High up in Crystal, the homestead settlement in a basin of springs and creeks, a winter storm could leave a farmer with a car and no road home. So the families there kept a garage together. When drifts closed the last miles to their places, a man could drive as far as the road stayed open, lock the car inside and go on some other way. On January 4, 1935, somebody broke into that garage and took the tires.
The Pocatello Tribune is the only paper found that describes the building, and it says little beyond its purpose. It does not tell where the garage stood, which road it served, who built it or when, or how the farmers covered the rest of the distance. Other reports show why Crystal needed it. In December 1923 the settlement’s schoolchildren wrote that the place would be almost deserted that winter, and in February 1949 a Rattlesnake rancher skied nine miles toward McCammon to telephone from Garden Creek Gap that his neighbors were running low on supplies. The shared garage was one answer to that isolation once the valley had cars to protect.
Ten tires and four wheels
The loss, as the Tribune tallied it, came to ten tires with their inner tubes and four wheels: a pair from trucks and a pair from cars, the car wheels still carrying their tires. Officers had been on the case since the day of the break-in, and three agencies took part: the Pocatello police, the Bannock County sheriff’s office, and Power County Sheriff “Buck” Davis, since Crystal lay in his county.
On Thursday, January 24, the paper reported three men under arrest and nearly all of the goods back in hand. Only one wheel and one tire were still gone. The men were Floyd Sandusky; William Cutshalts, 22; and Sammy McDowell, 23. Sandusky and McDowell were living in Pocatello, the paper said. Sandusky and Cutshalts were charged with the burglary itself. McDowell was charged as an accessory, which the next day’s paper explained as keeping the stolen property. Officers said he had been holding most of it and hunting for a buyer. Two of the men sat in the Power County jail at American Falls.
One arrest was made in Arbon Valley, though the Tribune could not keep straight whose. Its January 24 report put McDowell’s arrest in the valley; its January 25 report gave that arrest to Cutshalts, and which is right is not known.
The follow-up on January 25 had more. Pocatello officers had picked up Sandusky on the 24th and handed him to Power County, where his bond stood at $3,000. McDowell was free on $500, set in Probate Judge W. W. Howard’s court in Power County. Nothing was said of Cutshalts’s case. The paper also cleared a fourth man. A day earlier it had reported that officers suspected a man who had just pleaded guilty to petit larceny in a justice court, over a watch, of a hand in the tire theft. Now his charge had been dismissed, and officers said he had nothing to do with it.
A jury at American Falls
Sandusky went to trial in district court at American Falls, and a jury there found him guilty of first-degree burglary for the Arbon Valley tire theft, the Salt Lake Telegram reported in a short dispatch on March 8, 1935. A codefendant named William had already pleaded guilty. The machine-read text of the dispatch garbles his surname, but he was almost surely William Cutshalts, the only William in the case. Judge Isaac McDougall had not yet sentenced either man.
What sentences they received has not been found, nor whether the last wheel and tire ever turned up. None of the three men is known to have had ties to the valley, and the papers never named the Crystal farmers who lost their tires.
Thieving in winter did not end with them. Nineteen years later, in 1954, Arbon and Crystal ranchers banded together under the Power County sheriff to watch over their places through the cold months.