Decades before anyone settled in the valley now called Arbon, a long train of wagons and carriages came down a narrow ridge into it. At the head of the company was Brigham Young. It was the spring of 1857, the place was still Bannock Valley, and the travelers were bound for Fort Limhi, the Latter-day Saint mission on the Salmon River (the name is now spelled Lemhi).
Two accounts of that journey reached print the same year, one by a member of the party and one in Young’s own words. They are the earliest printed descriptions of the valley found so far.
A strong escort
The first account, by a traveler who signed no name, ran in the Deseret News of June 10, 1857. The copy read here is its reprint in “The Bannock Stake of Zion,” Andrew Jenson’s history in the Deseret Weekly of March 28, 1891. The digitized text of that page is rough, and this story keeps to what can be read with confidence.
Jenson wrote that Young went north with “a strong escort.” Young, Heber C. Kimball, Daniel H. Wells, Orson Hyde, Franklin D. Richards and several others set out from Salt Lake City on a Friday in April, and Lorenzo Snow fell in with them at Brigham City. Their purpose was to call on the Salmon River settlement and “to examine the intermediate country.” They organized at the Bear River ferry. How many men went cannot be made out in the digitized copy, but the company also counted 22 women and 5 boys, 54 wagons and carriages, and two light boats with decking planks for crossing rivers.
There was no Idaho yet. Jenson describes the trip as a visit to the Saints “in Oregon,” and the table of distances printed with the account marks the “Utah and Oregon line” on the way north.
Over the rim
From Bear River the company traveled up Malad Valley to the point where the Hudspeth Cutoff of the California road crossed it. There the wagons left the emigrant road for the fresh track the Salmon River missionaries had broken on their own way to Limhi. It rose gently to the northwest for some six miles to the summit of the Great Basin’s northern rim, the divide between the streams that run to the Great Salt Lake and those that find the Snake River. On the far side the way down was “rather rapid,” along the top of a narrow spur ridge and into Bannock Valley.
The writer found a valley running a little west of north that “averages about four miles wide.” It was “tolerably well grassed” and “very sparsely timbered,” though the rough copy leaves it unclear whether the qualifier “in some portions” goes with the grass or with the timber. The Basin rim and its spurs closed it in on the east and a rugged range on the west. At its north end it gave way to a plain the travelers named Shanghi Plain, “the greatest desert region surrounding the Three Buttes.”
Bannock Creek, in the writer’s words, was “a small stream with a sluggish current,” with a scattering of small willows, birch and alder along its banks. Farther down another fork came in, and the creek ran across the plain in a banked channel to the Snake, about three miles below the mouth of the Portneuf. Past the mouth of the valley the road struck out over the plain, joined the emigrant road to Oregon some six miles from Fort Hall, and followed it across the Portneuf toward the company’s ferry on the Snake.
Just where the company camped in Bannock Valley, neither account says. The table of distances names the summit of the Basin, a first crossing of the Bannock, a camp, the right fork of the Bannock and the Bannock bench, but its figures cannot be read in the digitized copy. The site’s history of the Arbon area puts Young’s camp at the springs north of Andersen Lane, below the old trail called Rocky Ridge, and the printed accounts neither confirm nor rule that out. They also leave open whether the missionaries’ track was the same trail as Rocky Ridge, which the site counts as the valley’s first road.
A great gulf
The company reached Fort Limhi on a Friday evening early in May, spent four and a half days there, and was away from home 33 days in all. On the whole the writer judged the road good. Among its few hard stretches the account names the northern slope of the Basin rim, the very descent into Bannock Valley.
Malad Valley, the writer concluded, was “much the best locality for settlement” anywhere on the route past Bear River. The rest of the country the company saw beyond Malad was “of but little worth save to answer the purpose of connecting territory which might otherwise be separated by a great gulf.”
In Brigham Young’s words
Young gave his own account on Sunday, May 31, 1857, a few days after the company got home, speaking in the Bowery in Great Salt Lake City. His remarks survive in the Journal of Discourses, the published collection of church sermons, rather than in a newspaper. The company had left on the morning of April 24, he said, and been gone “one month and two days,” covering 763 miles. The printed text spells the valley’s name Bannack:
Malad Valley, north of Bear River, has been considered a pretty desolate, cold, hard, sterile valley; it was so looked upon by us, as we passed through it on our way North. ... But after we had travelled over the Basin rim into Bannack Valley, descending a mountain, beside which the one we call the Big Mountain is a mole hill, down through the little Bannack Valley on to Shanghi Plain ...
The Big Mountain he measured it against was the high summit on the pioneer road east of Salt Lake City. The plain’s name, Young said, was the company’s own: “It is a vast, desert plain, and we called it Shanghi Plain.” And when they “returned again to Malad Valley” on the way home, “It looked to us like one of the most beautiful valleys that any person had ever beheld.”
The Arbon area history tells of that change of heart about Malad Valley as hearsay, opening with “Rumor has it.” Young’s printed remarks show the rumor was true. The history of Pauline and West Fork tells more of the valley before the homesteaders came.
The mission the company had traveled so far to see lasted less than another year. In March 1858, after word came to abandon Fort Limhi, a small party riding south was fired on from ambush on Bannock Creek, and Bailey Lake was killed, as told in the Stories. For the next several decades the valley Young had crossed remained what his traveling companion had called it, country that mostly joined one place to another.
The original article
The digitized copy of the 1891 page is too rough to transcribe word for word. The passages that can be read with confidence are quoted in the story above, and the page itself is linked under Sources.