In the fall of 1938, a stranger in a car with Washington plates stopped at Ben Lusk’s home at Arbon with good news: Lusk’s name had come up in a drawing. The first prize was small, a mattress. The second was not. Lusk, the man said, was one of five people in all of Idaho picked for a grand prize: a piece of land in the southeastern part of the state and a check for $35 every month for the rest of his life.
There was just one thing to settle first. The title on the land had to be cleared before it could be handed over, the salesman explained, and that would cost $88.50 in cash. Lusk paid it.
The salesman was E. H. King, and he had a companion with him on the call. The mattress, he said, came from a drawing at the Blackfoot district fair.
The neighbor’s story
Some time later Lusk got to talking with a neighbor and found that he had not been the only lucky man in the valley. King had paid the neighbor a visit too, told him the same tale and collected the same $88.50, though this time by check. The Pocatello Tribune spelled the neighbor’s name as “Jonney Bodenbrook.” Two days later the Sunday paper had it right: John Bolingbroke, also of Arbon.
Picked up in Pocatello
Power County officers already wanted King. Their complaint was that he had been selling Idaho land without an Idaho broker’s license. On Thursday, October 6, Pocatello police found him and turned him over to the county. The man traveling with him was let go. The Tribune had the arrest the next day, Friday, October 7, in a short unheadlined item among the local notes of its “Around Town” column.
By Sunday, Lusk had his money back. Chief of Detectives Guy Nelson told the Sunday Tribune-Journal so on October 9, and on Tuesday the Tribune added that payment on the second farmer’s check had been stopped. Power County then released King. The papers give no reason, and nothing shows whether the charge was ever pursued. King’s car was still sitting in Pocatello, and he came back to get it.
Only after he was free did a telegram arrive from the chief of police in Seattle. King, it said, had been selling real estate at the Island Lake Park Country club outside that city along with a man named R. E. Hagglund, and the chief understood that Spokane was looking for King as well. Nelson said the two men had been at work around Pocatello for some time, staying at one of the town’s hotels. When Pocatello police questioned Hagglund, he told them the land promotion was his firm and King was on his payroll.
A third winner at Lava
The Arbon men were not the only ones chosen. On October 11 the Tribune reported that J. A. Roswell of Lava Hot Springs had gone to Detective Nelson with his own visit from King. He too had been told he was one of five Idaho winners from a recent contest, and King let him believe the drawing had been held at the Eastern Idaho district fair. Roswell pointed out that he had never set foot in the Blackfoot fair. King’s only answer was that the Seattle office had sent him the list with Roswell’s name on it.
Roswell heard more of the scheme than anyone at Arbon had. The final payment on the land, he told Nelson, would come to $295. After that he would have to go to Seattle to close the deal, and there he could pick either $600 in cash or the $35 a month for life. That report gave the salesman’s initials as E. L. and named his firm as the Island Lake Park Development company of Seattle.
Where King went next, and whether Spokane ever caught up with him, has not turned up in any later paper read for this site.
The two families
The papers say nothing more of Ben Lusk than his name and that he lived at Arbon. He was probably Benjamin Wilkes “Ben” Lusk, born at Malad in 1904, the oldest son of Perry and Blanch Lusk, who ranched on the West Fork at the north end of the valley, as told in Pauline and West Fork. Ben made the Pauline school’s list for perfect attendance in 1916, and in March 1922 the American Falls Press noted that he and Eph Bolingbroke had returned to school in Malad after a few days home with their families at Pauline. He is the only Ben Lusk in the valley records this site holds, though nothing in the 1938 papers confirms it is the same man. The Lusk family accounts disagree on when Perry’s family left the West Fork ranch for Bonanza Bar on the Snake River, whether about 1935 or not until the reservation purchase of 1939. Perry himself served the county, as told in Perry Lusk and T. B. Evans on the Power County board.
The neighbor came from the Bolingbroke family, whose home ranch was also at the north end. The two families were tied by marriage, since Henry M. Bolingbroke’s wife, Mary Elizabeth, was a Lusk, probably Perry’s sister. There were two John Bolingbrokes in the valley that fall: John Henry, 63 and still ranching at Pauline, and his son John Jr., then in his early twenties. The papers do not say which one King called on.
Whichever it was, he got his money back. For two neighbors at the north end of Arbon Valley, the grand prize ended up costing nothing at all.