaufman, was from Driggs. Whether he ever worked in Arbon Valley is not yet known.
Then silence
After April 16 the papers stop talking about it. Searchable pages of the Press from late May to early October 1924 say nothing of an Arbon factory, and the other papers searched are just as quiet. Some weeks of the Press, mid-April to mid-May and mid-July to mid-September, could not be searched, and only some pages of other issues could, so a report may still surface. Until one does, no one can say whether the factory was built, where it stood or whether it made a single cheese.
One July item hints at what the valley’s farmers would have faced. Early that month the Press reported a meeting at Rockland where dairymen pressed a Kraft Cheese Company field man about their milk checks, and he blamed “the great decline in prices of cheese.” That was Rockland, not Arbon. But under the April terms, Arbon cream was to be paid for by the price of cheese.
The original article
American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
CHEESE FACTORY
L. B. Evans Reports Twenty Three Farmers Signed to Agreement Owning 213 Cows Which Will Supply Milk—Ernest Brog of Driggs Behind Factory.
Arbon valley is soon to have a cheese factory. It may be operating within the next month according to L. B. Evans, who was in the city Wednesday on business. Evans recently circulated a petition among the farmers of the community asking them to agree to sell their milk to the factory for one year and signed up twenty three farmers who promised milk, in support of the factory from 213 cows. Evans estimates that he has signed up about half the cows in the community for the factory.
Ernest Brog of Driggs, Idaho, is back of the factory which will be an Independent concern and says that he will come into the district on the promises and agreements given him. The price to be received for the cream will be based on the actual price of cheese.
Sources
- Oakley Herald, January 4, 1924, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 24, 1924, page 3
- Oakley Herald, February 8, 1924, page 4
- Rathdrum Tribune, February 8, 1924, page 4
- Caldwell Tribune, February 12, 1924, page 6
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 3, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 10, 1924, page 1
- Challis Messenger, April 16, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 3, 1924, page 1
- Find a Grave, Ernest Brog (1896–1985), with his obituary from the Star Valley Independent
