Harry Hill found the young man lying in his wheat. The stranger had red hair, and in late May of 1937 that was enough to bring two county sheriffs out to Pauline, at the north end of Arbon Valley.
Bannock County officers were looking for a red-headed man that week. Patrick J. McCarthy had been gone for close to two weeks. His car had been found near Downey, in Bannock County, soaked with blood, and a witness said a man with red hair had walked away from it. The Tribune gave the night of May 20 in one place and May 19 in another. Bannock County Sheriff Maurice J. Rossiter wanted to find that man and question him, and the paper did not shy from saying the case might prove to be murder. Reports of red-haired men came in to his office almost hourly. One placed such a man at DuBois, another near the stockyards at McCammon, another at a road camp at Swan Lake, and several had already fallen apart when deputies looked into them.
A rumor at Pauline
On Thursday, May 27, the hunt turned toward Pauline. By the time the story reached town it had grown: the red-haired man, people were saying, lay dead in a grain field. Power County Sheriff L. E. “Buck” Davis set that straight. He met Rossiter where the road enters Arbon Valley, and the two sheriffs rode on to Pauline together.
There they heard it from the farmers themselves. Nels Wimmett had taken the young man on as a hand in his fields, and one day the hand simply walked off without telling him. Not long after, Hill came across him stretched out among the wheat on the Hill farm. Asked where he had spent the last 24 hours, the youth gave answers that were hazy and evasive, and Hill called in Sheriff Davis.
The farmer the paper called Harry Hill was very probably Thomas Harry (T. H.) Hill, a Moline, Kansas, man who had homesteaded on the Arbon floor in the 1910s and in 1927 bought the Burge ranch about a mile south of Pauline. The 1937 story gives no initials, so the match rests on the name and the place. Wimmett turns up in no other record this site has found, and his name may be spelled as the paper had it. The Hills are among the families in the land records on the Arbon area page, and Pauline’s people are described on the Pauline and West Fork page.
Too young by a decade
Age settled it. Wimmett put the stranger at 21. The man wanted in the McCarthy case was believed to be between 30 and 35, so after a brief look around the officers gave it up. Rossiter’s judgment was that the youth was only a drifter who had eaten a meal at the Wimmett place and moved on. Nobody printed his name, and nothing read for this post tells whether anyone ever saw him again.
The sheriff who made that call may have known the ground well. In 1914 a Maurice J. Rossiter of Crystal gave notice that he would prove up on a homestead there, and in 1917 the American Falls Press described the oats, wheat and barley he grew on 160 acres up Cherry Creek, three and a half miles northeast of Crystal. The full name and middle initial are the same as the sheriff’s, but no source read here says they were one man, so the link is likely rather than certain.
Back to Downey
The Tribune carried the Pauline trip on Friday, May 28, inside its front-page story on the McCarthy case, where it was only one lead among many. By Friday Rossiter was counting on Tim Murtaugh, a friend of the missing man, whom he described as “probably the only person who knows the name” of the red-head. A few weeks before, the sheriff said, Murtaugh, McCarthy and the red-haired man had made a trip together to McCall. Murtaugh, though, had left a week ahead of the disappearance to prospect for ore in the Salmon River country, and Lemhi County Sheriff T. J. Stroud was trying to track him down.
Meanwhile Bannock County deputies Dave McNichols and Bert Empey went back once more to the place they believed McCarthy had died, in his own car, on May 19. How the case ended lies beyond the pages read for this post. At Pauline, the wheat went on growing, and the young man with red hair went on down the road.